Talk

Advanced search

Holocaust denial - sorry if sensitive. Shocked....

(17 Posts)
theluckiest Wed 01-Feb-17 20:52:20

Know this isn't a recent issue but know there's a film out soon on this subject so it's reared its ugly head...

I am just utterly shocked that this is even a thing. How can it be? Just listening to Mark Kermode talking about the new film 'Denial' - I just cannot believe that a major, catastrophic historical event still in living memory (just about) with many, many witnesses; victims, eyewitnesses and perpetrators; physical and photographic evidence can even be remotely questioned...

I know that history often throws up questions about evidence and reliability but the perpetrators of this particular genocide actually kept meticulous and detailed records of what they did.

I've just had the misfortune to stumble across some horrendously anti-Semitic website and the reasons for Holocaust denial would be laughable if they weren't so horrifying.

I am genuinely utterly baffled by the deniers. I'm not even really sure why I'm posting - I'm just shocked. Appalled. How easily history can be manipulated by ignorance and racism... sad

CornetBlues Wed 01-Feb-17 21:03:16

I know what you mean. I am 50 and grew up with hushed mention of local men I knew who had been involved in liberating Belsen. I now tell my children and also tell them of those who seek to minimise or even deny what happened. The eldest has watched The World at War on DVD and the documentary Shoah.

BillSykesDog Fri 03-Feb-17 16:43:58

There's a really good article in BBC History mag this month from one of the expert witnesses. He talks about their surprise and horror as they discovered how Irving had falsified his evidence. His name's Richard J Evans and he has a book 'Telling Lies About Hitler' telling it in more detail which I intend to buy.

Met David Irving once. Really creepy man.

CoolCarrie Tue 14-Feb-17 19:02:20

I would like to see the film as all the three lead actors are excellent and will be taking our son to see it as well. It is so important that we, and our children,and their children, never forget the evil that humans can do, and to know of the bravery of so many, the SOE, for example who gave their lives for our freedom.

AyeAmarok Tue 14-Feb-17 19:05:29

I have been meaning to watch this film.

I know what you mean OP, I just cannot understand how people can deny it.

IrenetheQuaint Tue 14-Feb-17 19:08:16

Neverunderestimate the human capacity for racism and self-deception.

Telling Lies About Hitler is a fantastic book.

Anasnake Tue 14-Feb-17 19:08:57

When I was at uni a holocaust survivor came to speak to us. He lost his wife and child but told us how he had been called a liar to his face. I've been to Auschwitz, you can't deny it. Shameful.

CoolCarrie Tue 14-Feb-17 19:10:56

It is totally bizarre to be think that it couldn't be true, I trust the memories of Richard Dimbilbey over a nutter like Irving

MyBeloved Tue 14-Feb-17 19:14:46

Shockingly, books about Holocaust denial are easily bought on amazon for as little as 99p.

There really are no words to adequately describe how I feel about how I feel about deniers.

FrancisCrawford Sun 12-Mar-17 07:44:40

It is shocking.

But one of many denials of atrocities.

The British Government refused to offially acknowledge the Soviet massacre of over 22,000 Polish officers in the Katyn Forest in 1940 for decades and even tried to block efforts by Poles in this country to erect a memorial.

CoolCarrie Sun 12-Mar-17 10:45:27

That is shocking FrancisCrawford, when you think how many Poles, Czechs and many others came to the UK to help fight it is a disgrace that massacre was covered up.

FrancisCrawford Sun 12-Mar-17 11:03:58

It was political, CoolCarrie.

The massacre is still not widely known about outside of Poland and Polish communities.

When the London memorial was unveiled there was not a single British Government representative (although some MPs attended in a private capacity)

alltouchedout Sun 12-Mar-17 11:09:46

I recently read Anton Gill's The Journey Back From Hell. It's no surprise, really, that holocaust denial is so common, when even in the immediate aftermath so many people just didn't want to know. To read the stories of survivors who talk about the way no one would hear them, the way no one seemed to care... it's frightening.

daisychain01 Sun 12-Mar-17 11:15:47

It will become even more of a trend when the remaining holocaust survivors/witnesses and family members pass away and there are no voices there to describe the reality and say I saw it with my own eyes.

I'm going to see the Denial film next Wednesday. I am heartened and proud that our little local cinema (converted from an old theatre) is choosing to show the film 3 times a day for several days.

I saw Schindler's List when it came out and the horror still lives with me all these years later. So I'm going next week, knowing full well it will rip me to shreds. But go we all must. Thanks for this thread.

CoolCarrie Sun 12-Mar-17 21:12:06

Thank goodness Steven Spielberg and many others are preserving the memories of survivors and the liberators for the future.

AutumnalLeaves38 Sun 12-Mar-17 21:42:27

One of the most pivotal moments in my childhood, which still sends icy chills down my spine, was (at age 8) noticing faded tattoo marks along the arm of my Grandmother's visiting Czech friend, Ada, as her discreet sleeve slipped down.

It led to an open discussion, age-appropriate and factual, but very honest. And obviously very upsetting for us all. Learning about the Kindertransport etc., and being given a copy of Anne Frank's diary to read when old enough, having met a real, live, camp survivor, impacted on me in a very major way.

I've always been utterly sickened by Holocaust (or any other atrocity) denial, in the face of legitimate evidence and witness testimony angry

CoolCarrie Mon 13-Mar-17 06:14:21

My grandparents neighbour in the 1950s was a survivor, she only spoke about it to my grandparents as my grandfather had been in the RAF, and the lady was very grateful to the UK for giving her a home. My mum used to go through to light fires, heat food etc for the lady on the sabbath.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now