My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Get updates on how your baby develops, your body changes, and what you can expect during each week of your pregnancy by signing up to the Mumsnet Pregnancy Newsletters.

Childbirth

if it were men who gave birth....discuss!

25 replies

lucykate · 29/01/2006 17:18

well, i'm sure maternity leave would be longer and better paid for starters!

OP posts:
Report
FairyMum · 29/01/2006 17:26

Never mind mat leave, men would introduce pregnancy-leave and perhaps even TTC-leave.

Report
CarolinaMoon · 29/01/2006 17:28

midwifery would be extremely well-paid .

Report
SoupDragon · 29/01/2006 17:28

There'd be a lot of only children in this world.

Report
Rhubarb · 29/01/2006 17:29

And we'd never hear the last of it!

Report
madmarchhare · 29/01/2006 17:29

There wouldnt be as many people.

Report
Rhubarb · 29/01/2006 17:35

Population would shoot down and there would be a hell of a lot more contraception out there.

Report
lucykate · 29/01/2006 17:40

all births would be an elective c-section

OP posts:
Report
LadyTophamHatt · 29/01/2006 17:42

they'd get really baggy japs-eyes!

Report
LadyTophamHatt · 29/01/2006 17:42

they'd get really baggy japs-eyes!

Report
WigWamBam · 29/01/2006 17:42

They'd soon manage to delegate it to the women ...

Report
megandsoph · 29/01/2006 17:50

all I will say is heheheheh hahaha can u imagine??

Report
hornbag · 29/01/2006 18:08

they wouldn't move off the sofa for the 9 months of pregnancy

Report
Blandmum · 29/01/2006 18:13

The human race would have died out because I don't think that they would ever do it twice!

Report
motherinferior · 29/01/2006 18:29

There would be some seriously good contraception out there.

Report
WigWamBam · 29/01/2006 18:31

But it would probably still have to be taken by the woman.

Report
spursmum · 29/01/2006 18:34

It would be compulsory to have an epidural the moment contractions started.

Report
Blandmum · 29/01/2006 18:35

Not quite the same, but along similar lines

If men could menstruate by Gloria Steinham

A white minority of the world has spent centuries conning us into thinking that a white skin makes people superior - even though the only thing it really does is make the more subject to ultraviolet rays and to wrinkles. Male human beings have built whole cultures around the idea that penis envy is "natural" to women - though having such an unprotected organ might be said to make men vulnerable, and the power to give birth makes womb envy at least as logical.
In short, the characteristics of the powerful, whatever they may be, are thought to be better than the characteristics of the powerless - and logic has nothing to do with it.
What would happen, for instance, if suddenly, magically, men could menstruate and women could not?
The answer is clear - menstruation would become an enviable, boast-worthy, masculine event:
Men would brag about how long and how much.
Boys would mark the onset of menses, that longed-for proof of manhood, with religious ritual and stag parties.
Congress would fund a National Institute of Dysmenorrhea to help stamp out monthly discomforts.
Sanitary supplies would be federally funded and free. (Of course, some men would still pay for the prestige of commercial brands such as John Wayne Tampons, Muhammad Ali's Rope-a-dope Pads, Joe Namath Jock Shields - "For Those Light Bachelor Days," and Robert "Baretta" Blake Maxi-Pads.)
Military men, right-wing politicians, and religious fundamentalists would cite menstruation ("men-struation") as proof that only men could serve in the Army ("you have to give blood to take blood"), occupy political office ("can women be aggressive without that steadfast cycle governed by the planet Mars?"), be priest and ministers ("how could a woman give her blood for our sins?") or rabbis ("without the monthly loss of impurities, women remain unclean").
Male radicals, left-wing politicians, mystics, however, would insist that women are equal, just different, and that any woman could enter their ranks if she were willing to self-inflict a major wound every month ("you MUST give blood for the revolution"), recognize the preeminence of menstrual issues, or subordinate her selfness to all men in their Cycle of Enlightenment. Street guys would brag ("I'm a three pad man") or answer praise from a buddy ("Man, you lookin' good!") by giving fives and saying, "Yeah, man, I'm on the rag!" TV shows would treat the subject at length. ("Happy Days": Richie and Potsie try to convince Fonzie that he is still "The Fonz," though he has missed two periods in a row.) So would newspapers. (SHARK SCARE THREATENS MENSTRUATING MEN. JUDGE CITES MONTHLY STRESS IN PARDONING RAPIST.) And movies. (Newman and Redford in "Blood Brothers"!)
Men would convince women that intercourse was more pleasurable at "that time of the month." Lesbians would be said to fear blood and therefore life itself - though probably only because they needed a good menstruating man.
Of course, male intellectuals would offer the most moral and logical arguments. How could a woman master any discipline that demanded a sense of time, space, mathematics, or measurement, for instance, without that in-built gift for measuring the cycles of the moon and planets - and thus for measuring anything at all? In the rarefied fields of philosophy and religion, could women compensate for missing the rhythm of the universe? Or for their lack of symbolic death-and-resurrection every month?
Liberal males in every field would try to be kind: the fact that "these people" have no gift for measuring life or connecting to the universe, the liberals would explain, should be punishment enough.
And how would women be trained to react? One can imagine traditional women agreeing to all arguments with a staunch and smiling masochism. ("The ERA would force housewives to wound themselves every month": Phyllis Schlafly. "Your husband's blood is as sacred as that of Jesus - and so sexy, too!": Marabel Morgan.) Reformers and Queen Bees would try to imitate men, and pretend to have a monthly cycle. All feminists would explain endlessly that men, too, needed to be liberated from the false idea of Martian aggressiveness, just as women needed to escape the bonds of menses envy. Radical feminist would add that the oppression of the nonmenstrual was the pattern for all other oppressions ("Vampires were our first freedom fighters!") Cultural feminists would develop a bloodless imagery in art and literature. Socialist feminists would insist that only under capitalism would men be able to monopolize menstrual blood . . . .
In fact, if men could menstruate, the power justifications could probably go on forever.
If we let them.

Report
WigWamBam · 29/01/2006 18:35

It would probably be compulsory to have an epidural from the moment the pregnancy was confirmed!

Report
WigWamBam · 29/01/2006 18:36

And scientists would spend millions developing a cure for morning sickness, which would be reclassified as a serious illness.

Report
lockets · 29/01/2006 18:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

corblimeymadam · 30/01/2006 10:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

beatie · 30/01/2006 10:58

They'd sit around with their friends afterwards telling exaggerated storues about the event.

"And the head was this big."

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

TheRealDeal · 28/07/2011 04:57

I men gave birth society would be a commensalist-utilitarian democracy, with emphasis on labour value for those that have children (not the opposite scenario we see today).

Just to note, if there is anyone on dadsnet 'laughing their ass off' at the idea of women giving birth...I will break their legs. Truly.

Report
sunshinestate · 28/07/2011 05:06

If men gave birth more modern forms of pain relief would have been found. In the 1970s my mum was offered epidural/gas and air/pethadine. Fast forward to now and that is still all that is available. If men were giving birth I guarantee there would be more/better options available.

Report
Tortoiseonthehalfshell · 28/07/2011 05:08

Okay, RealDeal, I'm reporting now. This is a five and a half year old post. This is ridiculous.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.