Advanced search

Mumsnetters aren't necessarily qualified to help if your child is unwell. If you need professional help, please see our mental health webguide

"it's all my fault" said by 4 y/o

(6 Posts)
GreenGoth89 Mon 06-Jun-16 21:13:54

My 4 year old DSS keeps saying that he's worried about himself/me/DP and saying that anything that goes wrong is his fault. He's crying a lot - whenever anyone at home says no (haven't asked nursery) or not right now. He's normally quite happy although any talk of mummy results in tears (he's resident with us and rarely speaks or sees her). I'm a bit worried about it, and his endless energy, lack of concentration, and not understanding "owch" or stop - although he has a good use of language. Am I fretting over nothing? He did witness a lot of violence when he was younger and no therapy or assistance has been offered, but I'm worried things are deep seated :/

BusStopBetty Mon 06-Jun-16 21:26:13

Do you think it would be worth a chat with the health visitor and a referral to play therapy or similar?

GreenGoth89 Mon 06-Jun-16 22:26:18

We did ask for this before we moved and we were referred for parenting classes instead! But it might be worth us trying here again.

RatherBeIndoors Mon 06-Jun-16 22:37:18

Margot Sunderland (child development expert, esp in early trauma effects) has written a series of books for children that it might be useful to look at together? There's one about anxiety, and about fear of loss, and about bottling up feelings. I agree with PP about asking for help, but any extra work you can do around helping your DSS express his emotions could be good - we used Mr Men to identify when feeling worried/angry/etc at that sort of age...

GreenGoth89 Tue 07-Jun-16 10:34:14

He is good at expressing his emotions and I've been trying to do mindfulness with him to stop the tantrums when we say no (which I think is going to be a long term project) but I don't think he understands why he lives with us and not his mum - and tbh, it's a difficult thing for an adult to come to terms with, not being able to live with someone you love because they put their violent partner first and their poor state of mental health means they are only just managing to look after themselves let alone anyone else. He's incredibly affectionate and not very clingy - he's happy to go spend time with our friends and nursery, he makes friends easily, gets very excited when my DM comes to stay (she lived with us for 6 months and sees him more than his actual grannies) but he does get very upset when he talks about his mum and this being worried stuff is worrying me. Do I just encourage him to talk? I have no idea what to even say other than mummy is busy right now and that why she hasn't been to see you in weeks. What can I say?

RatherBeIndoors Tue 07-Jun-16 11:41:32

I wonder whether it's worth asking on the Adoption board, as people there often have experience of helping young children process information about birth parents who made challenging choices. One option used is to create an "All About Me" lifestory book, in an age-appropriate way, about their current and past life (if you google Joy Rees there is some good advice and examples of how to create these books). In those books, and in training given to foster carers and adopters about talking about tough experiences to children, sometimes we're advised to talk about what a child needs (food, drink, cuddles, play, comfort, safety...) and that all children need all those things. That it was very sad that mum wasn't able to give you all those things, and you weren't safe. Sometimes we don't know why people find that hard, but they do. Sometimes people are a kind of poorly, which makes it hard for them. But children need to be safe, and that's why you live here with us, and you can talk about mum whenever you need to... You don't need to have all the answers, but just be age-appropriate honest. It's OK to say you don't know, but that you know it's really hard for him. You can validate his feelings about it "It's OK to find it really hard to understand, and to sometimes feel sad, or angry or upset about it." Caro Archer's "Parenting the child who hurts" is also good for games and activities to help a hurting child grow in a new relationship.

Children who have experienced neglect/trauma are often much younger emotionally than their biological age, so can need lots more help managing their feelings. In the situation you describe, it's also common for the child to have a deep need to control, because they have experienced the fear of being in a situation out of their control, with violence and helplessness. That can be why "no" is so very hard for them to cope with, and sometimes needs to be presented differently. Clearly, you will still enforce your chosen boundaries, but sometimes using controlled choices helps - instead of "It's time to stop playing and get dressed", you can try "Do you want to put on your trousers or your t-shirt first?" The theory is that they get to use their control, but you still get the task done. Also used in "Would you like to walk or scoot to the shop?" rather than "We need to go to the shop now."

You say he is "incredibly affectionate and not very clingy" - indiscriminately affectionate to people he doesn't know very well, would you say? Because that potentially sounds like disordered attachment to me, which would be totally understandable based on his early life. A learned behaviour to form quick bonds with lots of people, because he cannot rely on the ones who should be keeping him safe. Clearly that might be way off as I'm a stranger on the internet, but it is a waving flag, and I really think your HV or GP should be listening to you more.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now