Talk

Advanced search

Astrid or Clara

(35 Posts)
Zaya71 Sat 25-Feb-17 18:07:00

I love both... Currently completely torn between the two!

Thoughts?!

Niks2026 Sat 25-Feb-17 18:13:02

Clara is pretty. Astrid is more unusual and sounds quite harsh.

ninnypoo Sat 25-Feb-17 18:15:55

I used to love Astrid until The Office (US) where they completely ruined that name just by switching two letters (if it's not obvious then I don't want to ruin the name for you too!)

Definitely Clara.

Longdistance Sat 25-Feb-17 18:17:46

Clara. Fabulous name, that belongs to fabulous people grin

Rockaby Sat 25-Feb-17 18:28:02

Clara by miles for me. I have an irrational hatred of the name Astrid and think Clara is lovely.

Sugarpiehoneyeye Sat 25-Feb-17 18:48:06

Clara.

Obsidian77 Sat 25-Feb-17 18:56:50

Much prefer Clara though I suppose it depends on your surname.

emsyj37 Sat 25-Feb-17 19:03:41

Astrid for me - I like Clara too, but Astrid is beautiful. We planned to call DD2 Astrid but my DMum hated the name so we chose something else in the end. I still love it tho. Clara is becoming quite popular now, if that matters to you.
Interestingly, when I was on here musing over possible names for DD2, the name Astrid got almost universal gushing praise!

CaipirinhasAllRound Sat 25-Feb-17 19:15:57

Love them both. Work as 1st and middle names together both ways too

AlwaysTheWinner Sat 25-Feb-17 19:18:50

I really like them both, but I like Clara best.

reallybadidea Sat 25-Feb-17 19:21:04

I love Astrid. If I ever had another girl I'd definitely use it.

MarjorySunshineDust Sat 25-Feb-17 19:22:19

Astrid! Not keen on Clara.

OvO Sat 25-Feb-17 19:22:45

Both are fabulous but I think Astrid just pips Clara for me.

FirstSeemItThenBeIt Sat 25-Feb-17 19:25:02

Astrid by many many miles

geordiedench Sat 25-Feb-17 19:30:13

Clara. It's one of my favourite names for girls. But I think Clara Astrid is great - why not use both?

Rockaby Sat 25-Feb-17 19:31:55

Astrid / Ass-turd though... it is a wee bit like Ass-turd, is it not? Just me then! As you were grin.

Peanut14 Sat 25-Feb-17 19:32:06

Clara flowers

MrsMarigold Sat 25-Feb-17 19:42:28

Clara. Astrid is horrid.

RiaOverTheRainbow Sat 25-Feb-17 19:56:46

I like Astrid a lot, I find Clara a bit meh.

JanuaryJuniper Sat 25-Feb-17 20:13:05

LOVE Astrid!!!

GVmama Sat 25-Feb-17 20:16:06

Clara for me too! So pretty. Although Astrid is lovely too!

aquamarina100 Sat 25-Feb-17 20:16:54

I really like Clara, I find Astrid harsh sounding.

Muddlingalongalone Sat 25-Feb-17 20:17:21

Love them both. Clara seems super popular at the moment if that concerns you?

SuperBeagle Sat 25-Feb-17 20:49:31

Clara.

I can't see the appeal of Astrid. It's very harsh and unattractive sounding.

donkey86 Sat 25-Feb-17 20:51:04

I love Astrid. It's on my list, but I suspect DH will veto - he's not keen on anything out of the ordinary.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now