Edward, Charles, Alfred or Archiebald

[ps2304]

nicknames Teddy/Ed, Charlie, Freddie or Archie

Middle name Francis

Please can you rank them. We are struggling so much with a boys name

[NeverTwerkNaked]

It's Archibald. I'd spell it right on his birth certificate if you must use it.

I like Edward and Charles

Archie and Alfie sound cute on babies but the full names are pretty awkward for grown ups to carry off

[DeathByMascara]

I'd make sure I spelt Archibald properly firstly...

Dh is Edward - so while biased I do like that one! Charlie & Archie are lovely too. Not so keen on Freddie.

[SuperBeagle]

Not Archibald. Archer is infinitely nicer if you want the nickname Archie.

Edward is my favourite. Ed/Eddie and Ned are my favourite nicknames; am not fussed at all on Ted/Teddy but I think I'm in the minority on that.

I like Charles/Charlie too.

I don't like Alfred, and think he would be more likely to get Alf?Alfie as a nickname. What about Frederick if you want Freddie? My DS2 is Frederick and has been Fred since birth.

[Thisrabbitthatrabbit]

I love Edward, DS1 should be Edward but DPs nickname made it unusable

[Mouthfulofquiz]

Charles Francis is lovely.

[ps2304]

Sorry Archibald

[MrsHathaway]

Freddie Francis is a bit ... yeah, so I wouldn't use them together. You seem set on Francis so I think Freddie is out.

Edward - I have one. He is neither Eddie nor Teddy but a different nickname. I thought I'd like and use Eddie but actually when he arrived I couldn't bear it. Weird.

Charles - another of my sons was very nearly Charles but we changed our minds very close to the due date. If he'd been early he probably would have been Charlie!

Archie is fine but trendy. Archibald is awful. Archer is very cool indeed.

So I'd rank

Archer top
Edward / Charles equally - I dislike Eddie and Charles but like Edward and Charlie.
Archie next
Freddie
Archibald dead last.

If our Edward hadn't been Edward he would have been registered Robert and known as Robin.

[strawberrypenguin]

Edward
Alfred
Charles
Archibald

[Imaginingdragonsagain]

Edward Charles Alfred - like them all. Archibald a very distant last!!

[Sugarpiehoneyeye]

Charles Francis.

[BirdsongTweets]

Agree with Mrs much prefer Archer to Archibald, Archi-bald , dont like the 'bald' bit at all.

[Ordinarily]

1. Charles
   
2. Edward
   
3. Alfred
   
4. Archibald
   

I'm going to disagree with the others and say Archer is worse than Archibald.

[sonlypuppyfat]

Archibald and Alfred are indeed rank

[Sophronia]

I like Alfred best

[EggsEleven]

I like Edward. I like Ed, Eddie or Teddy as a nn.

There are so many little Charlies, Archies, and Alfies running about I wouldn't chose any of those 3 options.

[ElvenMoonwings]

None are to my taste, apologies, but I really dislike Archibald - I don't like the bald bit - and, male people dread baldness, so I would guess that's likely to strike a really bad and sour note in the mind of a son too.

[ThroughThickAndThin01]

Charlie

[BroadcastHouse]

I like all of the full names, especially Alfred and Archer (as suggested above). Of the nicknames I like Teddy/Ed the most. Not as keen on Freddy, Alfie or Charlie, they're still nice names just slightly more over-used.

[KoalaDownUnder]

Charles (love this)
Edward

Then the other two very far behind!

[MadameJosephine]

My favourite is definitely Edward with the others way way behind

[CakeRattleandRoll]

Edward, definitely.
I do like Archie as a nn, but agree with other ops that Archer is preferable to Archibald as full name.

[ShowMeTheWayHome]

Charles would be my first choice

[MrsMeeseeks]

'Archer' sounds like someone from the Midlands pronouncing Archie.

Edward is my favourite from your list, OP.

[LarrytheCucumber]

I had a great uncle Archibald, known as Uncle Arch.
Edward is lovely.

[CPtart]

Edward every time, in it's entirety. No infantile nn. Please no more Alfies's, Archie's, Charlie's, Freddie's.