Her sister should be called...?

[Nameconfusion]

What would you call dd2 if dd1 is tabitha?

[3littlerabbits]

Kitty? Matilda?

[DogEared]

I don't know about Kitty with Tabitha...
Elena
Greta
Posy

[Allthesanityinme]

Elsie
Elspeth
Naomi
Miriam

[Allthesanityinme]

I thought Kitty at first too, then I thought perhaps too much of a cat theme

[TheonlyoneIknow]

Imogen
Phoebe
Charlotte
Lucy
Eloise
Cassandra
Florence
Amelia

[3littlerabbits]

Hmmm you might be right on the cat thing. What about Cecily? Violet?

[Nameconfusion]

Thanks everyone, please keep them coming. Am wondering about Martha or phoebe?

[QOD]

Martha is so "right now", personally I don't like it and it's high fashion. Phoebe seems more sort of popular but not in vogue

Tabitha is such a pretty name and Martha, well, it's not

[anewmotivatedme]

Miranda
Samantha
Jemima
Selina
Sophia

[hatebeak]

I don't think Martha is "High Fashion".
I've known a few little Marthas over quite a long period of time - it's not as obviously faddy as, say, Elodie, or as "fashiony" as, for example, Violet. I think it's a pretty classic name, like Anna. And I think it's beautiful. (I don't have one or anything.)
Other names with Tabitha:
Millicent
Annie
Sarah
Rosamund
Josephine
Beatrice

[StepOutOfSpring]

Cecilia
Miriam
Zara
Elodie
Aurora
Louisa
Julia
Serena
Clara

[Psammead]

Felicity.

[MoonHare]

Oooooh I LOVE the name Tabitha, it's my DD2s name.

We're expecting DC3 and on our girls shortlist are:

Eliza
Harriet
Isobel
Meredith
Ursula

Also, names I love but can't use:

Iris
Alice
Martha
Esther
Rosalind
Verity
Astrid

DD1 is Eleanor.

Have fun deciding x

[sugarspiceandallthingsnice324]

Beatrix, violet, matilda, liliann, audrey, emilia,

[CarriMarie]

Tabitha and Jemima
Tabitha and Matilda or
Tabitha and Phoebe

[AgathaPinchBottom]

Isadora, Lydia, Cecily?
... Love Martha!

[Hulababy]

I like the name Martha. I think it goes nicely.

[PrincessPinotPartyPants]

I like the matching "th" sounds in TabiTHA and MarTHa.

yes!

[out2lunch]

sylvia

[manicinsomniac]

With Tabitha, I would suggest:

Abigail, Adriana, Bethany, Charlotte, Cecilia, Delilah, Emmeline, Evelyn, Felicity, Francesca, Gabrielle, Harriet, Isabelle, Imogen, Jasmine, Juliette, Katherine, Lauren, Lucinda, Matilda, Madeleine, Miranda, Natasha, Philippa, Penelope, Rebecca, Rosanna, Samantha, Sophia, Vanessa.

[zxcv123]

The Tabithas I know have sisters called:

Natasha
Tamara
Arabella

[TheMightyMojoceratops]

Tabitha and Mabel? (Tab and Mab for short )
Tabitha and Lucy?
Tabitha and Sophie?

A two-syllable name feels more 'balanced' than a three-syllable one when paired with Tabitha.

[Geranium3]

lorna?
josephine?
polly?
genevieve?
sasha?
freya?