Advanced search

If you are born in a caul you cannot drown?

(35 Posts)
travellinghopefully12 Sun 21-Aug-16 19:47:26

Is this an irresponsible thing for parents to tell their children? DP was told this as a child, by his othrwise lovely parents and I can't quite believe it.

He grew up thinking he could swim out as far to sea as he liked.

Crispsheets Sun 21-Aug-16 19:48:31

Of course it is

Just5minswithDacre Sun 21-Aug-16 19:48:43

Hopefully they told him that death from exposure of hypothermia was still possible?

Old wives tales are plain dangerous, aren't they?

AnchorDownDeepBreath Sun 21-Aug-16 19:49:37

Of course it is, it's horrendously irresponsible.

My godmother used to tell me I couldn't drown because I'm an aquatic star sign. That was really irresponsible too. People say some really bloody stupid things without thinking through the consequences...

travellinghopefully12 Sun 21-Aug-16 19:53:05

Why do otherwise loving, sane parents say these things? Yes 5Mins, old wives tales are terrifyingly dangerous.

Whitecovers Sun 21-Aug-16 19:56:09

My grandma told me little girls float 🤔

AnnieOnnieMouse Sun 21-Aug-16 19:57:24

Gosh, I haven't heard that one in over 50 years, and even then it was known to be an old wives tale. You can see where the thought may have come from, many centuries ago, before sense and logic took hold, but once we got into the 19th century...

BennyTheBall Sun 21-Aug-16 20:03:44

I don't think people spout nonsense like this nowadays?

My mum was told her pregnancy heartburn meant the baby had lots of hair confused

TheHobbitMum Sun 21-Aug-16 20:04:47

My daughter was born en caul (also Velamentous cord insertion) and all the midwives and healthy visitors would say this. I knew not to take it literally though lol DD is a complete fish! Would happily swim from sun up to bedtime and has swam confidently since about 3 and absolutely loves water sports too. Far more of a water baby than my other 3 so the family often out it down to her being born en caul as a family tale. It's just a old wives tale and I'd hope folk wouldn't take it as truth hmm

Chottie Sun 21-Aug-16 20:06:10

My DS was born in caul and people used to tell him this too.

Centuries ago, cauls used to sold to sailors for good luck and to save them from drowning.

TheSilverChair Sun 21-Aug-16 20:06:12

My gt grandfather always carried a caul when he went to sea. He was a lifeboatman and died in his bed aged 96 in 1941.

Seamen are notoriously superstitious.

TheHobbitMum Sun 21-Aug-16 20:06:56

Forgot to say DD was also born within the amniotic say completely intact around, which is a damn good job considering the volumentous cord insertion

Alisvolatpropiis Sun 21-Aug-16 20:07:47

It's just an old wives tale.

travellinghopefully12 Sun 21-Aug-16 20:10:21

Why is there the connection between being born in a cowl and able to swim? DP was a very literal child, and is a very literal adult, so I am confused as to why his parents thought that was a good idea. Apparently they never said it again after he tried to swim to some Island off Anglesey when he was small.

Dontyoulovecalpol Sun 21-Aug-16 20:11:28

Not sure what you mean by irresponsible? Might their children genuinely believe they can't drown and fling themselves in rivers and so on?

butterfliesandzebras Sun 21-Aug-16 20:13:07

My mum was told her pregnancy heartburn meant the baby had lots of hair

Apparently that one has been proven true (to a certain extent). High amounts of the same hormones that can make heartburn more likely, also trigger more hair growth in the baby...

0hCrepe Sun 21-Aug-16 20:14:20

How weird! I was watching childbirth clips earlier (I'm 36 weeks pg and wanted to watch positive births). Anyway one said birth in caul which I had never heard of before and now it's on here! In the video the mum gave birth in a pool and baby came out really slowly and stayed under the water the whole time and for quite a while after he was completely out. I thought this could happen with all babies though until they took their own breath. So still not sure what caul is, but this baby did have something floating around!

Chippednailvarnishing Sun 21-Aug-16 20:14:45

Maybe your inlaws are particularly thick?

0hCrepe Sun 21-Aug-16 20:15:07

The heartburn thing definitely wasn't true for me! I had terrible heartburn and 2 bald babies!

travellinghopefully12 Sun 21-Aug-16 20:23:35

They're Academics, Chippednailvarnishing! (but perhaps lack some practicality?)

OhCrepe, I think it's like a green bag??

Velvetdarkness Sun 21-Aug-16 20:26:32

Ohcrepe the caul is the sac. Some babies come out still inside it.

whattheseithakasmean Sun 21-Aug-16 20:30:22

I have horses and our foal was born in the caul. How reassuring to know she won't drown, I had never heard that smile

CalebHadToSplit Sun 21-Aug-16 20:30:26

My DS was born in his sac. He has never been told that he couldn't drown, but has been told that he will be a sailor / lucky at sea. One of my in laws referred to it as a 'dry birth' which was far more accurate as no waters to lubricate his passage out!

Canyouforgiveher Sun 21-Aug-16 20:31:49

That actually isn't the correct saying as far as I know.

It is "It you are born in a caul, you won't die of drowning" which is a bit different.

I suspect they read it first in David Copperfield (David Copperfield was born in a caul), and said it to him more as a reference to that/reminding him of the fact that he had a caul than a real directive that he should go and jump in the deep end because he was incapable of drowning.

Your DH didn't drown as a kid under his neglectful parents' watch - he grew up just fine. I'd chill and maybe ask them where the saying came from.

Hassled Sun 21-Aug-16 20:32:01

But how were cauls being carried around by superstitious boatmen? I mean - how can they be preserved? Aren't they wafer-thin? Am I being really thick?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now