Advanced search

MBE for homophobe who blames hurricanes on gay people

(20 Posts)
Pangurban Sun 04-Jan-15 09:48:34

AIBU to think that whatever weight you give to an MBE, it is a state award and may give more overall credibility to the recipient in some people's view. Is it a bit iffy to give it to people who proclaim such hateful things?

If it given for a specific endeavour or achievement, should anything else be looked at? Does it provide a veneer of state sanction to the person and their opinions as a whole?

Petradreaming Sun 04-Jan-15 20:44:07

This outraged a lot of people and is an astoundingly stupid thing to have happened. Though if the press is to believed many people in the 'establishment' knew of savilles activities prior to him being knighted. It is very odd.

Chiggers Mon 05-Jan-15 08:18:46

That man needs to be educated about climate and weather. To come off with a stupid comment like that shows his lack of knowledge about weather cycles. I've come across a lot of religious homophobes, but I usually ask them "What do gays lack that makes you so perfect and so much better?" They can't normally answer that without looking stupid and up their own arse. People (not everyone) generally do judge others and when religion is thrown in there as well, it tends to make people more judgemental about other's lifestyles.

Being gay is not a choice, just like being born male/female is not a choice. Yes, acting on gay impulses is a choice, but the fundamental feelings of being gay have a natural basis. There are studies in the animal kingdom that show that male animals will demonstrate homosexual tendencies by relieving their sexual urges with other males, if there are no females in the group. This doesn't apply to all male animals, only some, but if being gay can be found in animals, then it stands to reason that the same can be applied to humans and is totally natural.

People should be rewarded for their services, by all means, but there should be a condition that if they make racist/homophobic/religiously bigoted comments etc, then they can have that reward taken off them.

Older Mon 05-Jan-15 08:24:35

That's appalling. He should have been excluded on the basis of those remarks alone.

Catsize Mon 05-Jan-15 08:25:43

And there was me, as a gay woman, thinking I had great powers over weather.
We had torrential rain and floods on my daughter's christening day. Had we not had glorious sunshine for her brother's christening two years earlier, I would have put this down to God protesting about gay people having children.
Because God has nothing better to do.
And I am a very very important gay influence on metereological phenomena. confused

Patrickstarxx Mon 05-Jan-15 08:27:48

My cousin had dead birds posted in his letterbox because he was gay by religious lunatics.
He moved to London eventually through fear..

JeanSeberg Mon 05-Jan-15 08:29:43

Is there a petition against this somewhere that we can sign?

OhBuggeringBollocks Mon 05-Jan-15 09:06:45

It never ceases to amaze me that some people feel it perfectly acceptable to criticize others for who they fancy, love and want to have sex with.

It doesn't affect anyone but the immediate participants. Why would I care if my neighbour is gay, bi, asexual? It makes no difference to my life!

And that's aside from the dreadful lack of equality for non standard hetrosexual couples.

This man is clearly an idiot, and least he is quite open about being an idiot so people know to avoid and ignore him. Oh and also award him with an MBE hmm

MaidOfStars Mon 05-Jan-15 09:11:27

On the off chance that such things make a difference:

Petition at

JeanSeberg Mon 05-Jan-15 09:13:02

Thanks, Maid.

Chiggers Mon 05-Jan-15 15:14:24

Thanks Maid. Have signed the petition for award retraction. Hopefully he'll soon see that ignorant, uneducated homophobic comments will not be brushed off any more.

BackOnlyBriefly Mon 05-Jan-15 15:18:58

Signed. If an MBE is about contributions to society then he has made a negative contribution.

At the very least signing sends the message that this is not acceptable.

Enormouse Mon 05-Jan-15 15:21:20

Have also signed.

ithoughtofitfirst Mon 05-Jan-15 15:26:36


Fucking outrageous.

Older Mon 05-Jan-15 17:06:55

Also signed

Toooldtobearsed Mon 05-Jan-15 19:49:24


Chiggers Tue 06-Jan-15 18:31:54


pointythings Tue 06-Jan-15 21:12:55

Signed. It'll probably make no difference, but it needs to be said.

uglyswan Tue 06-Jan-15 21:33:08

signed. Thanks, Maid.

ifitsnotanarse Tue 06-Jan-15 21:51:33

Was wondering if anyone else was outraged by this.

Signed and shared elsewhere.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: