Talk

Advanced search

To thinks its NOT ok to sleep with your sisters ex

(31 Posts)
maypole1 Thu 22-Sep-11 17:06:38

now this has sprung from another thread, and I was horrified at the amount of people who think its ok to shag your sisters ex

They way I was raised is that you never ever sleep, date or kiss your sister or close friends ex unless given express permission To do so


Amount of time elapsed is Irrelevant I haven't seen my Childs father for 12 years but I still would be very cross with my sister snagging him


I just wonder out of all those who think any one is fair game would you be happy for you know husbands to date your sister after you divorce.

BoastingByStealth Thu 22-Sep-11 17:09:06

Absolutely not! No way, EVER!

Sounds like summat off Jeremy Kyle!

What's the other post?

usualsuspect Thu 22-Sep-11 17:11:50

People move on <shrugs>

KatieMiddleton Thu 22-Sep-11 17:12:55

bad form to start a thread about a thread...

nocake Thu 22-Sep-11 17:14:08

I would never sleep with, date or kiss my sister's ex.

But then I am a straight bloke so it would be a bit wierd if I did smile

StrandedBear Thu 22-Sep-11 17:14:52

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

animula Thu 22-Sep-11 17:17:14

If only Henry VIII had had you to talk to, Maypole. We might still be a Catholic country. Interesting thought.

Pandygirl Thu 22-Sep-11 17:18:59

What kind of upbringing involves even having that discussion????????

squeakytoy Thu 22-Sep-11 17:21:01

I think it is wrong when there are children involved, it throws all sorts of confusion into the mix, especially if the second relationship also produces children.. are they cousins? siblings? uncle, father, or stepfather.... etc.

I know someone whose family is like this, and it has torn them apart.

mpsw Thu 22-Sep-11 17:22:47

I think they were simply bowing to the inevitable - the relationship had begun.

If the OP had been from the pov of the second sister asking if she should embark on the relationship, then it would have been pretty resounding 'no' (further royal bad example - Diana Spencer teaming up with her sister's ex).

But it was beyond that point.

bumpybecky Thu 22-Sep-11 17:23:17

my sister has children with my ex, they've been together over 10 years

they thought I'd be really upset when they first got together, but I can honestly say it doesn't bother me at all - I'm happy that they've both found someone that makes them happy smile

I didn't go out with him for long (maybe 6 months) and it was approx 3 years after we split that they got together. It would have been different if we'd still be together when they started!

If I had a sister, I would hope that neither one of us was attracted to an ex boyfriend of the other. But I would hope that we could also understand that you can't always help who you fall for, and at least be able to talk to each other about it without it damaging our relationship or one of us 'forbidding' to go anywhere near the man in question etc.

But it's not entirely surprising that this happens, and I think in some cases it could work for the new couple and the ex, and it would be a shame if they never got the chance to find out, just because the 'wrong' sister saw him first.

I suppose if you are the first sister, it depends very much on the relationship you have with your sibling and your ex.

A bad relationship with either would make this a big no-no.

A bad relationship with one and a good relationship with the other would also be tricky.

A good relationship with both (and enough time passed) might make this situation initially awkward but eventually work out with all concerned still getting along just fine.

And if you are the second sister or the ex, your motives would need very careful examination before you went ahead and started the new relationship.

Whatmeworry Thu 22-Sep-11 17:45:40

iirc it was 4 years between Sis 1 and Sis 2 going out with the same guy and Sis 1 was deeply upset as she felt it Wasn't On.

I think in small communities through history the "not going out with an ex's sibling" would be absolutely dumb, so its a "first world ishoo".

I also think time does have something to do with it. Four weeks later is unforgivable, 4 months later is insensitive, but 4 years.....

What happened to that other thread anyway?

Kladdkaka Thu 22-Sep-11 17:53:51

I think I'd disown my sister if she did this.

MissPenteuth Thu 22-Sep-11 17:58:57

It would depend on how I felt about the ex. If I still had feelings for him then my sister having a relationship with him would probably be hurtful. However if we'd parted on good terms and I knew I didn't want to be with the ex then I'd like to think I could see past any weirdness and be happy for them.

maypole1 Thu 22-Sep-11 18:22:14

i think sister 1 has to be ok with it then its fine but otherwise no.

i also dont get mothers who have sex or date their daughters exs is their not enough men in the country

TrillianAstra Thu 22-Sep-11 18:23:57

YABU

Whatmeworry Thu 22-Sep-11 18:28:07

i think sister 1 has to be ok with it then its fine but otherwise no

How long does teh veto last? ! month? 1 year? 10 years? At some point it gives out.

Voidka Thu 22-Sep-11 18:31:04

Well if he is my sisters Ex then there must be something wrong with him.
YANBU.

Feminine Thu 22-Sep-11 18:32:58

As I said in in the other post its not fantastic ...I wouldn't like it.

But, such is life.

Shit happens.

And believe it or not,there is no law (nor should there be) preventing it.

The other thread indicates they are both over 16, so no crime has taken place.

Have you started this thread because your view is in the minority?

YABU! grin

thebody Thu 22-Sep-11 18:37:59

an ex is an ex really isnt it. if it didnt work out between you then why would you want to stop other people being potentially happy together..

however a sister/friend stealing your oh/dh then thats totally unacceptable.

Vallhala Thu 22-Sep-11 18:38:45

"They way I was raised is that you never ever sleep, date or kiss your sister or close friends ex unless given express permission To do so"

shock What? Are you sure!

In what parrallel universe does a grown woman have to ask the permission of another woman, regardless of who that woman is, before she dates/kisses/shags someone? I'm damned if I would!

MrsRhettButler Thu 22-Sep-11 18:44:25

But besides anything else wouldn't it just be a bit eeeeew?

I wouldn't want 'sloppy seconds' grin

MrsRhettButler Thu 22-Sep-11 18:45:14

Can someone link to the other thread please?

AuntiePickleBottom Thu 22-Sep-11 18:46:08

he is an ex, i really don't give a flying fuck who he dips his wick with.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now