to detest the poems requesting money as a wedding gift?(286 Posts)
We've been invited to three weddings in the last year. Each invitation has included a vomit-inducing poem about how the bride and groom want money as a wedding gift. Is there really any need? I didn't have a gift list or any other kind of mention about what we would like included with the invitations when I married three years ago. We found that the majority of guests gave us money or vouchers anyway. It just feels so grabby. Will stick a fiver in the card though .
Oooh this just reminded me of a wedding I went to, exes friend, hated the girl!!
They had a cardboard box at the main door which was pointed out on arrival. Later in the evening, the bride walked around with it asking individuals if they had contributed and if not, would they?
She also did an old 'Scottish tradition' (that this Scot has never heard of) which involved the men giving her money to lift her dress and the women giving her money to put it down.
Gave her fuck all but was tempted to take €50 out the box to pay for the cab back from the back arse of beyond!!
I don't like requests for presents or money TBH. Tis naff. Never seen a poem demanding cash though, that really takes the biscuit.
Elephant When we married three years ago, we didn't mention gifts at all on the invite and were wondering what would happen... We got home from honeymoon to a massive pile of amazing presents, really special because people had chosen things they liked, which means whenever we use those things we can think of them. We also got tonnes of cash. Not a single toaster either - bonus.
We included a link to our wedding website in the invitation (simple site made with Blogger) and on the website there was a link to our list (along with loads of other wedding info). Almost everyone found it just fine.
The problem we did have was that (mostly older) people began sending gifts from across the pond to the UK and we were incurring HUGE customs bills and had to refuse shipments! So we had to sort that out, and then mass email people telling them thank you SO much for the generosity but please do not take this course of action. Awkward.
Hate requests for money with a passion, poem or no poem. Its akin to charging an entry fee. If you cant afford your honeymoon or need to recoup the costs of the wedding then cut back or save for longer rather than expect guests to pay.
I dont mind a wedding list available if asked for and i usually do it the couple dont live together already and are just starting out. If they already have a home then i stick with a bottle of wine or something like that same for second marriages.
I got married, I had a poem, we went to Tenerife on honeymoon.
Go ahead do your worst
I don't like them either.
i realise it's considered fine, I get it's seen as practical. I understand that there's no point someone giving you something you don't need, times have moved on, yadda yadda yadda...
Doesn't matter. I still think it's rude to ask for anything. So gift lists are out too. the only acceptable response to "what would you like" is "nothing, really, it's fine. I just want your company."
They then have to beat it out of you, at which point you humbly suggest a packet of hankies and they buy you a toaster to go with the other 132 toasters that will be given to you on the day
Any deviation from this procedure is Very Bad Form.
I did once get a gimmee yer money poem from some distant relative I've never met. I amused myself by composing a suitable reply. "thanks for your verse, with your eyes on my purse..."
Didn't send it, of course. Before anyone keels over in shock
It's shocking. I hate how comercialised wedding have become, but then I only had about 12 guests and decided to get married 2 weeks before the wedding day! No gift list, friends just bought what they wanted to give. Have 2 beautiful pieces of art for our house which are my favourite.
What about B listers who are only invited to the evening do. Should they be asked to buy a present? I'm not sure of the etiquette on this one.
We got one of these recently, DH and I were pissing ourselves at it
"When it comes to our gift, don't be rash
How about a little cash?"
DONT BE RASH GIVE US YOUR CASH
The problem with asking for money is that when things are a bit tight you can with a bit of savvy shopping get a gift and they don't know how much you have spent. When you give money you end up sometimes feeling embarrased or tight.
I HATE the poems. Just invite people to your wedding. Most people assume that you do not want a kettle or a toaster and will give money. Some will give nothing and a few will give you a gift.
It bothers me that people think it is totally unacceptable to receive a gift that you do not want. When it is your birthday you don't give a gift list. When it is christmas you don't give a list (not unless you are 5 years old or a bit of an idiot).
FWIW I was very young and had nothing when I got married. People bought us bed linen, towels, cutlery, plates etc. We only had one duplicate gift.
Def not curiosa. B list = no gift requires IMO. Although if you'd like to of course that's lovely.
I get that the polite thing is to not mention gifts and then people call your mum etc etc but it only works if people know the rules. Which they don't generally. Gift list in the invite is so usual now that if its not there people just assume there isn't one and get what they want/ nothing. Which of course is fine and good (if we are all pretending to be selfless and polite ) but maybe not the ideal outcome if you've spent 2 weekends schlepping round John Lewis optimistically zapping le cruessettes with a bar code scanner thingy?
Actually soverylucky I do give a gift list at Xmas and birthday I keep a list of things I see thru the year but wouldn't buy myself as too frivolous. Then I give to dh in case he needs suggestions, I end up with a nice combo of treats I know I want and lovely surprises.
So out of curiosity to all you who wouldn't do a list, would you go to a wedding with no gift? I only ask as at my wedding last month we got hardly anything. We didn't do a list and didn't want anything pricey or specific, but I would have liked to have received something personal as a nice memory. I would never have turned up empty handed. I was quite upset. My sister and close friends didn't give me anything, just my parents gave me a cheque
I meant to say the Xmas list came after one year when I got about 20 bath bombs and a book on the history of electricity
MrsKoala, were your guests invited to the whole day or many just evening only?
All whole day, free bar, food etc. it was implied after that because it was a registry office and a pub do it wasn't a 'proper' wedding. So didn't deserve a 'proper' gift.
mrs - that's rotten. How horrible. And really, really shit to say it wasn't a proper wedding. In fact I think I remember you saying this before (I bloody hope it was you because I hope there aren't two people whose families said this!).
I wouldn't turn up to a wedding without a gift and I would always try to make that gift something the couple wanted, whether that was money or something of a list or the (slightly dreaded) 'surprise me'. I don't see what being invited to the evening do has to do with it, either. I think I would bring a smaller gift if that happened but I wouldn't just turn up empty handed.
Yes lrd that was me, sorry for going on about it on here but I was so surprised. It would have meant so much to have something as a keepsake.
Oh, god, no, believe me, I would be going on about that til kingdom come! And 'surprised' wouldn't cover it. Honestly, that is really shit of them. I'm so sorry.
I didnt put a poem in or a list or indeed mention gifts in any way in our invite.
We got some lovely gifts, including some.home.made, vouchers and cash. There may well have been people who didnt give anything. We had no duplicates and no household appliances.
Why is it always assumed that if you dont include a list you will get seven toaster - thats an old cliche that is said a heck lot more than actually done
That's crap Mrs
Although I doubt that we will ever actually get married "if " we ever did, I'd like to do it pretty much the way you described, except we'd probably bugger off and get married somewhere warm, then come back and have a celebration with all our family. As we've been living together for about 10yrs (together 17) we have the toaster, bed linen etc. Our house if falling in around us but I would never dream of asking for cash to fund repairs, I'd be happy with a nice scented candle or a nice bottle of wine - as I like both ! If people are feeling are more generous and want to spend more then that's very generous, but I don't expect...
What I found saddest was the nct group We had only been part of for a few months gave us a beautiful hand made babysitting 'voucher' and a paid for meal at a lovely restaurant and some picture frames and my family and friends I've had for years didn't bother with anything. I just feel so hurt, but hat I can't go on about without looking 'grabby'.
I think it's rude and vulgar to ask for anything at all to be honest - either a gift or money. It makes the person appear greedy. I think you should receive anything you're given gratefully with a smile and a thanks.
Even the hideous jardiniere and stand I received from a great aunt was appreciated, because she had taken the time and given the thought to buying it for us. It also gave us a giggle on many occasions!
Here you go moominlandmidwinter
Thank you for your invite,
You're poem made me stabby,
I don't mind buying presents
but rhyming for cash is grabby.
I went onto the t'internet,
and asked was I being U,
The mumsnetters agreed I wasn't,
It was a vulgar thing to do
So I thought I would reply to your invite,
But attempt to put it in verse,
So I will be attending your wedding,
But I wont be bringing my purse.
Erm I am feeling a bit bad now.
We are sending out invites in the next few days. We asked for vouchers (no rhyme) I hated the idea of asking for cash, but after several people asked me what we wanted, we sort of panicked and said John Lewis voucher please.
Have I committed a huge faux pas. Do I need to don a fire-retardant suit?
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.