My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationships

Why would a man do this?

277 replies

AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 14:45

I am struggling a bit with moving on with the end of an LTR and wanted to know if anyone can answer me the big "why" over my ex's bizarre behavior so I can try and make peace with it.

Can anyone tell me why would a person would possibly behave like this.

He was not a looker but he was a fantastic boyfriend. Kind, sweet, devoted, loving, attentive, supportive and basically everything I ever wished for and more.

He asked me to move in with him and became the most amazing stepfather to my DCs - kind to them, volunteering for bedtime stories and all that and replacing their own father who sadly disappeared when they were babies. DCs absolutely love him.

He spent years with me in a very happy life where I would have rated the relationship as 10 out of 10 on the happiness scale and he was quite vocal in expressing that he felt the same. He proposed publicly at his parents house with a tearful affirmation of how I made him the happiest he had ever been and he wanted to grow old with me.

Never once did he voice any unhappiness, any dis-satisfaction, any issues at all with me. Nor did he infer them through a reduction of affection or attention. In fact all the way through everything he said or did confirmed the opposite.

Then, very suddenly, out of nowhere, he announced randomly and without any emotion that he'd decided he didn't love me any more and proceeded to turn into the most evil, hideous bastard on the face of the planet.

He moved out and within a week joined every dating site known to man, and while there wasn't another woman he certainly went to great effort to find one and rubbed it in my face.

To make it even worse he started a smear campaign of lies - telling people around us (who were as shocked as I was) that behind closed doors that I was "crazy" and horrible to live with and tearfully told them how he had endured it for so long because of my DCs and he was so convincing that he actually ending up with people feeling sorry for him instead of me!

It was like he wanted to inflict the maximum possible pain and suferring onto me that he could inflict. He seemed angry, viscous, nasty and generally...just evil.

This happened to me a few months ago, and I just really want to find some understanding of how a person can behave like this or why they would want to.

I know people can "fall out of love" and hide it with ease if they choose to - although I do struggle with quite how convincing he was, but what I can't fathom is the cruelty and abuse towards someone who has never done anything wrong to deserve it...are some people capable of pretending to be lovely and then turning incredibly evil? Are they capable of pretending for years?

He has no history of behavior like this. For a long time I thought he had a brain tumour. His behavior since doing this has been very odd.

He started to drink very heavily, seems to not sleep very much, spends all his time on filthy chat sites or playing video games, he tells lies that are quite magnificent, is extremely manipulative and cruel.

I can't really begin to explain how much this is the opposite of the person I lived with for several years. I can't say I ever saw him be even the slightest bit nasty to anyone before.

OP posts:
Report
CocktailQueen · 20/09/2014 14:47

I have no idea, but it sounds quite horrific for you and your dc. X

Report
Quitelikely · 20/09/2014 14:49

You poor woman. Unfortunately I have never heard of this sort of behaviour before so I cannot begin to explain it to help your understanding of him. Very bizarre.

Did he show you any kindness after he left? What do his parents make of it all?

Report
Molotov · 20/09/2014 14:51

Maybe he disguised the person he was whilst he was with you?

Maybe he a psychological disorder? Alcohol dependency?

Regardless, it seems that you've had a narrow escape. Stop dwelling over this man and move forward with your life.

Report
Preciousbane · 20/09/2014 14:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SlicedAndDiced · 20/09/2014 14:52

He sounds like a sociopath op.

That's not a flippant comment.

Report
AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 14:53

Absolutely no kindness. He was almost glib, almost laughing at me. He used to be very humble and self effacing and now he is saying stuff like "Don't try and hold your next man up to my standards" and weird things like that.

His parents are shocked, but on the one hand they have me saying one thing and him saying another and as his parents they are probably inclined to believe him unfortunately. He's no history of being a bastard so unfortunately this works against anyone believing what I am saying.

His Mum thinks he might be ill and has asked him to go to the doctor.

OP posts:
Report
AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 14:56

I did think of the sociopath / psychopath line of things (my counsellor suggested this) but when I google it and look at the symptoms they are all true NOW but were not true before.

For example he was always very humble, always very prone to normal expressions of shame, very violent, plenty of close long term friends.

Can you just become one? It's confusing!

OP posts:
Report
Shockers · 20/09/2014 14:57

Has he experienced some kind of trauma? You mentioned that you thought he had a brain tumour, has he had that checked out?

Fwiw, I don't think someone could pretend to love you for such a long period of time. He sounds like he's had some kind of breakdown. You can't help him with that though, if that's the case; he's made his position clear.

Awful situation for youSad.

Report
Shockers · 20/09/2014 14:58

Very violent?

Report
Vitalstatistix · 20/09/2014 14:59

If he really genuinely went from amazing guy to that, then I would not rule out some sort of breakdown. Although I can't stress enough that I am in no way attempting to diagnose anything.

Or, perhaps he did have an affair - just because you have no evidence, does not mean it is a physical impossibility - people who shit all over someone they have claimed to love quite often have what is basically a self defence thing of turning their victim into a devil. It's the only way they can live with crapping all over them. The alternative is to accept they have been a complete bastard and to accept harsh truths about their character. If they are cowardly enough to sneak around behind their partner's back, they're hardly the type to be able to face unpleasant truths about their character, so they hate the person they've wronged instead.

However, nobody can maintain a pretence for years and years. Don't start thinking that your life together was a lie, it likely wasn't. At some point and probably for a long time, he loved you and was not a shit.

But for whatever reason, the person you loved does not exist any more. This person lives in his body. And you don't and never did love this person. So let this person go. They are nothing to you.

I realise that you probably feel like you need to know why, but really you can't know why unless he tells you why. Everything else is just speculation, yours or ours, and gets you no further forward. You really need to accept that he did what he did for reasons known only to himself and it was not your fault and not tie yourself up trying to figure out why, because it won't change anything and it won't give you back the life you had.

I'm sorry that you have to deal with all this. It must be extremely painful. Thanks

Report
AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 14:59

sorry, never violent. He was gentle and the opposite of violent. Don't think he ever got angry.

The only trauma he has had was about a year ago he was in an accident and had a head injury, but that was a year ago and I would have thought if there was a problem it would have surfaced by now?

OP posts:
Report
SlicedAndDiced · 20/09/2014 15:02

Someone can pretend for years on end. You would never know there us anything wrong. They say and do all the right things, you have a perfect life together. Then that's it, either he got bored and found a more interesting game to play or a better proposition.

Trust me, in the past I've done it myself.

Report
Vitalstatistix · 20/09/2014 15:03

x-post, if he mum also genuinely thinks he is ill, then she's seeing behaviours that worry her too and you can't rule anything out.

Again, not trying to diagnose anything, but head injury, certain diseases, mental health problems, certain tumours, etc all can cause drastic and disturbing personality changes.

But whatever it is, your priority has to be to take care of yourself and your kids.

Report
Shockers · 20/09/2014 15:03

I actually wondered about a head injury. I have heard about personality changes due to brain damage before.

If he has changed so dramatically, surely his parents are worried. Do you think they could persuade him to go to the doctors?

Report
Thumbwitch · 20/09/2014 15:03

It's possible that he has developed either a mental illness that has given him a personality change, or it could be a brain tumour as you've suggested. I think he definitely should go to the doctor to get checked out.

But! This sort of behaviour can and does happen when they meet another woman and leave you for them, because they no longer need to maintain their "relationship persona" - i.e. the one where they suppress the parts of them that don't "fit" into your relationship - are you sure there isn't another woman on the sidelines?

Report
Thumbwitch · 20/09/2014 15:07

Yes, head trauma - stroke, brain bleed, all that kind of thing - could also induce a personality change depending on where it is.

Sadly though, the bad news is that if it is after a brain injury, it's likely to be irreversible. :(
If it's due to a tumour, that could be removed and possibly the "old" personality might come back, depending on how much damage has been done.

Even a concussion could apparently cause some personality changes.

Report
Thumbwitch · 20/09/2014 15:08
Report
AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 15:09

I'm sure there's no other woman, as I say, he is active on dating sites and porno sites and behaving in a very strange way sexually. I don't want to be graphic but he has done totally bizarre things like put video of himself masturbating online. As he has quite a highly respected job and personality this is completely bizarre and out of character.

His Mum is worried about him, so she does see that there's a significant change in him. For example extreme weight loss. His clothes are un-ironed for work and he has missed a lot of work but obviously she doesn't know about the rest of stuff and it's hard for me to tell her.

He has made me "the enemy" so it feels like she feels caught between us and loyal obviously to her son.

He is very angry and aggressive which is uncharacteristic but for whatever reason I am the butt of all of this and he seems to literally HATE me, whilst being largely normal with everyone else.

OP posts:
Report
AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 15:14

Reading that link rings a bell. For several months before this he was complaining of poor sleep, tiredness and I noticed quite a severe increase in his drinking.

After the head injury he did experience a short term personality change for about a month, but then he seemingly went back to normal with only the above left as signs of the injury.

He has also described extreme problems with his memory. Not so much long term memory but he frequently forgets what he is doing etc. and struggles to remember conversations.

OP posts:
Report
Shockers · 20/09/2014 15:18

He needs help.

But not from you at this point.

Report
ravenmum · 20/09/2014 15:19

I've been in a slightly similar situation. In my case there was a behaviour change after his mother's death, then after several months I discovered he'd started an affair around that time. Not sure what came first, chicken or egg there, but I read the emails he sent his mistress and he'd also been telling her similar stories about me, saying I'd said and done various weird/nasty things over the last 20 years - she even replied saying how amazed she was at my weird behaviour. From a couple of things (ex-)friends said, it seemed he was also telling them similar tales, which they unfortunately believed (hence ex-).

In my ex's case I'd say it is partly cognitive dissonance: subconsciously not wanting to see himself as a bad person, so subconsciously searching for reasons why he has acted nastily - reasons which he believes himself. And partly consciously trying to find excuses. If your ex feels that suddenly upping and leaving you without warning means he's a bad person, then that feeling is horrible and he'll be trying to make it go away.

For months I thought the behaviour change was caused by his mother's death and overworking, now I have another explanation, but I do wonder if those causes did have something to do with the affair and this unexpected vitriol, too. Did any crises happen in your ex's life?

My ex was also very self-effacing towards me, never complained about anything, but now, with hindsight, I remember an expression in certain situations that I thought was boredom or disinterest. (Situations like me looking at clothes offers in the supermarket, for instance.) Now I've seen the same expression, but stronger, in the open arguments we had about his mistress and my "misbehaviour" and in fact it's an expression of dislike, even contempt. I reckon that he'd been fed up and secretly irritated with me for some time but was too scared/cowardly/indecisive to say anything at all, instead opting for the mistress. Any chance that your ex's amazingly humble behaviour might actually have been similar repression of his real feelings?

Report
Thumbwitch · 20/09/2014 15:19

He REALLY needs to go to the doctor.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

ravenmum · 20/09/2014 15:19

x-post, sorry

Report
BlueBrightBlue · 20/09/2014 15:27

You need to walk away and realise you will never get answers as to why he's done this.
You will drive yourself mad looking for the reasons he's behaving this way.
My guess is he's chameleon, there are a lot of people who are masters of this, hence your relationship scoring 10/10.
I feel for you OP, but you really can't help. Lick your wounds and don't be afraid to ask for any help that's on offer.

Report
AmeliaPondsBaby · 20/09/2014 15:29

Yes, he has had recent crisis in his life. A bereavement that knocked him for six, some financial problems that he was very stressed out about but he was always not really the sort of person to get down or stressed.

Raven your post was really interesting. He definitely does not want to even remotely acknowledge he has done anything wrong.

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.