to sing harmonies in toddler music sessions?

(292 Posts)
PrincessPotsie Sat 05-Jul-14 02:01:48

Am I turning into one of those annoying mums? I always remember a v annoying dad doing sit ups during 'Row Row Row Your Boat' at a playgroup I once went to. He definitely was BU...

slithytove Sat 05-Jul-14 02:15:00

Yes, very, this would strike me as majorly show off.

YABU.

Singsongmama Sat 05-Jul-14 02:17:19

Quietly and occasionally into toddlers ear- YANBU
Belting it out like a Mercedes from Glee - YABU and may be considered a numpty

I love music class - we all croak along - ain't no Celine Dions at my group.

smile

BOFster Sat 05-Jul-14 02:38:30

Erm, yes, YABU- I presume the point of you joining in at all is to model the actual melody for the toddlers present?

There are loads of adult singing groups around if you want to be a bit more ambitious.

Am I missing some fun irony thing? Sorry.

diggerdigsdogs Sat 05-Jul-14 02:39:33

You would absolutely BU.

I would assume you were a twat.

ElleBellyBeeblebrox Sat 05-Jul-14 02:41:55

Chuckle. Thankyou.
Obviously YABU and ridiculous, but at least now I will have the perfect example to use when trying to illustrate just why I don't always like going to baby music groups.

AgentZigzag Sat 05-Jul-14 02:45:58

A good measurement of unreasonableness would be what the other parents/children do when you start up the harmonies. Them starting to go along with you and congratulations afterwards at your talent and confidence would be good, sitting open mouthed and deadly silence/odd child starting to grizzle, probably not good.

Maybe you could start off singing row your boat in rounds?

SignYourName Sat 05-Jul-14 02:59:06

YABU but thank you for giving me a giggle - for some reason I started picturing this as a scene from a British comedy film (in the About A Boy / Four Weddings style) and imagining the rest of the group gradually falling silent and staring at you while you warble away, oblivious.

YABU. We had a lady do this at ours, comes across as totally self-unaware mixed with Performance Parenting. Annoying.

oxygenna Sat 05-Jul-14 03:09:03

Just you attempting the harmonies? Not so impressive sounding as you might think grin So yes yabu

I would assume you'd got the wrong end of the stick somewhere and were oblivious.

QuizzicalCat Sat 05-Jul-14 03:18:35

I have a toddler. I also teach singing and lead various choirs. I can sing harmony to anything.

I would roll my eyes and think 'get over yourself you show off'.

Time and place. Toddler group is neither. It's for fun, if you can carry a tune, great! Carry the bloody TUNE. It reduces the amount of people thinking 'twat' in your general direction.

Aeroflotgirl Sat 05-Jul-14 03:20:47

Yanbu at all, thought the toddlers were signing harmonies shock. The adults oh dear, they should join a choir if they want to sing.

Bogeyface Sat 05-Jul-14 03:24:45

H does this and it is such knobbish behaviour. He thinks he is just doing it because it sounds good, I know he is doing it to show off. He thinks he is the star, I know that he is the knob.

Stop it, you dont want to be "that" mother. Although....you may already be.

Noteventhebestdrummer Sat 05-Jul-14 03:44:27

I had a woman who was worse than this at my toddler classes. She improvised descants to final phrases.
The trills on the last verse of 5 little ducks were UGLY.

TiredFeet Sat 05-Jul-14 04:01:55

Toddler group definitely not the time or the place but I would be secretely delighted if you did, just because it would be so awesomely cringingly inappropriate grin

CustardFromATin Sat 05-Jul-14 04:49:41

Oh dear YABU and awful. It can be hard enough already, and plenty of our tone deaf toddlers struggle enough with the melody as it is.

On the other hand, you will be providing the other parents with much hilarity, so maybe you should just go ahead...

PrincessPotsie Sat 05-Jul-14 05:43:21

Oh dear.....so IABU then. It's back to the tune next week. Hopefully I will shrug off the 'that mum' label quickly. grin

Singsongmama Sat 05-Jul-14 05:46:03

I'm sure we are all 'that mum' sometimes....it's a chilling moment when you catch yourself doing it!

isitsnowingyet Sat 05-Jul-14 05:59:53

Actually, if I was there, I would think 'good for you - you are a nutter' - and I wouldn't assume you were showing off or 'a knob'. So I guess I must be 'one of those Mums' who doesn't follow what everyone else thinks or says <particularly on mumsnet>

Maybe it is possible that she is really enjoying the music???

I say 'Go for it Princess!'

Clarky365 Sat 05-Jul-14 06:10:34

grin would make laugh at you grin

AllHailTheBigPurpleOne Sat 05-Jul-14 06:11:52

Yanbu
if I were there I'd join in.
I love glee

GiniCooper Sat 05-Jul-14 06:55:31

I'd cringe for you.
I'm cringing now TBH.

Tanith Sat 05-Jul-14 07:00:33

At this age, when they're still learning the tune itself, you'd be an almighty distraction. Trust me: a fair few of the toddlers are going to think confused, never mind fheir parents smile

Harness that creativity and make up some new songs. I'm sure everyone gets sick to the back teeth of Rowing that flipping Boat, drowning those Little Ducks, catching those Fishes below the Twinkling blasted Stars. Especially those of us who've been singing them weekly for 15, 20 years or more shock

SavoyCabbage Sat 05-Jul-14 07:01:34

I'd think you didn't know the tune. It would give me something to look forward too though.

Cyclebump Sat 05-Jul-14 07:06:27

I do this at home to mitigate the boredom of singing the same songs over and over again.

I'd never do it at a group. When I have led a few sessions as a volunteer I've had quite a few parents say how nervous they are singing in front of people and I think getting a bit showy would completely put them off.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now