Boys school football team should have boys in??

(126 Posts)
plastique Tue 13-Sep-16 20:58:29

So son has come home from school, disappointed not to get in the yr 8 school football team. Ok fair enough, there must be better players than him.... Well that's life move on etc!!! Oh no that's not the case. Two girls are in the boys football team.. Fair enough too if boys are allowed in girls football team... But oh no girls only... Trying to teach equality etc but this goes against everything!! Thoughts please....

Mummyme1987 Tue 13-Sep-16 21:00:23

Surely it should just be a football team and whoever the best footballers are should fill the team.

Mummyme1987 Tue 13-Sep-16 21:01:13

Regardless of if they are boys or girls

katienana Tue 13-Sep-16 21:02:23

Girls shouldn't be competing against boys at that age.

Waffles80 Tue 13-Sep-16 21:02:32

Maybe they've not got enough boys who are good at football?

Don't worry, I'm sure your son's lifetime of enjoying make privilege will more than make up for this terrible slur.

Waffles80 Tue 13-Sep-16 21:02:54

Why the fuck not katie?

plastique Tue 13-Sep-16 21:04:52

They were advertised as boys trials and girls trials. Two very different teams.

PotteringAlong Tue 13-Sep-16 21:06:27

waffles there are rules about when mixed teams have to stop; the poster's not trying to be goady or offensive! She's being factual!

neonrainbow Tue 13-Sep-16 21:06:29

Yeah you're right. Girls shouldn't be in a boys team. There would be a big outcry if boys were allowed on a girls team.

PotteringAlong Tue 13-Sep-16 21:07:42

Ah, ignore that, it's been raised to 18! Maybe she is being goady. As you were...smile

PotteringAlong Tue 13-Sep-16 21:08:51

I was thinking of rugby where it's 12 when mixed teams are not allowed from

ssd Tue 13-Sep-16 21:11:01

seems a bit daft if girls are allowed in the boys team and boys arent allowed in the girls

who are they trying to encourage here?

AuntieStella Tue 13-Sep-16 21:12:17

You can have mixed teams at that age. It's just that most schools and clubs don't. So they are very unlikely to have much in the way of fixtures.

They will be barred from playing both all-boys and all-girls teams.

So unless there's a local plethora of mixed teams, it essentially means a cop out from the competitive game.

Holymolymay Tue 13-Sep-16 21:14:12

That's not equality. TBH I find it often works one way.
And honestly I have never felt being female to be a disadvantage like many around here.

katienana Tue 13-Sep-16 21:17:14

I played in the girls team for my school. We played a match against the boys once. We got annihilated! Boys get faster and stronger quite quickly at that age. I think girls should focus on playing in a girls team. Women's sport is great.

plastique Tue 13-Sep-16 21:17:52

I'm all for mixed teams, but a girls team and a mixed team!! The girls team did win the cup last year so there are some excellent players but hey just feeling meh and not fair on boys!!!

LaurieFairyCake Tue 13-Sep-16 21:17:59

never felt being female to be a disadvantage

Seriously? Feel totally safe wandering about in that bikini? Or hijab? Or being fat or thin? Or going for a run?

No one hassle you ever just for having the audacity to be female and moving about in the world ? hmm

Happy with that equal pay you won't get til 2065?

Waffles80 Tue 13-Sep-16 21:18:04

So your pay is equal to that of men in equivalent roles? You won't lose out on your pension because of maternity leave? You won't face the increased risk of being a victim of crime? You won't be overlooked professionally in favour of a man? Or any of the other millions of reasons women simply aren't equal still. In 206.

Must be lovely round your way holymary

anotherdayanothersquabble Tue 13-Sep-16 21:19:02

I can see why you might think it is unfair on your son that he lost an opportunity to represent the school and that the rules seem to have been broken in favour of the girls.

I have two sons and one daughter, all of whom play football. We have a constant battle with school over provision for competitive team sport for girls. Boys have plenty of opportunities both inside and outside of school to play competitive team sports at whatever level they are at. The same cannot be said for girls. If these girls are really good enough to be in the team they deserve the opportunity to play at their level rather than in a team of girls who have had less experience and less training.

In a world where Hilary Clinton is told to go home and be a grandmother but Trump is allowed to be a racist bigoted idiot, and male football players get paid 150 times more than female ones, I think we need to keep giving girls all the opportunities we can!!
.

acasualobserver Tue 13-Sep-16 21:19:13

It does seem counter-intuitive that there is something called a boys' team but which also includes girls. Why not just have a mixed team plus a girls' team and then everyone would know where they stood?

Osolea Tue 13-Sep-16 21:20:54

If there's a girls team and a boys team, then there absolutely shouldn't be girls on the boys team, even if they are better than some of the boys.

School teams shouldn't really be about who's best at a sport anyway, it would be better if they made it about providing opportunities for children to play team sports for the exercise and the teamwork aspect, regardless of how good they are.

plastique Tue 13-Sep-16 21:23:19

To go to the 'boys trial' and 2 girls get in is not what I was expecting! We live in a large town with ample football opportunity for girls. My friends have some very talented girl footballers. The point I'm trying to make us...it's not on ...

neonrainbow Tue 13-Sep-16 21:26:07

You'd be getting totally different answers if you had a daughter and 2 boys had taken places on a girls team.

Shakirasma Tue 13-Sep-16 21:28:52

Perhaps the girls identify as boys (on practice and match days), isn't that how things work now? hmm

Totally unfair OP.

MeAndMy3LovelyBoys Tue 13-Sep-16 21:31:19

Those girls shouldn't be on the boys team. They have a girls team why isn't that enough? Even if they were better than some of the boys, they weren't good enough to be picked to join the girls team so should wait until next time rather than stealing a boys place.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now