I got taken in as well - £37 worth of DVDs including Frozen. Made a claim with Paypal and despite a number of emails, they confirmed refund is subject to returning items to the seller irrespective of items being allegedly counterfeit. See their response:
"Thank you for contacting PayPal regarding PP-003-409-009-074.
While it may be against laws and regulations to ship a counterfeit item for commercial purposes, it is not illegal to return an item that has been alleged to be counterfeit in the process of pursuing resolution through consumer protection avenues.
We understand your concerns with returning an item where its authenticity has been questioned. The seller is denying your claim and stating that it is not counterfeit, and based on our review of the information other than that of the physical item itself - information on the seller’s business and track record, we believe that the best course of action is to return the item.
Please note that while it may be against laws and regulations to ship a counterfeit item for commercial purposes, it is not illegal to return an item that has been alleged to be counterfeit in the process of pursuing resolution through consumer protection avenues.
Our policy calls for buyers to bear the cost of returning merchandise in a claim. You are free to work with your seller to attempt to seek reimbursement for the cost of the return shipping. If you are unable to return the item to the seller as requested we will not be able to assist you in securing a refund.
With PayPal Buyer Protection, we help you to recover initial funds from sellers who deliver goods that are 'significantly not as described', or in other words, goods which do not match the original description. In keeping with our PayPal Buyer Protection program, we ask that you return the item to the seller so that we can issue a refund to your account. Without return delivery confirmation, we will be unable to issue a refund. PayPal does not cover the cost of returning the item.
Please fax or upload the proof of shipment by 09/29/2014 . If you fail to provide the documents within the given timeframe please note that we will close this claim in the seller's favor. Please use the PayPal fax cover sheet or alternatively fax the documents with your name, your email address and the respective PayPal case number onto the following fax number: 402-537-5760. Please note: To help protect your information, we don't accept files that are sent as email attachments. If you email us attachments, we will still require you to upload or fax your documents.
To upload files, please follow these steps:
1.Go to the PayPal website and log in to your account.
2.Go to the Resolution Center, and then click Respond in the Action column of the transaction in question.
3.Click Resolve Complaint.
4.Select the radio button to provide the documentation and click Continue.
5.Select a method to submit your documentation.
6.To upload your documentation, click Browse.
7.Select the file you want to attach.
8.Click Open.
Give the file a recognizable title.
•The title should not include more than three numbers.
•You may provide a description of the file you are sending, up to 100 characters.
•Click Attach this File.
•Information about your file will appear under the Attachments box. In the Attachments section, you can preview the file or delete it.
•Repeat steps 1-3 as many times as required, up to a total file size of 5000kb, using a gif(Graphic Interchange Format), jpg (Joint Photographic Experts Group), png (Portable Network Graphics), or tif (Tag Image File) format.
•Click Send Files to PayPal to submit your files for review by PayPal.
For more information on PayPal's Purchase Protection Policy, click the Legal Agreement link at the bottom of any PayPal page, and click PayPal User Agreement.
Please let us know if you require any further assistance.
Yours sincerely,
Joan
PayPal
Copyright © 1999-2014 PayPal. All rights reserved.
PayPal (Europe) S.à r.l. et Cie, S.C.A.
Société en Commandite par Actions
Registered Office: 22-24 Boulevard Royal L-2449, Luxembourg
RCS Luxembourg B 118 349