Saskia or Claudia?

(44 Posts)
Cosycottage4 Sun 15-May-16 08:32:59

DD1 is Naomi. Over to you, mumsnet jury! wink

Quercus3 Sun 15-May-16 09:21:56

Claudia edges it for me

BoboBunnyH0p Sun 15-May-16 09:22:10

Naomi and Saskia sound lovely together. Saskia is a strong confident name. Also probably less common than Claudia.

notsureaboutthis1992 Sun 15-May-16 09:22:36

Saskia!

1horatio Sun 15-May-16 09:43:09

Claudia is so lovely.
Saskia reminds me of Swastika, to be honest... Swahs-tee-ka, Sahs-kee-a sad

But I'm an expat and my first language is German, so maybe that's different for a native (English) speaker.

Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost Sun 15-May-16 11:55:33

Naomi and Saskia go much better than Naomi and Claudia.

EllenDegenerate Sun 15-May-16 12:29:29

Saskia is very popular around here.

I think it is a husky's name.

Claudia is marginally better I suppose.

Love Naomi thoughsmile

Hushabyelullaby Sun 15-May-16 12:32:10

I really like both <not helpful>

Maybe Saskia edges it for me.

Botchit Sun 15-May-16 12:34:25

I really love both names. I know one Saskia aged about 10, really lovely girl. I also know one Claudia, pronounced cloudia, again, really lovely young lady, about aged 20. I would pronounce it as Claudia though.
Love Naomi too. You have great taste.
I think if I had to choose I would go for Saskia. With Claudia and Naomi, 90's super models spring to mind.

LilyandGinger Sun 15-May-16 12:36:24

Claudia

PhylumChordata Sun 15-May-16 12:41:36

I love Claudia but I think it means lame or something similar which puts me off a bit.

Still a better name than Saskia imo.

Winterbiscuit Sun 15-May-16 16:42:14

Saskia

septembersunshine Sun 15-May-16 16:46:51

If I were you I'd have trouble deciding too. I can't decide. I would (honestly) have to see the baby and then decide. If I had to make a choice I would chose Saskia.... only thing is written down I keep seeing Kia (as in the make of car). Claudia sounds very sophisticated!

nectarini1983 Sun 15-May-16 17:12:06

Saskia. (Love Sasha too.)

Dangerouswoman Sun 15-May-16 17:14:24

I love both. I know two Claudias but never met a Saskia.

JingsAndCrivens Sun 15-May-16 17:16:25

I like them both. To me they're quite sophisticated names.

Dogolphin Sun 15-May-16 17:54:26

Saskia!

GoldPlatedBacon Sun 15-May-16 18:08:37

They are two of my most favourite names but Claudia is my overriding favourite

HeteronormativeHaybales Sun 15-May-16 18:13:18

Absolutely Saskia. (1horatio, it's a short 'a' in Saskia as pronounced by a typical Brit (and a German too tbh), sounds nothing like the a in swastika). It's strong, cool, elegant, phonetic, not overused and goes well with Naomi. Claudia will get different pronunciations in different parts of the world and tbh doesn't have a great meaning.

JingsAndCrivens Sun 15-May-16 18:33:12

The meaning of Claudia wouldn't bother me at all. I mean doesn't Cecilia mean 'blind'? And isn't Amelia the name of some disease or other?

1horatio Sun 15-May-16 18:50:11

HeteronormativeHaybales, the syllables are bit different, yes. But the last A is the same, tbh.

It's obviously just my personal opinion. And yes, German is my first language.
But seeing as this apparently isn't an issue in England: Saskia is really lovely.

EmmaWoodlouse Sun 15-May-16 18:56:44

I like both but I think I like Saskia slightly better with Naomi.

Millipedewithherfeetup Sun 15-May-16 19:49:54

Saskia for me too, love sassy as a nn.

julfin Sun 15-May-16 19:55:25

All three very beautiful and sophisticated names, imo. All three on my girls' names list for future. I'd struggle to choose between S and C. Maybe marginally Saskia.

As we clearly have very similar names, and I'm expecting a boy, may I ask what would have been on your boys' names list?

ThroughThickAndThin01 Sun 15-May-16 19:55:43

Ooh either.

If my life expended on it, Claudia.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now