Rate girls names...

(27 Posts)
Sugar2 Sun 25-Aug-13 12:16:47

Hi

Can you help rate these names... We are after a name that's different but still pretty and feminine. We dont want anything too trendy that will be dated in 10 years or where they'll be lots in her class!

Thoughts are...
Camilla
Elodie
Sybil
Polly

Thank you loads!

X

meditrina Sun 25-Aug-13 12:29:30

Lovely names!

I'd go for Elodie, with Polly as a runner up.

Fawlty Towers is just too enduringly popular for Sybil to be association-free.

Selks Sun 25-Aug-13 12:45:09

Ditto meditrina.

Bowlersarm Sun 25-Aug-13 12:47:50

I like Polly.

It's of the time now yet not a new name. I know Polly's aged in their 50's down to toddler age. There's a smattering across all ages.

TallulahBetty Sun 25-Aug-13 14:23:20

Love Elodie. Like Camilla. Don't like the other two at all.

cupcakeicing Sun 25-Aug-13 14:30:31

Elodie and Polly are lovely names. Agree Sybil has too strong Fawlty Towers/ Downton associations.

bishboschone Sun 25-Aug-13 14:31:14

I like eliodie but it sounds a bit like melody and I think she would have to explain her name every time she says it but if that doesn't worry you it's nice.

EnjoyEverySandwich Sun 25-Aug-13 14:32:19

Elodie is very "now" and will date as badly as it has done in France, where it is seen as firmly 1980s.

Agree that it's hard to cast off the FT connection with Sybil.

Polly I find a bit twee for my taste.

Camilla is a timeless classic, so that would be my choice. Hate Millie though, so I would hope that didn't catch on as a nn! But I was at school with a Camilla, and she was always called by her full name.

ChimeForChange Sun 25-Aug-13 14:33:18

Elodie for me

MummyBeerest Sun 25-Aug-13 14:34:42

If I had to place them:

1) Elodie
2) Camilla
3) Polly
4) Sybil

bruffin Sun 25-Aug-13 14:36:29

Elodie, not over keen on any of the others.

BlueStarsAtNight Sun 25-Aug-13 14:41:37

I think I'd say:

1) Elodie (though agree it might well date badly!)
2) Polly
3) Sybil
4) Camilla

NannyPlumForPM Sun 25-Aug-13 14:46:02

But polly is also fawlty towers?! I like polly the best but elodie is very pretty. Camilla has too big a royal connotation for me but it depends on other DC's and area etc. But not a big fan of Sybil

TenthMuse Sun 25-Aug-13 15:24:27

Like Elodie, although it's very much 'of the moment' and Polly is cute. Dislike both Camilla and Sybil, so definitely wouldn't go with either of these.

LoopyLupo Sun 25-Aug-13 15:30:51

I love Elodie and would consider if weren't for my PITA surname.

Sybil is very underused for such a lovely name and FT was yonks ago. None of her peers would know it. I wouldn't even consider it as an issue.

I always put Polly in the same category as Daisy or Poppy, lovely on a child but awful on an adult.

Camilla is too 'Royal' for me esp as Charles will be king soon.

LeMousquetaireAnonyme Sun 25-Aug-13 15:38:04

Elodie
Sybil
Camilla, can you use Camille instead? then it would be top with Elodie

Polly, no, good name for a parrot.

riskit4abiskit Sun 25-Aug-13 16:22:13

Do you have longer name that polly could be a nn of?

agree with comments above regarding sybil sorry.

pippa?

meditrina Sun 25-Aug-13 16:31:50

Polly is also a Fawlty Towers character, but the associations aren't the same, as it's not a catchphrase name. And FT keeps coming at/near the top of all-time comedy bests, so I think it's one that is just too widely known and likely to stick around.

I think Polly's a variant of Molly (short for Mary, same pattern as Peg and Meg fom Margaret) but that's a bit obscure these days. Or you could go all Mitford and label in full as Leopoldina?

Sugar2 Sun 25-Aug-13 16:49:16

Thank you! Mixed feedback! Such a responsibly! I think Sybil is out!

I'm leaning towards Camilla but royal connection does bother me!

How do you pronounce Camille? Is it cam-eel or cam-il?

Thank you!

LeMousquetaireAnonyme Sun 25-Aug-13 16:55:42

Camille = close to cameel

Frontdoorstep Sun 25-Aug-13 16:58:28

I've never been a huge Fawlty Towers fan and I don't associate Sybil with Fawlty towers for that reason, would today's younger people really be familiar with Fawlty towers?

Purplelooby Sun 25-Aug-13 20:24:26

In order of preference:

Sybil
Polly
Camilla
Elodie

But then that's just my taste. I think Elodie is the most likely to date.

KLou1105 Sun 25-Aug-13 23:27:04

1- polly
2- elodie
3- camilla
4- Sybil

williaminajetfighter Sun 25-Aug-13 23:42:57

Camilla is lovely. Works for all ages. Can be Cami or Milly for short.

Sybil 2nd choice.

Elodie is very MN popular at the moment.

Polly is more of a dogs name IMO.

Alisvolatpropiis Mon 26-Aug-13 01:31:30

Camilla is lovely with various nickname options.

Elodie is inexplicably popular on MN. It's horrid.

Polly makes me think of the nursery rhyme but is otherwise fine.

Sybil - no. Just no.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now