An unrecommendation - Garnier

[hollyisalovelyname]

I recommended the Garnier eye make up remover for sensitive eyes, praising it to the skies. It came in a green, then blue, bottle.
Sadly, they appear to have changed the formulation- now in a purple bottle and has caused a bad reaction around my eyes.
Grrrr- if it's not broken why fix it?

[Robertwars]

Same here! I loved the the blue bottle but the new formula makes me spotty ..wasting money trying find a new cleanser now .

[Marylou2]

Is this the blue bottle with the oil and water mix? Noooooo they just can't change it, it's perfect as it was.

[hollyisalovelyname]

No it was the sensitive eye make up remover. It WAS super. Non irritating.
NOT ANYMORE

[Tadla]

i love the one that you mix - the oil and water one marylou mentioned. Ive just bought it today. It takes off my waterproof mascara beautifully.

[maybemyrtle]

I don't think the Garnier biphase one works as well as it used to. It doesn't swipe everything off any more and I don't even use waterproof mascara. Any recs for an alternative? The Nivea biphase was useless and irritating.