My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationships

is it really better to be on your own? - having huge wobble!

17 replies

patchi · 18/04/2012 05:00

quick back story - I don't think i love dh anymore he has let me and dc down alot (losing jobs, suspicious incidents re ow but no actual proof).Anyway over last 5 years I have tried to sort of plan for escape (posted before). I am now at point of feeling constant physical anxiety and on brink of tears alot. Have spoken to him re him moving out but he just says we can work it out he loves me blah blah and then does make actual huge effort to please me and is finally doing stuff with the dc.
Is that really so bad my friends and family are all telling me to be brave and just do it but I feel totally ill at the thought.
Everyone is concerned he won't support us (earns alot when in work but often isn't in work iyswim).
I am so worried about what I will actually live on (I started my own business but I don't earn enough to support us all without his help)
I am worried i won't be invited out - we live in middle east and everyone is married.
I have no friends or family in UK or anyway to earn a decent living (or any living really) and feel that option is worse than the situation I am in.
Husband making real effort and things are totally amiable and fine but there is something huge missing.
I am so shaky and just cannot find the strenght to sort this out. Is this how everyone feels when they split up or do you suddnely find strenght from somewhere?

OP posts:
Report
HotDAMNlifeisgood · 18/04/2012 07:41

You are focusing on all the reasons not to act. Why is that, do you think?

Report
BranchingOut · 18/04/2012 07:51

Could you get back to the UK? Could you all move back to the UK as a family then you separate?

I would normally say 'leave', but I don't know what the situation is where you are living. I am assuming there wouldn't be a welfare state to support you. What are the laws about divorce and separation? Are there restrictions on what women can do independently?

I am wondering if you might have to think longer term eg. wait until your business has been built up, get a job or you have returned to the UK.

Report
HotDAMNlifeisgood · 18/04/2012 08:09

Is fear enough of a reason to hold back from something you have been trying to put in place for 5 years?

You can't know whether freedom will be better, and no-one can guarantee it for you. But you do know that the current situation is untenable.

Report
2rebecca · 18/04/2012 08:21

It's not clear from your post where your friends and family are. Are you from the middle east with support network there, you say you have no-one in the UK?
I think if you choose to leave a marriage you have to have a plan of how socially and financially you will manage, and be clear why you are leaving. You don't sound mentally well at the moment and that may or may not be related to your marriage. You may leave your marriage and find the anxiety and depression persist and you are just poorer and more isolated.
I did leave a marriage but was financially secure and mentally strong when I did so.
You say there is something huge missing, but there is no guarentee you will find it if you leave your marriage.
I would see someone to discuss your mental health first. You also have to look at how you will support yourself financially if you divorce and not rely on your husband to do so. You will get money from a split but divorce laws vary in different countries and I think women should be looking at supporting themselves and their ex just paying towards the children.
Sorry to sound negative but I think to go through the stress and financial hardship of divorce you need to be mentally strong and have a clear idea of why you will be happier not in the marriage. You sound very vague and a bit "grass is greener" about things.

Report
patchi · 18/04/2012 10:24

Thanks so much for all that advise that is what I am wondering when couples split do they just do it or do they have more of a plan and make sure they are all sorted type of thing.
I am british but my kids have been brought up in middle east.
I ahve great friends here.
I don't really have mates in UK and my family live all over Europe so no base at all as such.
i have lived in middle east for 20 years since I was 20 so don't even know where I would go back to in the uk.
what would I do and who would I see or even talk to?
At least here I have a business and great friends and the kids have a brilliant lifestyle.
BUT although my husband is trying really really hard right now to keep things going I don't really have any feeling towards him. He has lost so many jobs and I have never felt financially secure with him but at least I ahve some control over the money where as if we split up he will claim to have nothing i am pretty sure.
He is attractive and women always like him I am sure he will hook up with someone straight away and be off.
I know I won't probably meet anyone due to the lifestyle out here and you can't be with a man unless you are married iyswim or you could even end up in jail.
My friends are urging me to split but I honestly don't know if it is the right thing but is being with someone you don't love right either?
I do get on with dh he makes me laugh and we rub along ok. I can get on Ok with him and as i say he is really trying.
I feel constantly anxious though maybe I should go and see someone and try to get stronger mentally and try to formulate some sort of plan?
Thanks for the advise I do really appreciate you reading my rubbish!!

OP posts:
Report
doctordwt · 18/04/2012 19:24

Hi Patchi,

I remember your thread the other day.

I really do see your dilemma and I think it's truly a little different for you, NOT as simple as 'just leaving' for a whole load of reasons.

So when you ask 'when couples split do they just do it or do they have more of a plan and make sure they are all sorted type of thing' - well some do some don't, it's completely different for everyone I suppose, and in most cases depends on why you split and if things are amicable... But NONE of that matters in your case - you have so many particular factors to consider that I don't think you can look to 'what other people do' to help you out. Here are the things that I have been thinking about with regard to your situation - I've been thinking about you today! - I hope it might help.

Firstly, you and your husband. It sounds as if things are over for you but there's a nagging doubt. That is natural - he's the father of your children, he is 'trying' - etc. What I would say is that, until/unless you get to the point where things have deteriorated so much that you literally cannot bear the sight of him, there will ALWAYS be doubt. And it's best not to get to that point before you leave (more on that later). But what I would suggest to someone who felt torn in this way would be - get some time away from him, the relationship, your daily life, and see how you feel then. My advice on what to do RIGHT NOW would be - take the kids and go away for a break - a couple of weeks, preferably longer.

For you I think this advice goes double because of where you are. You are in a country where women are defined by marriage and the man they are with. I'm not surprised you can't imagine how to move forward without him, having spent 20 years in a country like that. So I would say - don't just take a break from him, take a break from the sexist reality you are in (! - sorry - sounds heavy - can't think of a better way to put it). You have spent your whole adult life absorbing this, sit and think about it - a part of your reaction is one you have learned - 'what can I do, who will I be without my husband - nothing.' That's the reality where you are, but it's not like that elsewhere. So again - go with your children and get out of that culture, and get some perspective on things. To hear you worry about whether you will be invited anywhere if you separate - so sad, and so hideous. That doesn't need to be your life.

So, outside of the country where you are, could you go to family or close friends for say, a month? Is there someone - you say they are all supportive of you leaving - is there someone who would step up and be there? Parents, siblings? Where are they? Could they put you up?

This brings me to how you would actually go about leaving if you did leave. The first thing to say - what is the status of your children? You are British, they were born in the ME - where is your husband from? Is he British? What I'm getting at - I'm guessing that if you split, if he wanted to prevent you leaving with them, he could? Worse than that, could he prevent you having custody of them even if you stayed in the ME?

Be warned that I have seen many, many threads on here with so many women in shock, saying 'I never, ever thought he would be capable of doing x' when their relationship broke down. So if your instinctive answer to my question above is 'He could stop me, he would have custody automatically according to the law here, but he would never do that to me/us' - just stop right there. Think the worst. Honestly. This goes back to my point above - it's best to leave before things get to the point where you really can't bear the sight of each other. For your situation, with the type of law you live under, you really might be better off with the element of surprise.

You can see where I'm going with this. My advice would be: go for a visit to relatives, for a month, enough time to think through options and make a decision. And if you decide that you want to go ahead with leaving him, then don't go back. You may think that you know how he'd react if you told him you were leaving. I would bet you a month's wage that you don't. You already don't trust him. For goodness sake, whatever happens, don't put yourself in the position of letting him get a step ahead and preventing you from leaving by using the law to stop you. Don't take that risk. It something that women in this country don't have to worry about - for you, it should be the biggest consideration when you plan if or how you leave.

That brings us straight to two big things. Firstly, money. So that all sounds very easy, get away, make your decision with a clearer mind - then what? This is where you need to do your research (make sure you cover internet tracks). If there is a country which would be a very obvious 'better bet' to go for your visit to (presume EU) - then go there. If there's a place where you know that you and your children could have a home for, say, six months - then go there. Ask your family and friends for practical help as well as the support they've been offering - is there a temporary home somewhere where you would be eligible for any social help? This may have to end up being the UK, at some point - check it all out. Maybe post in legal, or expats? And your business. Could you make a go of it in any other location?

At the end of the day, you'll manage because you have to. I suppose a worst case scenario is you coming to the UK, going to a refuge, from there to temporary accomodation and after that social housing. And you would find a job, eventually.

Not a brilliant prospect in many ways. This brings me to what you would actually want for the future out of this. In many ways, the hardest part of all this is that actually, you are settled where you are and it feels like home. You have friends there. You moved there when you were a young adult, you know nowhere else as an adult. In a way, I think that's totally working against you. I would say that I would be almost certain that if you were to spend even a year in a country where women are NOT second class citizens, then your eyes would be opened. Do you really want to stay? You say your children have a brilliant standard of living there - do they? Do you have a daughter? Do you want her to grow up knowing nothing but the way a woman has to live in that society? To never get to have friends of both sexes, to never know equality in her own country? Do you have a son? Do you want him to grow up absorbing as a fact that women are inferior? You say yourself that 'you would never be able to meet another man' and illustrate very well how difficult a life it would be as a divorced woman in the country you are in. But you don't have to be that woman. You aren't a national of that country and you don't have to live that life. It would mean leaving behind twenty years of roots being put down and would be the biggest bravest thing that you have ever done. But I think that is the choice, really. Things won't get better within your relationship. Outside of your relationship, in that society, it would be grim. Your best chance for a REAL, fulfilling life would seem to be in another country - where you would not be curtailed socially or economically simply for being a single woman. So maybe that is the last point to think about. What is it that would keep you there, and is it worth the sacrifice? Friends can travel. And I can say too, at about (I think) the same age as you, after many many moves, new cities, and new friends - and we're not done with that yet - you are too young to settle for this if it's not what you want. It's worth the upheaval, you've got probably another forty or more years in you. Too many to waste. You WILL make new friends and a new life, you will. I am guessing that it just doesn't seem like that after so long living in the particular situation you have been.

Wow - WHAT A POST!!!!!

Report
doctordwt · 18/04/2012 19:24
Report
LittleHouseofCamelias · 18/04/2012 19:36

Hear Hear!!

Report
izzyizin · 18/04/2012 19:38


Wow, that's one smokin' hot gun keyboard you've got there, doc Grin

Applauds doc's well reasoned and pertinent advice - and sincerely hopes that patchi will act on it.
Report
izzyizin · 18/04/2012 19:39

Now then, Camelias... you should know better than to mention claps around a doctor Grin

Report
Just1willdo · 18/04/2012 19:43

Hi OP, your'e not the only one with no mates..I don't have any either!

Report
BranchingOut · 19/04/2012 08:38

That is an amazing post.

Report
Anniegetyourgun · 19/04/2012 08:45

I love you, drdwt.

Report
patchi · 19/04/2012 11:29

yes I think I love you too dr!! thank you so much and i am crying and so touched that you would be thinking about me and post all that!!
and thanks to everyone else too!!!
I actually did some snooping this morning (have not done for 5 years after our last episode the ones that spurned me on to start my own business in the event I might end up on my own) and surprise surprise found an email straight away to another woman all rather vomit inducing think they are star crossed lovers with me getting in the way. it also bizarrly said how much he loved me and wanted to sort things out with me. i am not sure but it seemed to be from one of the women he was emailing back from before (5 years ago and referreed to the fact they had not seen each other for 3 years wtf!)Anyway one good thing is at least I know I am doing the right thing splitting up and am not actually going mad. He has been so over the top nice to me I was thinking he is such a nice guy and I'm making a mistake.
Anyway I have made an appointment to see a lawyer here so I can kind of find out some facts re exactly where I stand although I am hoping we can do things amicably.
We are both british btw and married in UK which aparently does give me more rights.
I have also started looking at some flats and cheaper villa's I could move to - they are all miles away from where I need to live but at least there are options.
My issue now is - do I get all my facts before I act or just kick him out tonight?
I feel like I can sit on it not angry my only concern is for the children.Ideally I want to stay in this house for now so the kids are not disrupted.
I know he doesn't have right to get custody of children and he wouldn't even try as he is a fairly disinterested dad at the best of times (but delusionally believes himself to be a great one)
I may also try and go to stay with my parents in europe but my ds has learning issues (whole other story and another reason my husband is so useless as he has not helped me with any of that at all) and has an important assesment in 2 weeks re what we need to do with him and school so worried to leave right now and go on holiday iyswim.
you are right living here does knock your confidence and makes you lose a grasp on reality really and I am thinking about moving back as well but don't want to panic act and then regret it for the sake of dc.
God have you read this far!!

OP posts:
Report
patchi · 19/04/2012 11:43

Just re read your post dr and yes moving back to the UK does make more sense long term for sure.
I feel a step at a time for dc might be better for them though.
My issue as well is not so much h wanting custody of children but more of actually bothering with them at all.
If i move home he will never see them but I suppose that wouldn't be a bad thing :0)
I pretty much know all they (and I) will be to him is a sob story in the pub about what a bitch his ex wife is. He loves to be the victim
thank you so much once again

OP posts:
Report
patchi · 19/04/2012 12:13

sorry just one thing is that I have an irrational fear (based on dm crap we read here) that schools in Uk are hotbed of bullying and drugs etc and it scares me to death to send dc to school in uk.
Here the kids are totally innocent (till secondary) and I sort of like it that they have that sort of old fashioned child hood??
It's probably not like that at all is it?

OP posts:
Report
MooveyMover · 22/04/2012 22:47

Patchi, please let that be the least of your worries. I think that your DC could come to school in the UK, get a great education and be very happy.

Schools in the UK are for everyone - yes, that does mean that some social problems creep into schools, but schools are set up to deal with that and if you are a bit careful about where you live then you should be fine. Please don't let the DM scare you off making a change in your life!

The innocence you talk of sounds wonderful, but it sounds as if you live in quite a repressive and unequal society. Is everyone (the very poorest, migrant workers' children, different ethnicities etc) entitled to go to school where you are? It may be that the same issues are just being 'edited out' where you are but other issues (lack of freedom, inequality between the sexes) have taken their place...

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.