Mumsnet Talk

This story is in my local paper today. You may find it distressing. I certainly did.

In brief it features a mum who was living with her young son and baby and partner in a one bed flat in York. The flat was damp. The council knew it was damp but as the one bedroom was very crowded condensation etc was seeminly inevitable. The family were filmed by the Guardian for their poverty series. 4 weeks after filming the baby died sudenly. No cause has yet been found for her death.

I live in York. I am bitterly ashamed to live in a city where such a thing could happen. The pictures in the film remind me of those from the late 19th/early 20th century when so much pioneering work was done combating poverty. The film is heartbreaking (i'm at work so i haven't yet heard it with the sound up). Baby Telan should be happy and healthy. If she was my child the statistics say that she would probably still be happy and healthy but her parents were poor and so she's dead. I can't believe that happens in 2012.

Or maybe it's just me?

It's very tragic - you are right, no one should be living like that in 2012. Unfortunately , the mother would have no recourse with the council until the toxicology & histology reports are done in regards to her daughters death - none of which would bring the child back anyway

I'm going to write to our MP about it. I know he has a strong interest in social policy anyway.

It is tragic that she died but I do wish they had waited till they had all test results before publishing the article. The damp may have contributed to her death, or she may have had an undetected health problem or something else I would not know about.

This us probably going to terrify parents living in damp houses, either their own or rented and it may not have been the cause.

I hope the family get moved soon or manage to find a private rental.

It is tragic. Truly it is

But I can't help wondering why people continually bring children ito these type of environments - the description and photograph looks horrendous and certainly not the type of place I could bring a child home to

Harsh, I know and the situation is bleak but you have to put your children's first and of that means not having them well so be it

Well Korma they don't have her now do they?

When the baby was born they thought they would eventually be re-housed, that the flat they were in was temporary. They have been rehoused now but it's too late. The council should be ensuring everybody who requires social houseing is safely housed. That didn't happen for this family and another family referenced in teh Guardian article here had a similar situation.

"But I can't help wondering why people continually bring children ito these type of environments"



Fucking poor people having children. It oughtn't be allowed.

Yeah I pretty much expected that response

But I'll stand by it - if you cannot adequately house, feed, educate , clothe a child then it is not ideal to have them

She already had one child living in total poverty

It might not be "ideal" to have them, but to bring that argument to bear on the death of a baby is fucking shameful.

This country is fucked while such ugly moralising is socially acceptable.

It is very sad indeed. But the mum is clean and dressed well. I have seen so many far worse places where a child is being brought up.

Korma - you can't choose your life and should not judge others.

Korma - do you mean in your posts to effectively blame those parents for the death of their child? Not failures by the local council or the national government who have a legal responsibility to house them safely but the parents? Is that the impression you mean to give?

That is so incredibly sad. Mould is known to be harmful - I'm sure I've reaad this in numerous places. Poor family and baby caught in the poverty trap.

No I absolutely do not blame the parents for the baby's death

I cannot imagine the pain they are in, I'm not completely heartless

I just don't like the blame being placed in the government/ housing dept etc

It was a tragedy but that aside, I think it is a parents duty to adequately house their child. Yes you may need help but I think the responsibility to house a child is the parents - the government are not responsible for our decisions

But I don't have the energy to argue about it so ill leave you to it

Or perhaps the argument is that this little girl is no loss to the world since she should never have been born to her feckless parents?

The parents did the best they could to bear that responsibility. Family houses are expensive to rent in York. When we were looking 14 years ago dh was earning 13,000 and we couldn't afford to rent. What saved us was being able to buy but the same house now costs around 4 times as much.

"I just don't like the blame being placed in the government/ housing dept etc"

She was their tenant.

If she died because the housing they provided was damp, then it is their fault.

Your morality has to be seriously corroded to blame a tenant for their own poor housing because they should be able to afford better.

Korma -unless someone is wealthy enough to own their own home, and yes these days you need to be very wealthy to buy for the first time, then they are always at risk of poor living conditions. Rents are exhorbitant in many areas, landlords are so frequently total crooks and the law is seemingly non existent in practice. It is shameful, and to not understand/acknowledge this is pretty poor as well.

Sorry but I agree with Korma, she got pregnant and had her 2nd child whilst already living in obviously inadequate accommodation. Why didn't they wait until they had been rehoused? Possibly because they thought a second child would increase their chances of a move. Also the report states they had a dog as well, no doubt compounding the problem.
I would never in a million years have planned to bring a baby into that environment. Having a baby is not a right, and you need to take some responsibility and ensure that you are able to support yourself and your family, not rely on benefits and expect free housing.

Athing - you are twisting my words and clearly looking for an argument
At no point did I say it wasn't terrible or she won't be missed

We're currently renting. It's a nice cottage, nicely dn

I'm really not looking for an argument.

I feel too nauseated by the kind of unspeakable arseholes I apparently share a country with to have the stomach for it.

Saying something is terrible while you justify it and blame the victims is not worth a lot really. Is it?

We're currently renting. It's a nice cottage, nicely done up, as good as we can afford. We have mould everywhere and it isn't through lack of ventilation or any of the other crap they spout to blame tenants. The place is built with poor quality stone and has been inappropriately modernised. I worry about my children's health every day, but thank god their room is the only one without mould. We are doing the best we possibly can. But perhaps you should only be able to have children if you can livein a house you own? Maybe a pre-conception inspection would be n

We're currently renting. It's a nice cottage, nicely done up, as good as we can afford. We have mould everywhere and it isn't through lack of ventilation or any of the other crap they spout to blame tenants. The place is built with poor quality stone and has been inappropriately modernised. I worry about my children's health every day, but thank god their room is the only one without mould. We are doing the best we possibly can. But perhaps you should only be able to have children if you can livein a house you own? Maybe a pre-conception inspection would be in order?

Oh dear,sorry! Damned touchscreen keyboard!