Hooray I have my shortlists, opinions needed!!

[esmeraldasmith]

sorry they're a bit boring

Estella
Tess
Matilda
Catherine
Milly
Alexandra
Isabel

Noah
Felix
Leon
George
Oscar
Finlay

[crunchynutter]

My initial reaction would be Milly or Isobel and George or Oscar! Some lovely names though. Good luck! Xx

[Iklboo]

I adore Milly & Isabel, Noah & Oscar

[Nbg]

The only girls one I really like is Matilda and the boys I like Oscar and Felix.

[MrsMattie]

Girls - Alexandra and Tess are both gorgeous. Milly, Matilda, Isabel - a bit played out in current times, but that may not bother you? Catherine - not to my taste, but classic.

Boys - Really don't like any of them but Leon, sorry!

[MrsMattie]

Oh - like Estelle or Estrella, but Estella sounds a bit made up.

[Mamazon]

I like Milly but it is getting quite well used.

i would go for Isobel and Matilda or George and Oscar

[MamaG]

Estella - don't like it
Tess - like it
Matilda - like it
Catherine - like it
Milly - like it
Alexandra - LOVE it
Isabel - meh

Noah - yes
Felix - yes if you're a bit posh
Leon - yes
George - yes
Oscar - yes
Finlay - bit "now" imo

[welovepinkmilk]

Love:
Tess
Matilda
Catherine
Alexandra - wanted this for my dd but overruled by dh
Isabel

Only really like Noah from boys names. Used to love Finlay but now all I think of is the fire engine!

[branflake81]

Estella - NO, don't like
Tess - Like it
Matilda - Don't like
Catherine - OK
Milly - No way
Alexandra - Love it
Isabel - Like it

Noah = No, too trendy
Felix - No, too weird
Leon = Yes, like it
George - Not bad
Oscar - Not bad
Finlay - a bit trendy

[UpForAir]

Matilda
Isabel

Felix

[IllegallyBrunette]

Like Matilda and Alexandra for the girls.

Noah, George and Finlay for the boys.

[castille]

Matilda, shortened to Tilly. Much prefer "proper" names to abbreviations as given names.

Oscar for a boy.

[ethanchristopher]

this is my order of preference

1. milly (i LOVE it)
2. isabella (cause i dont like isabel)
3. catherine
4. estella
5. alexandra
6. Tess
7. matilda

1. finlay
2. felix
3. noah
4. oscar
5. leon
6. george

[Stars22]

Estella - Dont really like
Tess - Is ok but sounds astho its short for something
Matilda- Might get shortened to Tilly
Catherine- Ok bit old fashioned imo.
Milly- is ok, not great
Alexandra- nice, i like it shortened to Alex for a girl.
Isabel- Dont like , also there are too many around.

Noah- Dont like
Felix-Cat
Leon- HATE
George -Nice
Oscar- dont like
Finlay - I like this one but prefer it spelt Finley.

This is only my opinion i dont mean to offend anyone.

[chocolatemummy]

like Estelle......but that is my dd name and still quite unusual thankfully. but Estella is a bit of a strange version

Like Noah too

[seeker]

Why not go for Theresa and Matilda shortened to Tess and Milly to give her more options?

[Reginaphilangy]

Estella - really don't like.
Tess - lovely.
Matilda - don't like this.
Catherine - lovely and love Cate as nn.
Milly - gorgeous! but prefer the spelling Millie
Alexandra - like alexandra and nn ali. absolutely can't stand the nn alex!
Isabel - lovely. very popular.

Noah - don't like this.
Felix - really like felix.
Leon - don't like this.
George - great name!
Oscar - like this.
Finlay - really don't like this.

My favourites from your list are Milly or Isabel for a girl and George, Felix or Oscar for a boy.

[Moomin]

think they are all lovely. Only thing I;d say is that Isabel is really really popular a the moment and she is likely to be one of 4 or 5 in any given class in the future!