Eden or Ellen

[FlowerBellll]

Edie or Ellie?

[VinylScratch]

Eden.

[AuntieStella]

Ellen/Ellie

(I'm not wild about boys names on girls)

[ThroughThickAndThin01]

Ellen

[Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost]

Ellie.

[xmasseason]

Edie but short for Edith.

[FlowerBellll]

It's funny, I'm not that keen on Edith, so it is def between Eden or Ellen

[WhyCantIuseTheNameIWant]

Eden

[perpetuallybewildered]

Ellen - no contest.

[Pobspits]

Ellen or Edie not Eden or Ellie!!!!

There are ALOT of Edens here but haven't met a little Ellen

[BendydickCuminsnatch]

Ellen but not Ellie! Ellie is so overdone. Does Ellen really need a shortening? All the Ellens I know are just Ellen, and it's a lovely little-used name :) don't know any little Ellens.
Eden is pretty too though but more popular IME!

[SinisterBumFacedCat]

Eden definitely

[Pancakeflipper]

Ellen because the Ellen I know is one of the most lovely people I know. Whereas the Eden I know is a bit of a cow. Illogical reasoning but I've had some wine.

[IoraRua]

In contrast to pancake, the only Ellen I know is a total bitch
I like Eden. Ellen is a bit drab in my opinion...and I thought that before I met the wagon.

[NadiaWadia]

Eden is lovely. And it's not a boy's name (I mean I know it sometimes is, but it sounds a lot more feminine to me).

Ellen is nice enough though, although I prefer Eleanor or Helena, or even Helen. Ella is pretty too, though a bit over-popular.

[DragAct]

Ellen. Eden sounds like a tiresome teenage boy band member.

[ThursdayLastWeek]

Ellen or Edie.

I love Edie short for Edith

[Chewbecca]

I always think Ellen sounds like Helen with the 'h' dropped (Essex so inevitable).

[Purplehonesty]

I like them both. Probably Eden for me tho; never met anyone called Eden.

[spring1bee]

I love them both but for different reasons. Ellen to me is very traditional, classic and elegant whereas Eden is a bit more edgy and "out there." I agree with others though that Edie is a lovely nn for Eden but Ellie is very overdone.

[YeOldeTrout]

Ellen. We know one (clever, nice, Queen Bee) who is 14.
Eden sounds hippy or religious. Are you hippies?

[spring1bee]

(having said that, I know a 16 year old Eden from a very "hoity-toity" UC family who chose it because of the family's roots in Eden Valley in Cumbria)

[AMT2512]

I like them both :) I think I prefer Eden, but prefer Ellie... I'd go with Eden!

[Vixxfacee]

Eden but edie is ruining the name.

[bruffin]

Ellie, eden is awful

[xmasseason]

Ellen

I like Edie but not Eden