Thoughts on short list for boys names

[MrsRadicchio]

Just wanted some views as DH and I cannot really settle on a name for DS2 who is due imminently. We are thinking of:
-Evan
-Alexander
-Toby
-Joel

DS1 has a short name too (seem to like 4 letter boys names!) which is not too popular but well known, and easy to pronounce. Were hoping for something similar for DS2.

Any other suggestions are also welcome!

TIA

[AlwaysHoldingOnToStarbug]

I love them all!

Toby is really popular round here, I know loads of them.

There are 2 Alexander's in my youngests class but I don't know any others.

Joel is one of my favourite names, and I adore Evan.

[forevergreek]

I like Joel Alexander

[TodaysAGoodDay]

My nephew is called Evan so I'm a bit partial. It never gets shortened to anything else either. Good choice OP.

[forgetmenots]

Love Toby (and Tobias with Toby nn)
Also like:
Noah
Jonah
Finn

[Rhubarbgarden]

I like Evan. How about Edgar?

[popcal]

I like them all especially Joel Alexander( ds1)!

[MollyMurphy]

I like Toby - I think it's really cute

[OutragedFromLeeds]

-Evan - nice
-Alexander - nice, but I'd avoid if you want something not too popular, I know about 35 under the age of 8.
-Toby - sweet, I like Tobias with nn Toby better.
-Joel - not for me, it's awful in my accent.

I'd go with Tobias Alexander or Evan Alexander

[FellatioNelson]

I like Evan best.

Alexander is nice, classic, nothing to dislike really.

Toby not wild about it but don't hate it.

Joel don't really like, but I can't exactly say why.

[lottiegarbanzo]

Nice list. Alexander is by far the most popular name there, really quite prevalent at the moment.

[lottiegarbanzo]

So of those I'd choose Evan or Toby (Tobias) probably with Alexander as middle name.

[LaGuerta]

I'd go for Joel or Evan. I like Alexander and Toby, but there are a fair few of them around in my experience.