ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
To think being older doesnt necessarily deserve you more respect regardless of behaviour?(33 Posts)
I'm watching CBB and Janice and Les Battersby are both in there. Les is raging at everyone and has shouted at various people, mainly women. Charlotte (in her twenties) raged back at him and swore at him and told him to leave another young woman alone. Now Janice is saying that she can't believe Charlotte can speak to an older man with such disrespect. But Les is shouting at her and other young women with no respect at all (and is actually quite scary!). I don't get why he (and Janice) think other people should respect his behaviour when their (similar) behaviour angers him so much.
I think this applies to people in real life sometimes too where they expect to be treated with respect because of their age despite them being completely twattish in behaviour.
Am I being unreasonable to think age doesn't automatically deserve more respect regardless of behaviour?
I have a basic level of respect and politeness that I use for everyone, regardless of age, unless they act in a way that makes it difficult for me to respect them. I do not make allowances for age with this. Elderly people do not get an extra chance just because they are old. If they are rude, condescending, obstructive or deliberately awkward, they will get the same short shrift as anyone else with these behaviours.
YANBU OP. Unfortunately there is a demographic of older folk who believe they are entitled to the utmost respect regardless of their behaviour because of their age. I've found that its people like this who have a 'children should be seen and not heard' mentality and would think nothing of behaving appalling towards those younger than them. My husband's elderly GM is one of these people, and she's vile (has been regardless of age).
Age has nothing to do with respect, nor should it.
I respect everybody unless they lose that respect. IMO respect is something that is lost, not earned.
I try to judge people by their characters. Young or old does not deserve priority/respect just based on age alone.
I think ageism is vile and sign of an uneducated cunt.
Older people will be naturally more vulnerable and should be treated as such and cared for, but just because someone has more years than someone else does not mean their views are automatically correct.
lucille I completely agree with you.
I quite often feel really bad for groups of teenagers. They get such bad press. I've asked groups of teenagers (even the really 'rough' looking ones) to help me carry a pushchair down steps or help in other ways and I've yet to have anything other than a positive response.
It's amazing you know, if you treat them like 'normal people', that's how they tend to behave....
The behaviour of some older people towards younger people is shocking sometimes.
Being older than me doesn't mean they deserve respect more. You simply can't base respect upon age alone it is about the person not how old they are.
I respect everyone equally, regardless of their age or any other factor.
what's wrong with showing a little extra regard for someone who is senior, in appreciation for their age and experiences
I actually don't even understand that. I don't understand what bearing their age and experience would have on me and why I'd need to appreciate it.
However, if they are an arse, then I would also withdraw that respect. Regardless of age or any other factor.
Sirzy, to advocate respecting elders doesn't automatically imply that younger people shouldn't be respected. All humans beings should be given respect but what's wrong with showing a little extra regard for someone who is senior, in appreciation for their age and experiences?
Also, I suppose it also depends on how each of us define 'respect'.
Respect can mean different things.
If it means "give consideration to physical and emotional vulnerability" then I think youngsters should be taught to respect older people (and anybody else who may need it).
If it means "feel feelings of deep admiration regardless of actual fact", then no, it's not something I'd expect from my dc.
If it means "behave politely regardless of your inner feelings", then again I am generally in favour.
So if old people should be respected simply because they are old does that mean young people don't deserve respect?
I feel older people should be respected just because they're older, especially older members of the family such as grandparents. Their behaviour is another issue separate from respect. If they are rude or impolite in some way, that shouldn't affect the way you are with them. I'd like to think my children would be courteous and polite to older family members and others in the community regardless of how they came across and that their own behaviour and politeness wouldn't diminish just because others were not graceful enough to appreciate it.
We have some difficult relatives. My children are teenagers and they do come back and tell me occasionally how rude a certain family member was and how annoyed they were by him/her, but I love that my kids have learnt not to emulate that behaviour and be rude to losers who are rude to them. They do try to keep to their own standards of good conduct and not let others set the tone.
Rudeness from their peers or strangers who are nasty, spiteful or racist is another thing though. In that case, I would encourage them to stand up for themselves in whatever way they needed to even if it meant being disrespectful.
That's my way of dealing with things though. I don't expect others around me to act that way because each person will have their own standard of what is acceptable and what is not. As long as you are generally polite to those around you and respectful to others in general, regardless of age, then you're fine.
I start in a position of neutrality - politeness and manners until it's proven otherwise.
I respect very few people, young or old - to me it's something that has to be earned. That doesn't mean I don't respect their rights to be dealt with politely & respectfully.
Unless they do something that'll take me out of that mode in which case I'll treat them appropriately.
Actually, a person is a person.
I was watching last night too and was thinking of starting a post saying the same. Surely an adult is an adult.
I don't think that simply enduring the passage of time entitles anyone to anything.
Respect is earned, not demanded.
I automatically respect human beings. If they act in a completely disrespectful way, then that respect is withdrawn. It has nothing to do with their age.
I remember trying to explain this to my parents as a young person, growing up and rebelling against the attitude I had been raised with; to respect one's elders. I gave childish examples at the time about older murderers or older rapists, but it was never properly understood.
I respect older people for their superior life experience. This, however, can be negated if they show a negative life experience in the way they have treated or continue to treat others.
Oh I agree OP. My SIL and I took DS1 and his cousin both 11 to the British Museum last week to see the Pompeii exhibition, they were impeccably behaved but we had three separate incidents with older ladies. The first was in the line to pick up tickets, the boys were stood at the exit with me and an older lady just held her hand in their faces to get them to move, she obviously couldn't say excuse me, there was another exit she could have used, the place was practically empty, they were then tutted at for just walking with the crowd, the last straw was when they were sat down watching a short film a lady bounded over and told then to move up in a very nasty tone so she and her husband could sit down.
They had as much right to be in that museum as anyone else, in fact young people looking at the charred remains of Roman artefacts and engaging with their story is surly something to be encouraged. I feel sorry for young boys out and about, they seemed to be singled out just for being bumbling young boys.
Yes I saw big brother I was
as I don't really even class him as old! He must be 60 ish? My parents are 65 and do not think they expect any kind of extra kindness or respect as they are of sound mind and body.
The only time I think it would apply is if it was concerning an elderly person who was no longer of sound mind but that goes without saying really.
I have come to the conclusion vicky and Bruce were just playing themselves in corrie!
But that is nothing to do with age. Those who go on about "respecting your elders" are generally the type who do sit in judgement of others.
Too often respect is seen as a one way thing with the expectation that everyone will respect you simply because you are older. That isn't how respect works.
surzy you start from a position of respect though, don't sit in judgement before deciding whether people deserve respect from you. Sure, if people show you they don't deserve it then fine but you don't sit in judgement first like some stroppy teen thinking people have to prove their worth to you before you respect them.
Yes automatically respect older people
That almost implies you wouldn't automatically respect younger people?
Respect shouldn't be about age it should be about actions. I will respect anyone as long as they behave in such a way to deserve respecting. The idea of "respect your elders" is wrong because in some cases they don't act in such a way to deserve such respect.
No point in treating someone with respect if they treat you with contempt. I think you should treat people how they treat you.
We were getting on a boat last week and there were some older people that were very rude. Instead of just waiting in the queue, a group of them were pushing and jostling to get on first. Lots of tutting and hairy eyeballs. One lady pushed ds 6 and nearly had him over. The jetty was on an incline and he couldn't stop and so pushed the,people in front. It was packed, and we arrived early with a family with two young children. Despite them being at the front they were almost last on.
I think some older people do,expect reverential respect due to their age. I think you should treat everyone with equal respect at first and then treat as you find.
I have pain and a mobility problem and have issues standing. This isn't obvious by looking at me. I'm still happy to give my seat up for elderly people. Manners don't have an upper age limit.
Great post Cailin. No, they don't deserve more respect because they are old but now I'm approaching mid 50's I feel people are more helpful and make fewer slightly snippy comments. Maybe people have changed but I'm not snapped at now to "get out of my way, etc" on the tube or in a supermarket as I sometimes was in my 20s.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.