Mumsnet Talk

Vinegar obviously both are fine but I presumed OP was Welsh because there were a few Welsh names dotted through the lists.

Both are fine isn't quite what you said initially I assume if she's Welsh herself she'd know the Welsh pronunciation. Here in London I've only met "dillon"s and would pronounce it like that unless the parents told me otherwise.

Sorry Vinegar,I think sometimes I type forgetting that it will come across differently to how it would if it was a speaking conversation,so it doesn't always end up reading how I meant it to.

Hah, this is Baby Names, it's meant to be about loves and hates! No need to apologise!

Dylan pronounced Dillon is fine. It's DS2 name and when we went on holiday to Wales they all pronounced it Dillon too.

I think all of the names are perfectly lovely. Please don't let yourself get paranoid - I had some reactions like you've described when we called our first daughter Ivy - but we weathered it and I'm so happy I never let anyone else's opinions affect my choice.

One of my daughters is called Greer and EVERYONE has an opinion on it. At the end of the day, I love her name, her Daddy was talked round to it ;) and it really suits her. My criteria was that I wanted my children to each have a name that nobody else in their schoolclass had, but which wasn't totally wacky. If people don't like their names, that's their trouble If they express to you that they don't like the name of your child, that's downright rude imho. If you can't say anything nice, say nothing at all.

I love Greer.

I love greer too Never heard it before as a christian name

Greer Garson, old time actress.

Greer Robson, not quite so old time actress

That's who I like to mention, everyone usually asks if I named her after Germaine Greer since I'm a bit of a manhating feminist

All fine except Haylie (Surely its Hayley) and Robbie (chavvy).

I hope your kids aren't called Haylie and Robbie.

Mind you when people hear my kids names the comment is always 'ooohhh very middle class' which I am but still grates a little. I would always be gracious about someone's choice of name even if I didn't like it.

Oh and another comment we get is 'are you German' ha ha so what if I am!

Just don't sweat it I am trying to say as long as you like them ignore other people.

Madame, you didn't read all of OP's posts did you?

GIRLS:-
sophie, nice
kiera, nice
ruby, nice but very popular
elin, LOVE
bethan, meh, sounds a bit dumpy to my ear
erin, sweet, short name; I wouldn't use it as I'm Irish but not a bad name
seren, LOVE
brooke, has a harsh sound imo
maisie, too nicknamey imo
mollie, too old ladyish imo
haylie, nice, sounds like a name for a girl who does sports, is outgoing...
layla, like a lot
jasmine, like a lot

BOYS:-
joseph, LOVE
flynn, don't like -- makes me think 'skinflint' and also an Irish surname
jack, like but very popular
arthur, it's ok, for some reason I like the E European Artur spelling
rhys, like a lot
robbie, like if short for Robert
henry, like a lot
ellis, like
toby, like
oliver, LOVE even though it's popular
jacob, ok, maybe a bit dated
james, like
dylan, like
alfie, dislike
logan, nice

(Love Greer)

The only really crap name from your list is Maisie, imo

Only like Sophie out of girls although Bethan OK.
Boys like James, Oliver, Henry,Joseph, Jack and not the rest.

We chose Seren as a middle name in the end, it means Star in Welsh, after reading so many comments saying they've never heard of it. I wanted it as a first name but OH wanted Isabelle too much. Although the reason we chose Seren was because of the word Serendipity, which means a happy accident. Haha, kinda fitted! But if she asks, it means star.

I love Erin also.

The rest are lovely, some a little common but still pretty. But can't stand Ruby. Always think of some pornographic skank of a model or a dingy club.

Boys names are all lovely. Out of them Robbie is actually my least favourite, but it works for you and that's what matters. Couldn't have Jack/Alfie/Charlie because all our dogs are named those. I love Logan!! We love Zachary as well.

Love your boys names.

We struggled ver the names of our last DC, we got Luke warm responses in RL but one of them is on your list and has a great responses on here!

I remember feeling awful about DDs name before I came to terms within any it suits her and I love it.