Hide
Mumsnet

Should I take it as read that benefits threads always go the same way?

(5 Posts)
nkf Fri 03-Feb-12 19:48:39

I mean, it's in the news and it's obviously a big change to the benefit system. And I feel I know very little about the system and the changes have made me aware of that. So I click on the threads and, somehow they're all the same. Polarised, jeering and I end up none the wiser. Is the topic in the "can't be discussed" properly?

TwoIfBySea Fri 03-Feb-12 19:53:29

Very much so.

It always ends up near hysteria.

nkf Fri 03-Feb-12 20:07:00

Ends up? They sometimes start that way!

CogitoErgoSometimes Sat 04-Feb-12 10:09:24

The subject can't be discussed intelligently on a message board, no. The two dominant views are 'all benefit claimants are lazy, on the fiddle &undeserving of help', 'all benefit claimants are honest, unlucky, & poverty-stricken' and never the twain shall meet. Which is a pity really because, in reality, welfare is a complex issue which affects the make-up of society as a whole & is very easy to get wrong due to the laws of unintended consequences.

nkf Sat 04-Feb-12 13:36:39

That seems to be the way. And the dominant views do just that - dominate. There must be more level headed opinions on MN. I'll just have to have RL conversations about it.

Add your message here

To post you need a valid nickname and password. Log in if you are a returning member, or join for free.

If you have forgotten your nickname or your password, you can get a reminder.