ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
To confess I don't donate to charity(130 Posts)
Not because I'm evil, I just don't trust them.
The only 'charitable' things I do is donate to church, I'm brownie group leader, help out at the local stables and students who need very hard to get but needed work experience for my line if work.
Am I going to hell?
I've just been made to feel guilty by not donating to RND by peers.
I honestly won't donate until they have a list on the website showing every penny spent and where it ha gone.
This is a lively, thought-provoking and possibly controversial talk about the effectiveness of charities paying high salaries, spending lots of marketing, and achieving goals quickly.
Well worth watching if you're interested in the sector.
It's fairly quick to research which charities are most effective though
scroll down the page to see different ways you can choose to work it out.
The "Give Directly" charity for example simply transfers money to poor households in Kenya - over 90% of what you give.
Well, I don't have a DD set up. But i give to , sponsorship forms, every time ds1 has a dress up day at school. Dropping money into boxes as I pass in town centres. letting ds1 and ds2 put 2p/5p into slot in tesco where coin goes round and round etc, which they ADORE.
It is enough. I think.
HillBilly76 Wed 20-Mar-13 01:07:50
"Charities are a con. They just exist to make people feel better about themselves and to give well-paid jobs to otherwise unemployable lefties. If you want to give money to the poor, cut out the middleman and give money directly to the poor. "
Where were you when I was sobbing my heart out because the hospital refused to let dd borrow a wheelchair? And did you even have a second-hand wheelchair to spare?
If we were all to travel to Africa with our individual gifts to to individual refugees won't that be an awful waste of money that could go to the people in genuine need instead?
Oh, and HillBilly, I know someone who thinks the same. She's a right uninformed twat and I suspect a bit of a
Oh comfy you have made me giggle, tapping the side if your nose and winking "confidentiality"
Look, if you have been working on end year accounts which hide something of that scale and the salary does not appear in the audited and published accounts ( as available to everybody on the charity commission website) then really you need to be considering that this is fraud and should be reported.
Otoh, i actually dont believe you.
HillBilly, giving money direct to the poor is all well and good but charities do so much more, often in areas of life where most of us don't even know there is a need. Some charities bring change not only to individuals but to society as a whole.
People need more than a handout. Some need expert advice, skilled listening support, regular services. Some would like a cure for cancer or better understanding of what Alzheimer's is doing to their spouse.
HillBilly, what a ridiculous post! Charities don't just help the poor - I work for a children's hospice - how do you suggest people "cut out the middle man" with our charity?
I buy the Big Issue. Wish I could do more, because the homeless are treated like scum in this country (not the UK).
In the UK I used to donate to Cancer research every so often. I ignore chuggers and am quite short with door-to-door collectors.
A charity is just a business, like any other? I hate how every charity, no matter how genuine is tarred with the brush of big business.
My DPs (both in their 70s) are heavily involved a tiny, local charity. They helped found it, have found volunteers to help them, spend many, many hours every week doing the admin they need to raise funds via grants, keep grant providers happy and ensure volunteers are trained and CRB checked.
Neither they nor any of the volunteers have ever made a penny out of the charity. All the money raised is spent on funding materials/venues/creches etc. for the people that the charity supports.
They never ask members of the public for donations. They would be devastated to know that so many people see them as money grabbing con artists .
Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.
I donate to charities when I choose to. I dislike being asked. Or having tins rattled at me in the street. There are certain charities I think do good work - and I'll chuck a couple of quid in a tin if I see them. Others I don't actually 'feel the love' for and resent other people trying to guilt me into donating to them. It's a very personal thing IMO. So yes...I'm sure the WWF do a fantastic job. But I don't care greatly about saving the white tiger or whatever. I'd rather give my money to the NSPCC perhaps. I think my main feeling is that there are just too many charities, all wanting money. And my budget is pretty limited.
I get really irritated by people wanting me to donate to 'their' pet cause. You might support British Heart Foundation. I might support Cancer Research. Probably for family reasons, as you/I have lost family members to this specific illness. It doesn't mean yours isn't a great charity. It just means I choose to donate to something different - and I can't afford to donate to everything.
We don't give monthly money donations to charity however I donate all our old clothes and items to jumble sales or charity shops. I also buy items from charity shops etc. I recon over the years they have made a small fortune on my back.
In this context I am always reminded of the salutary and moral tale of the Chevalier Bayard in the 15th century
or whenever it was. He was walking along with his squire one day and came across some ladies whom he naturally saluted in his polite and chivalrous way.
- But my lord, exclaimed the shocked squire, do you know who those ladies are that you are saluting so humbly? They are... public ladies!
-Verily, said the Chevalier, I would rather salute a hundred public ladies than run the risk of omitting to salute one real lady.
I am happy to run the risk of funding a few charity workers, paying for the paperwork and possibly even funding one or two undeserving people rather than run the risk of not doing my bit to help one genuinely starving child. The latter risk seems to me the more serious.
I've worked all round the voluntary sector in my time. I assess applicants for the main leadership programme in the sector (and they are all pretty damn amazing). My partner works for one of the major funders.
Holidays? Perks? What planet are you on??
I work for a national/local charity.
I get paid a living wage. As a previous poster said, no perks, and a three year pay freeze. There is a culture of working additional hours to patch over where we don't have the resources to do what we need to achieve. Obviously we don't get paid for that.
In common with other charities we are accountable for every penny spent.
And we do quite a lot of life-changing good stuff As well by application of skill, judgement, hard work.
I am very sorry that there are untrustworthy charities out there, but there are hundreds of amazing ones too. I don't mind if people choose not to donate or donate time instead. But the lack of trust upsets me.
I understand it all and therefore you must understand what I know is confidential.
A charity is just a ''business' like any other.
And just like any other business, as MrsKeithRichards pointed out, their accounts are a matter of public record.
Here is a more recent article:
www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/1104344/ - November 2011
"The highest salary reported is £167,000."
Link to ACEVO PAy Survey 2011/2012
Sorry -sounds like a flimsy excuse not to donate. Like people who say 'charity begins at home' as a reason for not giving to overseas charities then don't give to UK charities either.
All decent charities will post their expenditure on their website. What makes you think your donation is so special that you deserve a penny by penny breakdown?
Just admit that you're too tight to give rather than hiding behind crappy excuses...same goes for many people on this thread.
Please read my posts
Tedious comfy? You're telling me it's tedious when you're there saying charity staff earn millions, get free holidays, bonuses etc etc then quantify it by saying it's true because you just know yup, that's tedious. I'd go as far as to say you're talking pish, utter pish, but I'd love you to prove me wrong.
I had an excellent experience with the Wildlife Trust recently (well done Wildlife Trust if you're reading this)
I give them a monthly donation. A lady phoned up from the local branch, thanked me for having donated for a year, and said, sounding a bit embarrassed, 'look, you're already one of our larger regular donors, and we don't like to pester people for money, but would you be able to donate a bit extra for this particular local project?'. I said I'd rather not. She said something like 'I completely understand that, and we really appreciate your regular donations'. No pressure, and I'll probably donate a bit extra for another particular project that was in the magazine.
I think its wise to give carefully to charity, you want to ensure the money is actually helping the cause rather than just paying wages etc.
I mainly stick to solely the PTA now as have a large say in how its spent and it ll goes ln the children and school. We do give to the local hospital but usually in the form of new toys or dvds etc as boredom can be rife for long term stays.
This was my post and this is why I find MN tedious at times.
If you are going to comment please make sure you understand what has been said.
*My comment on minimum wagw was meant to be tongue in cheek.
But when I read that some well know charities pay their chief executives in excess of a million pounds a year I was rather shocked.
Also I did not read this in any paper is was year end results that I was involved in.*
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.