Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

to feel like my ex-childminder is in the wrong or am I?

(35 Posts)
YouGoGlenCoCo Fri 18-Jan-13 23:44:45

I have two children, I work part-time so they go to a childminder Wednesday through to Friday.

My DS(3) has been going there for 2 years and my DD(8m) has only been going for 2 weeks.

I have never had a problem with DS however my childminder kept making comments about my DD - such as she pinches the other children. I have personally never witnessed her pinch any other child (we do a mums coffee morning every Monday, friends and neighbours have lots of young small children, she has never pinched her older brother)

There were many comments made. The final straw happened when I came to pick her up last week and the childminder said that DD is a lot of trouble and stealing and snatching toys off the other children. Erm ... she's 8mo has only just got the hang of crawling, like all babies if they see something like that they will go over and have a look at it, she doesn't have the ability to snatch and obviously wouldn't understand the concept of sharing at that age.

Anyway this was building up over 2 weeks and it was upsetting me and I felt the best thing to do was find a new childminder so I spoke to the childminder and said that I would be finding someone else. She was quite annoyed to say the least but I agree that I would give her a months notice and she would be paid for that time.

This week she hasn't even come to the door when I dropped the children off as she couldn't face me, it was her dh that opened the door to me.

Anyway, today I go to pick them up and she asked to have a word with me, and she tells me that i am making a huge mistake as my DS has made friends here and is settled and that now she would not be able to afford a holiday now etc.

aibu to think that this is emotional blackmail? and that even if I am being a bit precious, ultimately I should leave my children with someone I am comfortable with?

YANBU.

Eight months old babies do not deliberately pinch or snatch and your childminder seems to have lost sight of that.

I'd imagine leaving your baby with someone is hard and she should be trying to ease this for you by telling you positives about the day not finding negatives where there aren't any.

Has it been a while since your CM has looked after such a young child? An eight month old needs far more one to one attention than a three year old and she may be finding your daughter hard work. She's not enjoying looking after your DD and rather than admit that she's shifting the blame.

Telling you they won't be able to afford a holiday if you move the children is completely unprofessional! It's not your concern. Besides, a holiday is a luxury. Her whole world will not fall to pieces if she doesn't get two weeks in the sun. If she had been kind and thoughtful to a baby - basically done what she was paid to do, she wouldn't be in this position now.

insancerre Sat 19-Jan-13 10:14:46

YANBU
Find another childminder. One that knows about children.
Is she even qualified?

financialwizard Sat 19-Jan-13 10:12:10

Yanbu

I would be out of there as fast as I could.

ChunkyChicken Sat 19-Jan-13 10:02:53

Even giving the CM the benefit of the doubt & maybe thinking she wasn't moaning about your DD, but merely commenting, it is totally within your rights to end the contract as and when you like, within the terms etc so giving the required notice (as you have done). The only exception would be if you'd be chopping & changing CM, but clearly you haven't if your DS has been there for 2yrs!!

I would want to get a new one on the basis of the emotional blackmail tbh. So YANBU.

One question, out of curiosity, did you actually tell her why you were ending the contract?

HSMM Sat 19-Jan-13 09:42:10

I am a CM and mind an 8 month old who takes any toys he likes the look of. It's curiosity .. not snatching.

SuffolkNWhat Sat 19-Jan-13 09:35:17

OP YANBU

But I had to comment because I love your name!

Cherriesarelovely Sat 19-Jan-13 09:33:36

YADNBU! How ridiculous that your childminder is saying these things about an 8 month old child! I would definitely stick with the decision to move your DCs. She has no right to try to make you feel bad about it.

Cuddlyrunner Sat 19-Jan-13 09:32:25

Please tell me you are not leaving your children with this woman again, you won't be able to relax and it doesn't sound right.

Mimishimi Sat 19-Jan-13 09:26:44

YANBU at all. You've given notice and that's all you are obliged to do for her. Really, what did she think would come of catty comments about your eight month old. Her holiday is none of your concern.

Ifyoucantsayanythingnice Sat 19-Jan-13 08:40:49

YANBU. She is.

Find a nice new one

VinegarDrinker Sat 19-Jan-13 08:34:22

Obviously that should say Wtf not ETF!

VinegarDrinker Sat 19-Jan-13 08:24:46

ETF? An 8 month old pinching and grabbing toys off other children? My DS would hardly have had the pincer grip to pinch, let alone the co-ordination at that age! And certainly wouldn't have been fast enough at moving or strong enough to grab toys off older babies/toddlers/preschoolers.

YANBU at all. And urgh at the emotional blackmail.

PatButchersEarring Sat 19-Jan-13 08:19:49

YADNBU.

I'm about to start childminding myself, and I find this woman's behaviour staggering.

She clearly has little understanding of child development, a total lack of professionalism and a propensity for emotional blackmail.

Your DS will make new friends in a new setting. Don't worry about that.

I would be taking my kids away from there in a flash.

AgentZigzag Sat 19-Jan-13 00:28:24

Could it be that she'll miss your DS?

That could explain why she might use her holiday to get him to stay?

foslady Sat 19-Jan-13 00:27:24

Sounds like she's thought about losing two children........or rather the fee for two children

YANBU - stuff her, your children deserve better

apostropheuse Sat 19-Jan-13 00:19:14

YANBU

How on earth can a childminder think that an eight month old baby is in any way capabe of intentionally stealing toys and maliciously pinching older children? She's doing what babies of that age do and it's perfectly normal.

It's absolutely not your fault if she doesn't get a holiday. She will just have to look for other older children to mind.

Viviennemary Sat 19-Jan-13 00:13:24

How on earth can an eight month old baby be accused of things like taking toys of other children. The childminder sounds more than a bit strange and you have done the right thing taking your children away. She hasn't a clue. Don't give in to her emotional blackmail about her holiday. She should think before she speaks in future.

zzzzz Sat 19-Jan-13 00:13:20

Sounds awful, I would be in a tizz, not because you shouldn't move them (without question and as uickly as possible), but because I hate any sort of conflict. You wll feel muh better once they have moved, just keep your eyes on everything being better soon.

YouGoGlenCoCo Sat 19-Jan-13 00:12:43

Ok thanks everyone, I was worried I was being too precious or that I was being a terrible mother for taking DS away from his friends.

AgentZigzag Sat 19-Jan-13 00:12:15

When I was reading through the OP I wondered whether she didn't think what she'd said was significant and hadn't noticed that she'd mentioned it to you as much as you feel she has.

Either that or it has happened and she thought she was doing the right thing by letting you know (you not seeing it/having it mentioned by someone else isn't concrete proof your DD hasn't done it with her - although I know what you mean about going on what you see of her behaviour)?

Or maybe she has older children normally and has forgotten how into everything an 8 month old can be?

SIBU to try and guilt you into still using her though, regardless, through her holiday is bad enough, but to try and use your DS is pretty low and would make me feel as though I'd definitely made the right decision if that's an indicator of how she works.

Totally up to you who you use, whether or not she's right about your DD or not, she's undermined the trust you have in her and that's what childminding is all about when it comes down to brass tacks.

shesariver Sat 19-Jan-13 00:12:00

YANBU. But I do find it strange that she has childminded your DS since roughly the same age for 2 years and you have never had a problem and now this, wonder what has changed? Sounds as if she is panicking now anyway and realised she could lose them both.

DeepRedBetty Sat 19-Jan-13 00:09:28

YANBU Hope you find a childminder who isn't into emotional blackmail soon.

GregBishopsBottomBitch Sat 19-Jan-13 00:07:32

Also babies bite, not maliciously, but because they test things, if DD was pinching, she was just testing.

GregBishopsBottomBitch Sat 19-Jan-13 00:06:10

WTF???? How the hell could a 8 month old, know what they were doing, CM can sod right off, i wouldnt want a CM who was so set against a baby.

blackeyedsusan Sat 19-Jan-13 00:02:26

sorry posted too soon... as i waas having a rant at the key board for writing in txt spk... she seems not to have much understanding of child development. go with someone you are happy with.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now