to think that if you nearly cause an accident.....(34 Posts)
...your instinctive reaction should be to apologise/indicate remorse, not to shout and scream and wave your arms at the person you nearly drove into?
I was driving to work this morning and I had been following a slightly irritating driver through the town centre. She didn't do anything massively dangerous - she was just one of those very wafty, hesitant, drivers who drift about the road and make you a bit nervous because they don't seem to know what they are doing. I passed her on a stretch of dual carriageway on the outside of town and didn't expect to see her again.
I got onto the single carriageway and was trundling along in a row of 3 cars, all doing about 50 - its a 60mph road but people tend to go a little bit slower because it is a bit bendy in places, with side entrances and there tend to be a lot of cyclists on it. There is a long straight on this road and towards the far end of it there was a car broken down. The three of us therefore obviously stopped to wait for there to be nothing coming the other way before going past. I glanced in the mirror and saw this woman enter the straight, several hundred yards back. I glanced up again and saw her still going quite fast about halfway along but not close enough for me to be alarmed. The next thing I knew there was an almighty screech of tyres and I looked up and saw her close behind, still going fast, swerving all over the place, dragging at the wheel, obviously trying to get the car back under control. I had assumed she was about to hit me and braced myself against the steering wheel, but she managed to stop sideways across the road, a few inches off me.
There was a huge stink of rubber and she had obviously ripped the tread of her tyres trying to stop. I turned round and lifted a hand in a 'what the actual fuck was that?' type gesture and she went ballistic, screaming and shouting and waving her arms and tooting her horn.
After I drove off she was still sat there trying to get herslf back onto the road properly. It looked as though she might have done some damage to her tyres as she seemed to be having problems moving.
So am I being unreasonable to think that if you entirely fail to notice stopped traffic on a clear, straight road in full daylight, when you have several hundred yards to realise that said cars aren't moving, and nearly run into them at high speed, your response really should be an indication of apology and acceptance of fault, not to try to blame the other driver?!
It seems like noone ever just says 'oops, my fault, sorry' anymore. If I make an error while driving and it affects someone else, I immediately make an apologetic gesture. Maybe I should start shouting and waving my arms.....
Never get out of your car in that sort of situation. You're far more likely to be killed that way if she did hit you. That is the absolutely the most stupid thing you could possibly do!
That sounds very scary kungfu!
Tweed, I probably could have done that if I'd thought of it in time, although the risk is that you then get shunted into them - I had a decent gap because I hate people who stop so close you can count their nose-hairs....
I am fairly sure she wasn't on the phone, although I could be wrong, and she was on her own in the car. If I'd thought she was on the phone I would have reported her.
I'm afraid there is no way on this earth I would have got out onto the middle of the road to check if the screaming, shouting, arm waving woman was ok. She didn't hit anything and while I'm quite sure she got a massive fright, there wasn't really anything to be said. If she had disolved into tears, or slumped over the wheel, or hadn't been trying to get moving I might have pulled in and waited to see if she got going, but given that her response to me raising my hand, palm-up was to scream and arm wave and toot, approaching her wouldn't have been my number one choice, even if it had been safe to do so.
It was the tooting I found surprising. I can just about understand the surge of adrenaline making you shout and gesture in shock or fright but repeatedly bashing the horn is quite agressive and suggests someone who is more angry than shocked.
I always leave a big gap between me and the car in front if stopping unexpectedly.
Leave car in gear , foot on clutch and footbrake. In your actual scenario you then might have been able to pull into the gap without her hitting you, and maybe shove you into the car in front of you.
Glad you wernt hit as whiplash can be painfull
I am slightly horrified at the idea of getting out of the car.
If that sounds like an option then I don't think I described it properly!
I looked in the mirror and saw her about halfway along the straight, probably doing 40-45ish, so fairly fast but not fast enough for me to think she wasn't going to stop - she still would have had plenty of time for a normal braking process. The only reason I clocked her at all was that I recognised the car as probably being the one I had passed earlier and I had a passing thought that it had taken her quite a while to catch up.
The next time I looked up was when I heard the squeal of tyres, at which point she was in the middle of the out-of-control emergency stop, so all I could do was hold the steering wheel hard. There is no way on this earth i could have undone my seatbelt, opened the door and got out of the car, even if that wouldn't have meant jumping into oncoming traffic! I can't imagine anything less likely to end well.
The hazard lights is an interesting one. If you take the view that you should put them on when you are stopped to go round a stopped or parked car, would that mean you should also put them on if you are waiting behind someone turning right? Or just in heavy traffic? I don't see people doing that habitually. This was a normal road and normal stopped traffic - on the way home tonight I stopped three times on the same road, twice behind people turning right and once because of a van on the side of the road. No-one put their hazards on and no-one had problems seeing or stopping. I would use hazards if I was in a situation where everyone was stopping very quickly to warn other drivers of a hazard actually happening right then - I wouldn't put them on simply because I'm stopped with space behind me, otherwise I'd have them on constantly on the roads round here.
I don't think, on balance, that I should have had hazards on, although I wouldn't say you would be wrong to do so - except that I was indicating to go round the stopped car and that would have been masked by hazard lights. Brake lights are supposed to indicate slow or stopped traffic and those would have been on as I had my foot on the brake. I think if someone can fail to notice a row of stopped, indicating cars, with brakelights, after a long run-up, hazard lights probably wouldn't add much.
digerd - no cars behind her at the time, fortunately.
Shock definitely makes you react out of character. A car drove into the back of mine when I was stopped at traffic lights on red I got out and screamed at her what did she think she was doing and I had my kids in the car blah blah. Then I looked at her face and she looked like she was going to cry. I was mortified by my reaction. Luckily nobody was hurt and the damage was sorted in a calm friendly manner.
Looks like she was distracted maybe by a child in the back or on the phone or just new driver. I think you should have checked she was ok.
I did wonder if maybe a phone was involved
Perhaps she was texting?
Trying to think of a gesture that means " Are you OK?" but can't think of one. She must have been in a terrible state of shock, more than you, I expect, and would not have reacted rationally anyway.
Know I made the right decision, when I gave up on trying to drive years ago.
Thank goodness she didn't cause damage to cars behind her
From the way I'm picturing the road the OP describes, it sounds like there would have been space to move ahead or to one side hence my comment, if that isn't the case then sensible to stay in the car obviously.
Hazards / No hazards / break lights its all personal preference I suppose but break lights is the least I would doing.
Well I definitely wouldn't have ot out of the car strawberries In to oncoming traffic? And if she'd swirved to avoid the car she could have quite easily hit you!
I'd have said it was far safer to stay in the car.
Sometimes if I'm in a queue of traffic after a bend I will keep my foot on the brake so if anyone corners to fast it's more obvious that i'm stationary. I wouldn't have put my hazards on sat in traffic on a straight road though
massive amounts of adrenaline can have an outstanding effect
Yes, back in the summer we were crabbing and I knocked my eldest daughter off a pontoon - I was helping her sister and without me realising, she'd walked right up behind me, as I kind of stepped back and turned to check on her, I knocked her over. Luckily the water was only a couple of feet deep and I fished her straight out. It scared the shit out of me and I ended up letting rip and giving her a bollocking. Totally my fault but I was shaking and my heart was pounding, once she was safe I just reacted without really thinking
YANBU to think that is the better reaction, to apologise and take some responsibility - however, instinctive reactions should be judged a bit less harshly. I don't think your "what the actual fuck" reaction was very appropriate either, an "are you okay" reaction would have been better, given she was already in a state. You just fuelled the fire and didn't actually do anything to help the situation, either in warning her or settling her down afterwards. Maybe her car was playing up or she was scared about a car up her rear and gesturing at them, she was probably a bad driver or an idiot, but you don't know it as you didn't ask.
I think she was obviously in the wrong but you don't deserve whatever boost you are hoping to get from this thread. You can't claim that you are genuinely wondering if people will think screaming and shouting is correct etiquette, of course they don't.
It is a 60mph road, single carriageway, and you even you even said you saw her going quite fast halfway down to you, I'd have put them on.
She might not local and not realise the road is prone to obstructions.
She is still in the wrong, ultimately though.
Yes perhaps because she was a new driver? Who cant read the road well or is new to the area? If I saw someone approaching at speed enough to alarm me I would put my hazards on and if i was bracing for impact id of gotten out of the car... Not saying your wrong just points to consider, doesn't excuse the rudeness though
It wasn't really a hazard light situation - I always do that if I am on the motorway or of it is a very sudden stop, but this was a clearly visible obstruction with a long, clear run-up to it, and there are quite often obstructions on that road as there are a lot of warehouse type business yards and you get lorries stopping, or tractors going slowly - its not a clear road where you can do 60 most of the time. There's always a lot of slowing down and speeding up, and usually at least one or two stops for people turning.
It was just a normal traffic stopping scenario and she for some reason didn't notice.
You should have had your hazards on. She prob wondered why on earth you had stopped and maybe not even clocked the broken down car at that point. She was a numpty though, she must have realised you were at a standstill so late!
Nowt so queer as folk.
That's the only explanation there is. Are you going to publish your road-related adventures into a series kungfu? I'd buy them.
Well, look on the bright side. Her stupidity probably cost her some damage to her tyres and a good old fright. She'll be a better driver because of it. Consider it your gift to the universe
But yes, you are totally in the right and she is an idiot.
Massive amounts of adrenaline can have an astounding effect.
Mrspepsi - shock affects different people differently.
Does shock make you act like a knob or is it the fact you know you are actually the fuckwit that makes you lash out?
Having very recently suffered from shock, non car related, I can honestly say that aggression was the last thing on my mind.
I agree that shock causes people to behave like that freddie In the OP I bet that driver's heart was thumping. No excuse though.
I had a cyclist zoom out of a side turning without looking, straight into my car - I was sitting in a queue of traffic and was stationary, just clear of the turning so he scraped all the way up from the rear bumper, ripping off the wing mirror in the process.
Did he apologise? Did he heck, he ranted and raved, told me I was a stupid bitch and a fucking idiotic driver.
I put it down to the fact that
he was a fuckwit he'd scared the shit out of himself and was in shock and was lashing out
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.