to not have lots of food at ds 2nd 'birthday party'?

[OFSTEDoutstanding]

My ds is 2 on Tuesday and so we are having a family get together on Sunday afternoon. The 'party' is from 2.30-5 and I have only asked both sets of grandparents, uncle and godparents, there are no children coming as we are only having the get together for family members.
I am a childminder so will actually have a house full of children on his birthday and we are going out for the day to soft play as his birthday treat.
I am wondering whether I am being unreasonable putting out just a few bowls of crisps and nibbles instead of loads of party food. My ds will have had lunch before they come and will have tea when they leave and am assuming that they will do the same. We will of course have a birthday cake during the afternoon so that they can see him blow out his candles.
MIL reaction was well its not a real party if there is no party food, imo ds doesn't even know what a birthday is really, we are actually having this get together as MIL doesn't respect my job and often thinks she can turn up during work hours to see ds as I am at home I am not really working!! Obviously I don't want her turning up next week when I have mindees from 8-6 and ds goes to bed at 7.
Is it being unreasonable to not have loads of food and is it being unreasonable to wish my MIL will be able to keep her opinions to herself for 2 1/2 hours!

[OFSTEDoutstanding]

Thanks for all your comments yes my MIL is a PITA!!! Think will stick to nibble sas said on the thread they are only travelling 5 miles to get to us so don't need a huge feed
Hana you are right don't really want them there or MIL anyway she is too opinionated and I spend whole time on edge waiting for her to upset someone

[portonovo]

You're being eminently reasonable, although I would make sure everyone knows what they're getting! So phrase it perhaps 'we'd love you to come and see x and have a piece of his birthday cake and a cuppa'.

I assume these family members aren't coming from far and wide so shouldn't expect a full tea unless they're invited for one. And you said no other children are invited so you're not disappointing any little ones.

[NoBiggy]

We had similar for DD last weekend. Just family, mainly adult, Sunday afternoon, cups of tea and birthday cake all round. DD was 1 btw.

Parties are for the child, and any invited children. That's the basis I work on. DD didn't have a party (we did go out for a fab treat mind you).

[hana]

I'd probably put out more than just a few snacks - I would expect that for a party at that time tbh if i was going to a 'family get together'
sounds like you don't really want them there

[mixedmama]

I dont think you are being unreasonable, although personally if I was inviting people round, especially for a party i would lay on a bit of food, mainly because Dh and I both come form cultural backgrounds where youhave to feed guests rather than because i want to.

[lucyellensmum]

re the food YANBU

re MIL keeping quiet for that long - hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha .


Cake and nibbles sound perfect. Maybe you could do up a plate for MIL and make her wear a silly hat.

[maisemor]

Your party, your house, your child therefore you decide.

She can host her own party and serve whatever she likes to serve.

I would serve food because I love to cook, and I usually end up serving way too much.

[newgirl]

i think it is entirely up to you

but for me for that time i would do some very simple sandwiches and cakes

why not ask mil to make a large plate of sandwiches - how could she possibly object?!

[NKF]

I'm sure it's fine but I would serve food. But then I always do. I come from a family who serves food at the drop of a hat and it would seem odd to me to have people in my house for several hours without producing plates of something. But probably best to make it easy on yourself.

[babyblueiloveyou]

What alicet said! I'm usually the 'hostess with the mostest' - any excuse for food (& lots of it) but I think what you have planned is reasonable. Tea/Coffee and Cake is completely appropriate for the time and type of get together, especially when it's all 'grown-ups'. In a few years you won't be able to get away with doing this kind of party - there will have to be entertainers, party bags and of course most importantly generaous helpings of stress for you! (My ds1 is 5 shortly ) Enjoy it while you can!

[alicet]

I think what you have planned is fine. I certainly wouldn't expect more than this (although I am sure I would eat it if it was there! )

If MIL has a problem with this why not suggest to her that she brings some food with her to contribute - as you work full time as a childminder you won't have time to do this and it would be a really big help! That will either shut her up or she will bring loads of food - win win as far as I can see!!!

[ChasingSquirrels]

There are no otehr kids there, it is family coming to see 2yo because of birthday, there won't be time for food they will all be fussing over him - birthday cake and drinks will be fine.
Your MIL sounds like a PITA.

[bubblagirl]

you could just get a few bits of food if they are there for few hours

i done for my sons 2nd birthday a few sandwiches, quiche, crisps ,scotch eggs and nibbles all went down well and my son enjoyed sitting on floor with party hat on and party plates nibbling on it but you do what you feel is best i wanted it to be more party feeling as he was more aware of it being something special but i thin k regardless he'll have good day

maybe you can tell your guests aboput food situation as from experience if you know your going to a party you dont have much lunch as there is normally food at a party so you dont want everyone skipping lunch for crisps

[SSSandy2]

This is just a get-together with around 10 adults and the birthday boy she said. The kiddies party will be on another day.

I would have thought cake and some nibbles would be fine but maybe you could have a big pot of something ready and people can just help themselves. Something they might eat, don't know them but say soup and baguette, or a big pot of pasta or chili or something.

Or as someone else said make some nice sandwiches, a plate of cold meat and some nice cheeses if someone needs something more substantial or doesn't like cake, then you've covered everything.

[Hulababy]

If there were children coming then I think it would probably be a bit different.

[Hulababy]

Nibbles and cake seems perfectly acceptable for the time of day your "party" is.

[maisym]

Just some cake would be fine - small kids aren't there to eat but to play.

[Alambil]

you could do a fast platter - french stick, cut up, couple tubes of pringles, butter, meat and crisps then with the cake that will placate any stroppy adults that there isn't any food, but be cheap and fast for you to not cause stress n hassle

[goldenoldie]

sorry, I would expect food at an afternoon children's party, I know my kids would too.
tbh how hard is it to do a few sarnies, bit of cold meat, cheeseboard, bread and pickles. That would keep most people happy and would take about 10 mins to put together

[kickassangel]

i once went to a 1 year old party which was just grown ups - family members & they kind of did the whole childrens party thing (no hats, thankfully) and there was just a very surreal moment when all the grown ups seemed to try to entertain the birthday girl by doing baby talk & eating childrens party food. i found it very odd & hid in the kitchen, making tea.
it's really a chance for family to turn up & see the birthday boy - if i had several adults coming round at that time of day i would do a light bite, not proper food. cake will be fun, but that's all you really need. as you say, he doesn't really get it & will like the attention moe than anything

[OFSTEDoutstanding]

No none of them eat in te afternoon thats why I thought I wouldn't do food they are all (and there are only 8 of them) having either big lunch or big tea on a Sunday so I know most of them will not expect anything, in fact most have said a cup of tea and slice of cake is all we need but MIL got me thinking.

[madamez]

Are any of your invited guests the type who regularly eat an afternoon tea at 4-ish? Because I suppose it can be a bit distressing to people to miss out on a meal at a time they are accustomed to one - but otherwise, between 2 and 5 30 isn't a time when most people would expect to eat a meal as opposed to nibble the odd peanut. I know toddlers often have an afternoon snack but the cake will surely cover that.
SOunds like your MIL is just one of life's moaners, really.

[OFSTEDoutstanding]

sorry PUT the kettle on

[OFSTEDoutstanding]

She never knows how to work a kettle even when I came home from hospital after having ds she walked in and said 'out the kettle on!'

[OFSTEDoutstanding]

Yes MrsS I have the Thomas Tank plates ready and waiting