Long time lurker, signing up in the hope that it'll help clarify my thoughts by talking it through, so...
I'm a PhD student working in health/socsci area that closely borders trans issues (and as such will probably have to devote some of my thesis to discussing my work and its relationship to trans stuff). I am a gender critical feminist, but it feels like this is a bit of a no-no in the academic circles I'm working within.
This is making me feel:
a) that I am 'wrong'/ out of touch for not believing that 'you don't need a vagina/uterus to be a woman, and if you disagree you're TERF scum', that men in women's space is fine and I'm a bigot for not agreeing, and (my favourite so far) that being critical of the oppressive nature of gender is 'creating trans corpses'.
b) that I can't vocalise my views and reasoning in a professional context. For example, I recently attended a meeting for a professional group that I represent at postgrad level. This group is concerned with furthering research and visibility of sexuality research (sorry I can't be more specific..small world/potentially outing). All the usual trans-ideology vernacular was used this meeting, 'cis women' etc. ...basically it was made clear that this was a space where TI rules. I am fairly new to the group, and to see established academics advocating this reductive way of thinking was a really ostracising experience. Do they really believe that 'lived experience as a woman' trumps being an actual woman, or is it toeing the party line?
This week, I have been asked to collaborate on a paper with a colleague (also at postgrad level) that discusses LGBT issues and mental health. Having read the paper proposal, colleague also uses 'cis' terminology and appears to also support TI.
I feel like I have two options
a) 'come out' as critical of all this shit, break professional ties with those who are not trans-critical (before they do it for me, I imagine) and feel like an island. As a very early ECR/still doing my PhD, I feel like I this is a risky move career wise. I already feel pretty marginalised in terms of my area of research, my approach to it etc..
b) pretend I agree and basically go along with it all for the sake of my career, whilst raging inside at the insanity of it all.
Neither of these is ideal. Both A and B are terrifying for different reasons, both have huge implications for me in terms of my values and my research career. Where are the GC academics? I feel like if we were more of an open, 'me too' critical mass, it might be easier to 'come out'. Am I looking in the wrong places, or are we too afraid of the backlash to put our hands up? If academia isn't the place to discuss this, then where is!?!
I completely respect that individual university policies on this whole issue might prevent people from speaking up. As a PhD student I probably have a little bit more freedom to do so, but it still feels so risky.
TL;DR: where are all the critical of trans ideology- academics/PhDs and how do you navigate this in the current climate if it has the potential to have a real and specific impact on your research/teaching?
TIA
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Academic common room
'Coming out' as critical of trans ideology-impact on career?
24 replies
headinavice · 26/11/2017 11:04
OP posts:
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.