Emily or ...?

Emily - love this! Classic and timeless
Holly - not keen
Mikaela - really dislike
Makena or Makenna - never heard but really don’t like
Pearl - ok
Zoe - not keen
Chloe - ok

Zoe

Emily is lovely. I also like Zoe, Chloe and pearl. Prefer Michaela. Not a big fan of holly but do like molly. Hate makenna.

Emily - I really like Emily. It seems like about 10 years ago it very everywhere but it's calmed down a lot now. The youngest Emily I know is 4

Holly - it's OK, a find it a bit overdone

Mikaela - not a fan

Makena or Makenna - really not a fan. It comes across as downmarket

Pearl - lovely

Zoe - lovely though very popular on here lately. Not sure if that correlates to the name charts

Chloe - I really like it

We were going to have an Emily molly (middle name after my gran). Turns out we had a Thomas!
They don't often get it wrong, but luckily we had a boys choice too!
So I like Emily, and also Zoe

I like Holly and Pearl.

Love Emily and Pearl.

Mikaela / Makenna etc seem a bit cheap (don’t know if that’s the right word) compared to the others.

Love holly

I love Emily and Pearl.

I love Emily, Pearl, Chloe and Holly.

Have you thought about Isobel? Or Clara maybe?

Emily - fine
Holly - ok, prefer Polly and Molly
Mikaela - no, Michaela is better
Makena or Makenna - dreadful
Pearl - ok but not keen
Zoe - fin, like it
Chloe - seems dated

I like Holly :)

I love the name Holly.

Emily is lovely too.

I like Emily. Not keen on the others.

Emily - like
Holly - OK, also prefer Polly and Molly
Mikaela - dislike
Makena or Makenna - really dislike!
Pearl - dislike
Zoe - like
Chloe - like

Emily - nice (and safe)
Holly - I love this
Mikaela - I like this
Makena or Makenna - not my taste
Pearl - not my taste
Zoe - really like
Chloe - love (I have one) but hate that people think of it as dated on here.

I love Emily, and it was on my shortlist.

Holly is OK, but I would probably only use it for a winter baby. I don't like any of the rest.

I like Zoe, Chloe, Emily, and Holly, probably in that order. Emily feels a little bit more established/classic (at least in English) than the others, if that matters to you - also gives a few more possibilities for shortening (Em, Emmie, Millie, etc.) I especially like the meanings of Zoe (life) and Chloe (green shoot).

I like Pearl in theory but the sound is a little awkward to me - it's one of those names/words that I'm never sure if it should be one syllable or two. Plus it reminds me of both purl (as in knitting) and peril.

Not crazy about Mikaela - I know it's the traditional feminine version of Michael in some languages but even the most common English-language version (Michaela) feels kind of contrived to me, like it's really a boys' name adjusted to make it feminine.

Makenna reminds me of the surname MacKenna but the spelling throws me off. For Makena, I'm not sure if it would/should be pronounced the same way or more like "ma-KEEN-ah".

Emily is really dull. Holly and Zoe would be my favourites.

Emily - nice, prefer Emma
Holly - twee, no
Mikaela - 80s naff, no
Makena or Makenna NO. OP!!

Pearl - no
Zoe - love it
Chloe - fine

Emily - love was one of our top 2 names
Holly - no
Mikaela - no
Makena or Makenna No
Pearl - no
Zoe - love was our other top 2 name
Chloe - dislike, too common,

Zoe is my favourite from the list.

Emily - ok
Holly - really like
Mikaela - not keen
Makena or Makenna - not keen
Pearl - not keen (but quite like as mn)
Zoe - love (this is my favourite from your list)
Chloe - like

I like Emily and Holly, not keen on the others.

Quite a variety!

Emily, Zoe and Chloe are beautiful.
I do quite like Holly.
Mikaela is OK I suppose, not sure about this spelling though.

Pearl, no, seems to be having a moment but there's nothing attractive about the sound and it's old fashioned.
Makenna, no, not even sure what this is supposed to be.