Talk

Advanced search

Stonewall don't believe in same-sex attraction.

(58 Posts)
AntsInPenzance Mon 19-Oct-20 08:58:29

From their glossary:

HOMOSEXUAL
This might be considered a more medical term used to describe someone who has a romantic and/or sexual orientation towards someone of the same gender. The term ‘gay’ is now more generally used.

OP’s posts: |
IwishNothingButTheBestForYou2 Mon 19-Oct-20 09:00:52

It's good to have an authority on made up stuff.

Datun Mon 19-Oct-20 09:05:17

Yep. To be blunt, according to them, lesbian sex can be two males giving each other fellatio, PIV sex between a male and a female or two women.

Anything, in fact. Likewise any other sexual orientation.

EmpressJKRowlingSpartacus Mon 19-Oct-20 09:07:16

Stonewall haven’t believed in same-sex attraction for years now sad. They’ve gone from fighting for LGB to fighting against us - they’re essentially a bunch of misogynistic homophobes. Or homophobic misogynists, take your pick.

nauticant Mon 19-Oct-20 09:09:01

I still smile at the discussion of 69 and the wave of deletions that caused in FWR.

Whatwouldscullydo Mon 19-Oct-20 09:12:38

Yep its been that way for a while.

Another example of how egging people on and being egged on by others always results in eventually having to follow things through to their logical conclusion even when that loses you credibility and respect and money/custom .

Perfect example of why we need boundaries and how saying no might have been "kinder" in the long run.

RedToothBrush Mon 19-Oct-20 09:13:31

Its worse than that...

If their definition is based on how people identify rather than their actual sex:

Homophobia is observable in critical and hostile behavior such as discrimination and violence on the basis of sexual orientations that are non-heterosexual. Recognized types of homophobia include institutionalized homophobia, e.g. religious homophobia and state-sponsored homophobia, and internalized homophobia, experienced by people who have same-sex attractions, regardless of how they identify.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homophobia

nauticant Mon 19-Oct-20 09:13:52

It is amazing that Stonewall claim not to believe in same-sex attraction these days (although nearly all of them will believe it in private and particularly would accept nothing other than that in their relatiohnships).

It makes me think of when David Jenkins was consecrated as Bishop of Durham and caused a massive fuss by questioning the literal truth of some miracles in the Bible. You'd have thought there'd have been a similarly massive fuss in Stonewall.

Datun Mon 19-Oct-20 09:27:43

How can they campaign against homophobia when, according to them, it doesn't exist.

Their entire raison d'etre has gone. They should not be funded, or solicit funds, on the basis of something they say doesn't exist.

TyroBurningDownTheCloset Mon 19-Oct-20 09:28:03

The term 'gay' is more generally used.

Does this piss anyone else off? I grew up with the understanding that gay implied male and the female equivalent was lesbian. Now the latter's seen as a dirty word (unless used by men to describe themselves) and women are expected to shift to using the male variant.

It's the same old pattern of male as default and female as degraded other; when problems arise (as they always do because of that underlying assumption of female=other) we're expected to adjust our language so the male-variant becomes the human-variant and the female-variant becomes verboten.

risefromyourgrave Mon 19-Oct-20 09:32:09

Surely their definition of homosexual is more a definition of pansexual? Or have I misunderstood what pansexual is?

NecessaryScene1 Mon 19-Oct-20 09:38:40

"Pansexual" is attraction to "any gender" (regardless of sex). As opposed to "same gender" (regardless of sex).

nauticant Mon 19-Oct-20 09:39:56

I thought when put into proper terms, "pansexual" means attracted to people irrespective of their sex. Clearly we already have the word "bisexual" for that but in this time of pretendy definitions, that would "exclude" people who claim to have no sex by virtue of being "gender fluid" or "non-binary".

The amusing thing about "pansexual" is that I suspect most of them are heterosexual but are embarrassed to be so mundane.

IwishNothingButTheBestForYou2 Mon 19-Oct-20 09:50:31

pretendy

Love that word!

TyroBurningDownTheCloset Mon 19-Oct-20 09:52:07

Now just waiting for the obligatory post of the Sandy Draws Badly take on pansexualism. It's always good for a giggle.

TyroBurningDownTheCloset Mon 19-Oct-20 10:00:54

While I wait for the cartoon - I suspect pansexual came about because bisexual carries certain baggage due to being characterised with reference to monosexual attractions.

We say homosexuals are attracted to their own sex and heterosexuals are attracted to the opposite sex ergo bisexuals are attracted to both sexes.

Meanwhile there's a shitload of people out there scratching their heads and thinking "But I'm not attracted to a sex; a person's sex is utterly irrelevant to whether I fancy them."

This is usually referred to in scathing tones as "hearts before parts", which is a bit of a shitty and othering way to characterise other people's lack of a reproductive-sex-class orientation.

Pan means "I couldn't care less what sex you are".

nauticant Mon 19-Oct-20 10:02:49

Pansexual often means a young woman who is attracted both to men who have a masculine presentation and men who (sometimes) have a feminine presentation.

RedToothBrush Mon 19-Oct-20 10:06:15

Pansexual - Someone who is bisexual but believes in gender stereotypes and thinks bisexual is boring and old fashioned.

NewlyGranny Mon 19-Oct-20 10:07:31

So, theoretically, if the pansexual feels attracted to the asexual, there's a dilemma! Surely someone is going to hear the word 'no' spoken. Won't that be panphobia?

FindTheTruth Mon 19-Oct-20 10:10:23

Stonewall: HomoGENDERals are allowed ....HomoSEXuals are transphobic 🙄

Stonewall science: Queer theory. SEX is a social construct. Gender identity is real

Stonewall mission: Abolish sex based rights.

TyroBurningDownTheCloset Mon 19-Oct-20 10:17:32

I can see I'm going to end up playing devil's advocate on this thread!

If you're only attracted to one sex then the sex of potential partners matters. If you're capable of being attracted to both then their sex doesn't come into the equation, yet you're required to declare an orientation based on this thing that you experience as an irrelevance.

Obviously (as nauticant points out) some people use the word to disguise a heterosexual orientation. But some people use it because they don't have a sexual orientation in the traditional sense.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g Mon 19-Oct-20 10:18:55

Here you go, Tyro. grin

TyroBurningDownTheCloset Mon 19-Oct-20 10:28:54

Ta, Gasp0de - my day is made! grin

terryleather Mon 19-Oct-20 10:47:27

Seeing the above has made me remember this, also from Sandy....grin

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g Mon 19-Oct-20 10:50:05

Sandy is a genius.

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in