An ex-colleagues just sent me a copy of paper from a conference that took place in 2013, about treating and supporting transgender patients.
I though it was interesting from a number of perspectives; not least how things seem to have changed so much over the past 4 years.
One of the speakers was Dr James Barrett who is a psychiatrist, the Lead Clinician at the Gender Identity Clinic Imperial College and the President of the British Association of Gender Identity Specialists.
This man has seen hundreds, probably thousand of people presenting as trans. I've copied below some of what he said at this conference. I thought it was really interesting, particularly in light of arguments regarding access to women's spaces for anyone who rocks up in a dress and lipstick; the frequently trotted out 'trans people have unique mental health problems and are likely to commit suicide'; and also the rather sinister push towards insisting people believe that trans women are women. Here's what he said:
----------------------
"The 'trans' umbrella includes people who cross-dress, transsexuals, and other gender variant people, including individuals who are androgynous and those who identify themselves as non-gendered.
He stated that people with gender identity are not more likely to be afflicted with mental health issues than the general population. However, there is a tendency to forget that they are highly likely to be afflicted with physical health problems just like the general population. . .
Dr Barrett discussed characteristics of the cases seen at the clinic. The majority of the male patients have also had history of transvestism, sometimes briefly fetishistic but usually evolving into dual role transvestism. They are usually sexually interested in women and remain so. Many have had apparently successful lives in a male role, sometimes for many years. A smaller proportion of male patients give a history of viewing themselves or having been viewed by others as rather feminine gay men, who have over time developed a growing sense of their femininity.
The women seen at the clinic tend to present earlier in life, almost always present with an earlier self or social identity as a gay woman. This is sometimes uncomfortably worn for many years, and many give a history of childhood tomboyishiness.
A quite small proportion of patients of either sex seem to have had a sense of being physically opposite sex from their earliest years. A hugely greater number of patients make this claim, only for interviews with parents to subsequently refute it or cause it to be modified to a history of childhood cross dressing – which does not amount to a GID.
Hormonal and surgical treatment
Dr Barrett identified that most people want to be treated with hormones and surgery so that they might as closely as possible resemble the other biological sex. The guiding principle is that reversible changes should precede irreversible. This should only occur under the supervision of a GIC. Advice given includes;
Patients must change their social gender role entirely before they are commenced on hormone treatment. Patients sometimes argue that the latter is needed for the former to be possible, but clinical experience strongly suggests that if this rationale is followed, change of role does not result but demands for ever ‘stronger’ hormones do.
Patients who demonstrate brief episodes of reverting to original role for ‘special occasions’ or ‘no special occasion’ carry a poor prognosis and preclude the initiation of hormone treatment.
Living in another gender role:
Dr Barrett defined what living in another gender role was as “an acceptance in that role by others around the patient”. It does not necessarily equate to others actually believing that the patient is that sex, simply that they are accepted as a member of that sex.
Facts to consider:
Suicides and homicides get alerted to the GIC, and are rare."
----------------------
Also interesting to hear what Dr Barrett says about the self-report of many trans people that they have a sense of being 'physically the opposite sex' from a young age, but that then isn't supported by family members.
Any thoughts?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
Transgender expert's comments - at odds with much of the trans narrative?
8 replies
Obsessivenamechanger · 24/11/2017 11:26
OP posts:
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.