Talk

Advanced search

Now the term FGM is cissexist? WTAF?

(232 Posts)

MNHQ have commented on this thread.

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 21:30:54

elegantgatheringofwhitesnows.com/?p=2069

By the very brilliant Louise Pennington.

How can they try to erase the lived experience of violence against women by banning a discriptive term for what is actually happening?

"It is not “cissexist” to talk about the biological reality of women’s bodies and the damage done to them within a capitalist-patriarchy. Frankly, even the suggestion that it is “cissexist” demonstrates a fundamental inability to actually understand the reality of lives of women and girls in our world."

heartisaspade Tue 28-Oct-14 21:39:32

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ZombiePuffinsAreREAL Tue 28-Oct-14 21:48:22

And, the day that CCP published her blog post on anxiety and depression, she has quit Twitter.

It's not enough to label her and other women TERF. They are now labeling her a racist.

Boysclothes Tue 28-Oct-14 21:49:49

FUCK these transactivists. Seriously. They're making me sick now.

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 21:56:46

No! Do you mean that louise has quit twitter?

ZombiePuffinsAreREAL Tue 28-Oct-14 21:57:39

No, Louise is still there, but Caroline Criado-Perez has gone. She has been under attack all day on there and she had had enough.

ElephantsNeverForgive Tue 28-Oct-14 22:08:12

FFS that's utterly ridiculous.

FMG isn't any kind of ....ist. It's just evil.

Shallishanti Tue 28-Oct-14 22:11:49

racist??? huh??
really this just all confirms my conclusion that this talk of 'cis' is just a load of rubbish
if these people had any idea at all of the harm done to girls and women and their babies through FGM they'd have better things to do than insult those trying to make things better for real people in the real world.

mrsruffallo Tue 28-Oct-14 22:16:41

You know what? Young girls have enough shit thrown at them without these pathetic transactivists joining in.

AyMamita Tue 28-Oct-14 22:25:31

Careful guys... someone very close to me got banned from MN with no warning for saying that they were tired of transactivists pushing their agenda on here.

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 22:26:12

This is just cementing my objection to the cis thing. How can it be cissexist to talk about things that happen to female bodies. I am not anti trans*, and respect any individuals choice to 'to do what they want to do', as the song says. I will respect an individual's choice of pronown and all that. But that includes other people NOT shutting down discussion of a real problem.

ZombiePuffinsAreREAL Tue 28-Oct-14 22:33:55

Thanks for the heads up AyMamita, it wasn't on here, it was on Twitter. I've not actually seen any TAs on here.

I'm all for everyone having whatever opinion they like. I don't care what people want to call themselves, how they want to label themselves. What I really care a stupid amount about is people co-opting women and girls' pain in order to promote an unrelated political agenda. It, quite simply, disgusts me.

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 22:48:03

I have emailed MN for reassurance that I am allowed to discuss this. If the answer is no, then I will be gobsmacked and disappointed.

CheeseEqualsHappiness Tue 28-Oct-14 22:48:32

I hadn't even heard of cissexism until 20 minutes ago, and have been reading some interesting arguments on other pages. So am I right in thinking that there is a push for the recognition that some people who identify as female have penises, therefore the definition of FGM being descriptive of vulva mutilation and not including foreskin removal is cissexist?

LineRunner Tue 28-Oct-14 22:54:45

So they would use, what, 'vulval genital mutilation' and 'penile genital mutilation'?

Why don't they just do that, then. No-one's stopping them.

CheeseEqualsHappiness Tue 28-Oct-14 23:06:12

Yes, this is what I think they are looking for, or just genital mutilation to encompass it all without recognition or a separate phrase for the awful reality that is FGM.

And it seems that many posters in what I have read are unsure of what FGM even is

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 23:10:57

Well the other thing for me Is that FGM covers a few different set of procedures. I won't detail them here but it is pretty grim

Here is a link if you want to know

www.dofeve.org/types-of-fgm.html

It seems that the Twitter user just wants us to reclassify the removal of the clitoris as not FGM? What about the other forms?

Thumbscrewswitch Tue 28-Oct-14 23:14:11

I came on here to ask wtf "cissexist" is but I think I've got it - it's women born as women being sexist against trans-women, is that it?

And if so, then really? They want to ban discussion of FGM because it couldn't have happened to them because they didn't have the relevant parts at birth? Jeez-us. That's hitting the "inhumane" button quite strongly for me - children are being mutilated and a tiny subsection of the population objects to the words used because it couldn't have happened to them? Fuck.

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 23:17:07

Yes TW.

I have heard of (but not witnessed) objection to speaking about menstruation, smear tests, or childbirth as being trans-excluding as well.

I will try to look for one of the links...

heartisaspade Tue 28-Oct-14 23:17:26

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LineRunner Tue 28-Oct-14 23:19:24

Oh well fuck em

LineRunner Tue 28-Oct-14 23:20:00

Discuss.

Obviously.

ElephantsNeverForgive Tue 28-Oct-14 23:21:11

thumbs you sum it up perfectly.

Apart from anything else FMG is just vague enough you can use it in senior school assemblies, and allow the DCs to research it themselves in an age appropriate way.

I

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 28-Oct-14 23:21:52

Take this one for instance

feministing.com/2011/04/11/why-i-wont-be-talking-about-abortion-as-a-womens-issue-anymore/

I mean really. Women's reproduction and bodily autonomy is not a women's issue.

MyEmpireOfDirt Tue 28-Oct-14 23:23:15

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now