AIBU to just not want to argue with men anymore?(31 Posts)
I'm fed up. All over the real world all over the internet, I got an earful from two twats on my friend's facebook page yesterday.She made the mistake of posting a picture that said women should not be any man's "waste of time" or something to that effect. Totally uncontroversial but apparently she is being sexist and it is equally important for men to know their own dignity and not be abused by women etc etc..and I just thought fuck off. I got in to it with both of them at first and then I was like why am I wasting my breath? They don't get it they never will, and the fact that upsets them means they want women to continue to know their place. So I blocked them. Should I keep arguing?
I just can't imagine seeing a little picture that says people of color should understand their worth and jumping all over it and being like white people have it bad too! It's obvious that being white comes with a privilege in my country and that I should be happy when other people are happy and feel good about themselves. I wish I could start a world wide public service campaign that says women, minorities, people with disabilities are just people and by trying to improve their lot in life it does not reduce your lot in life.
Hellsbells, I totally see where you are coming from. DH is only here at weekends and I really find it stressful . I feel myself start to get tense around Wednesday, and now I just feel ill. It is not like he is a bad person, it's more like I can't cope, I want my own space. Now that I have noticed, I feel awful.
Totally get where you're coming from. I can rarely stop myself from commenting but am getting to the point where sometimes I think that either I CBA or I realise I'm not able to not take it personally so I just don't reply.
Luckily on FB a great many of my friends will pile in when an entitled male posts crap so I tend to just post on my wall and go from there.
Always loathed that song that starts with a dreadful wailing "You're miiiiiine" and goes on to tell the woman that she's his favourite waste of time, for the sound of it as much as the sentiment; so if that's what your friend was railing at, more power to her elbow! It just so happens that the song was being sung by a man about a woman, so the comment was valid. Yes, OK, I'm sure we can also agree that a woman should not be calling her boyfriend a waste of time either (or should be ditching him pronto if he is), but why does that make the original complaint sexist? Women are human beings, not hobbies. By saying that, I am not somehow implying that men are hobbies, not human beings.
Re the "it happens to men too" knee-jerk: obviously, men being raped, abused etc, whether by women or other men, is a bad thing. It's just not always relevant to mention it at the time. A woman has been assaulted. This is a bad thing. Why jump in and shout "men get assaulted too"? Right here, right now, that is not the issue. We should not stop challenging overt examples of cruelty and injustice just because other forms of cruelty and injustice also exist.
Like, oh, I dunno, that recent hospital scandal where loads of people died unnecessarily from neglect. It is a fact that in hospitals and (tragically) orphanages in certain parts of the world the death rate is higher, but is that really the point when discussing this particular piece of news? These things happened and they happened in that hospital there, and they were bad things. Yes, something worse may well have happened somewhere else, but that is not the point.
I'm with you Hells. If it's not broke then don't fix it!
No, relationships can definitely hinder feminism, dh and I have been together nearly a decade and in that time he has seen the side effects of my militant feminism I pull him up on anything remotely sexist now and feel it's my duty to teach him .. he does sometimes take the piss (good naturedly..but still ifykwim) but he has been pointing out stuff and telling me things that wound him up at work or news articles he has read that are basically feminism 101 and I see it getting through... he probably isn't up to your ds's level yet..but we are getting there!
I'm really glad I didn't offend - some of my best friends are in relationships and I'm happy for them (the non-abusive ones anyway!) but it was realising it doesn't really work for me and that's ok that was so liberating in so many ways. Hard to convey that without people thinking you're criticising their choices (or just being deviant) sometimes though
Sorry, bit of a diversion...
hells I'm in a relationship but totally see where you're coming from. If we split up (and I really hope we don't, because I do love him and he makes me happy) then I doubt I'd be rushing into another relationship.
Oh yes, and having the kids too. Trying to raise DS to be a respectful man (he notices and points out sexism to me at 10 which I'm pretty proud about) and trying to make it a marginally less shit world for DD to grow up in and give her a sense that she can do or be anything she wants. Those are all pretty powerful motivators.
That's such a good point. I've found myself becoming much more outspoken and generally giving much less of a fuck who agrees with me over the last few years and I attribute it to a combination of being older and more confident/secure in my opinions generally, and especially with realising I don't need/want a man in my life. I really did self-censor a huge amount when I was either with or looking for a boyfriend - I'd internalised that message that men don't want want a 'strident', 'Millie Tant' type. Since shaking off that idea that a woman is incomplete without a man, and realising that I'm actually happier without a relationship - god, that was a blinding revelation and one that flies so much in the face of dominant cultural norms - that I've been liberated in so many other ways too. I don't want to get all 'fish/bicycle' and I don't mean to denigrate women in relationships at all...this has just been my personal experience and what works for me and what has helped me to feel freer from all that abiding by the status quo crap...
I have always considered myself a feminist but in the past two years or so (around the time I had my daughter, no coincidence I am sure) I have felt increasingly militant about it. I also may have been quick to play devil's advocate back in the day about how men also get sidelined.. not sure why. I think it was important to me that I not feel like I was trying to put someone down, I didn't realize that I can't put someone down. Feminism is in no way capable of reversing things and making men in to second class citizens. I just didn't see it.
Am so with you all. I constantly despair at how women collude, but I think there is something deeply psychological going on. There is something so sweet about going along with the status quo and knowing that you have the backing of the common man.
Being a feminist is so isolating.
YANBU I despair on a day to day basis. I'm not sure if it is an ageing thing, but it all seems to be getting worse out there for women.
I am called Militant "McMooncup" by many acquaintances. It fucks me off.
I suppose not, and that's another thing...once you've started thinking about this stuff and having your eyes opened, you get really fed up having to explain it all from the beginning. Feminism 101 - the most basic stuff. It should be widely known that Lennon was like that, but he's been virtually canonised. It should be bleeding obvious that drugging and raping a child is a Bad Thing no matter how many arty movies you've churned out. And it feels like having to go over and over this basic stuff is taking up energy we could be using to actually change things. Which, I'm quite sure, is why the MRA types use arguing round and round a subject as a silencing and delaying tactic.
I hope it is solidarity, as for the John Lennon thing is it that well known? I only found out about it this year which really fucked me off.. Because now I want every article about him to say and known wife beater.
hellsbells yes, that thought has crossed my mind too, but I am trying not to be cynical.
Oh yeah, I was going somewhere with that in response to your post. I can't help wondering, rather uncharitably perhaps, how many of the men protesting in India are motivated by genuine solidarity and how many by the outrage at the violation of one of 'their' women. I was struck by the picture of men with guitars singing Imagine...by that well known wife-beating misogynist cheating twat Lennon. Again...just not getting it.
I was arguing with various twonks on fb the other day about that victim-blaming 'how not to get raped' bollocks and so many men were loudly proclaiming how anti-rape they were but mainly through graphically violent descriptions of what they'd like to do to rapists, or by exhortations for women to carry guns (mostly Americans there, obviously). Of course they were only talking about 'real' stranger rape and they completely failed to see that their violent fantasies were part of the problem. They just don't get it. If it's not that, it's the faux-reasonable mansplaining and head-patting and whataboutery that DOES MY FUCKING HEAD IN (like the joker on the Polanski thread earlier). It's all so bloody tedious.
snowshapes yes I totally agree. I just cannot be bothered being told "yes but" or "what about" and then being told they have a right to an opinion.
It really makes me despair. They are so fucking tenacious and they are so convinced they're right.
One thing which is heartening about the horrible situation in India. Well 2 things: first, that it is actually getting attention. And second that there are so many men out protesting alongside the women. You so rarely see a man even vaguely interested in women's rights in this country, let alone out protesting.
Yes, it is depressing. The male stalwarts on here have put me off commenting on certain threads because it is just so - I don't know - why do I need to explain why to me, as a woman, having rape crisis centres is important and it doesn't mean that I don't support other worthy causes. It's a silencing tactic because you just can't be bothered any more, just let them carry on spouting their claptrap. And that is on a women's rights site.
But generally, there are more men in public space and they have louder voices, so you have to be pretty determined to keep putting your (minority) opinion across, at the same time, as a woman you have more to do, so actually, you are just too bloody tired.
And yes, it is most disheartening when someone you actually respect in RL seriously does you down when you do stand up on a point of gender-equality principle. I did argue a point recently because something seemed to me to ingrain male privilege (though I did not use that phrase), and I was stunned, really, at the strength of the response. It felt like going out on a limb to state what seemed obvious to me. I'm not sure if I now propose to STFU or keep fighting the good fight.
mrsclown that's lovely, I have been so moved by the media coverage of the Indian women protesting. They are so brave, I have an Indian friend who lost her virginity against a wall in a back alley. She never felt she could ask for justice or even tell her family. She still has the physical scars as well as mental scars too. I don't know what it would take to get women in Western countries to get up and shout for their rights anymore.
It is maybe more depressing when women come out with it I agree. One you can't understand why they would want to make their life harder just so they can enjoy the little touches like lipstick and having the door held for them or whatever it is they bleat on about but also because it makes you look mad. Because if these issues were really that bad..ALL women would be upset. Or so you would hope.
Thank God I am not alone in my feelings. If I mention anything remotely feminist to my work colleagues they practically tell me to shut up so I dont any more.
Mind you, I had a deep discussion with a colleague of mine this morning. She is Indian so I asked her if she would mind discussing her opinion on what is happening in India at the moment. She said that women have been getting raped and murdered for years and no one has done anything. She said lots of staff in the call centres who work evenings have just disappeared and no one has done anything. I told her that I will be dancing on V Day in Sheffield for OneBillionRising to protest about what has happened. She thanked me for caring enough. I know my other colleagues think I am mad for doing it but I felt good because it seemed to mean something to her. She actually said in front of one of the colleagues who thinks I am mad 'I am a feminist'. It felt good.
Sorry to go on. I felt a bit inspired!
Yes, I couldn't agree more.
It's so depressing and wearing to have the same arguments over and over again.
There are a couple of stalwart men on this site whose - I have to say, idea of a good time differs so vividly from mine - obviously think we're a bunch of complete idiots and yet just keep coming back and back and back, and can't stay away. They don't agree or sympathise with anything - but rather simply post to be some sort of male 'voice of reason' against the insanity they seem to think we spout. Why? Why would you persist? What do they get out of it? One of them has moved from FWR into relationships recently.
And yes, when the handmaidens get involved too, you honestly do just feel like giving up.
It's so, so depressing sometimes.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.