WWYD? Young child and smoking relative(65 Posts)
My Dd is 3.
Every Saturday she attends a ballet class.
My nan takes her to these as I don't drive. It's a walkable distance but it's easier if she's driven there.
Nan sometimes picks her up Friday and goes straight from her house.
Anyways, after ballet she usually takes Dd back to hers and keeps her until Monday when Dd is then dropped off at pre-school before coming home.
Dd LOVES going to my nans and my nan really enjoys having her as she's been a bit more lonely since my grandad died last year.
Now the problem. My nan is a heavy smoker. Worse than she ever has been. It got worse after my grandad died and she's already been diagnosed with COPD so now she's just surviving instead of living.
She's in a lot of pain with her back too so the smoking probably helps that.
But my problem is, she smokes that much that when Dd comes home she stinks! Really badly. And occasionally she's come home wheezing a little too.
I don't want to stop my nan having her as it's something that both her and Dd love doing. (I have checked with my nan and made it clear if she's in too much pain or if she doesn't want to do it, please tell me and we will stop)
However I don't think it's my place to tell her she can't smoke in her own home...but I don't want Dd to be wheezing either.
Argh...wwyd? Grin and bear it as she might not have long to live, or confront the issue gently and point out that Dd could be suffering?
I'd stop the visits tbh
A lifetime of breathing difficulties is not fun. Watching a child developed asthma and be pinned down fir nebuliser is not something you want to risk.
It's not safe. Your nan will have to come to you to visit and you take her to the class.
Even if she didn't smoke around her there's going to be residual smoke and nicotine in the house
Dd has already been on a nebuliser before so that was scary enough
Her dad has asthma too and when she gets a cold she does wheeze quite badly so ahe could end up developing asthma at some point.
Wow... tricky one. I grew up in a house with two smokers. I must have smelt like an ash tray. Years later I remember telling my dad he shouldn't smoke in the same room as a baby. He thought I was bonkers. When I kept saying it, he actually got quite angry about it and said he could do what he liked in his own home. I haven't helped you at all - if yr mum hasn't absorbed the 'don't smoke around kids' messages by now, then sorry, not sure how to deal with this one Good luck.
Oh dear it is so hard, my dad is the same and he will not be told does your nan smoke with your DD in the car? Could you tell a white lie and say your health visitor has advised you to keep DD away from smoke due to her wheeze and could she smoke outside when your DD is there?
Nan doesn't sound physically able to be honest. Even without the smoking issue. I would stop the visits to nans house and have nan visit you instead.
There's just no way that I would have my dd staying in the home of a heavy smoker. It will be impossible to manage this without spelling out the issue though.
She's definitely able and would be insulted if I told her I didn't think she was well enough..
She never used to be this bad. I think the death of my grandad hit her worse than everyone ever thought it would.
She never used to smoke around me as she knows I HATE it but now she does it when I'm in the room too.
It's like she's given up and I think if I stop Dd going, it's another nail in the coffin for her in life.
I wouldn't allow my child to be exposed to cigarette smoke in this way.
So you told her not to smoke around you but have let her smoke around your dd? I find that odd.
No she knows not to do but she just doesn't think about it anymore
She's operating without thought anymore. Just going through the motions
Which I think it's why she loves having Dd so much
Gives her some form of distraction
Thing is if she has given up you can't sacrifice your dds health fir the Sake of someone who doesn't even care about their own.
You have to do something. It's not just the smoke it's the fire risk. Can she not at least smoke out of the back door? The pain in her back could be due to her copd.... I only know this as my partner is a chronic asthmatic and gets severe back pain when he has an infection. What will happen when she needs oxygen for the condition? She won't be able to smoke then....
Smoking is a deal breaker for me, especially if it was affecting my daughter's health. I would stop the visits and tell your nan that your daughter staying at her house is giving her asthma, and if she wants to see your daughter she visits your (smoke free) house instead. Simple.
I don't think she's thought that far ahead tbh.
And I know I can't sacrifice Dd for her either
It's so horrible to be in this situation
She usually keeps her all weekend? And DD has already been on a nebuliser and you think she might be prone to asthma?
I think you know the answer already, surely?
I think for your daughters health you need to either minimise the time spent in a confined smokey room or stop visits to her house altogether.
I still feel bitter towards my mum for smoking around me, in the house, during pregnancy, in the car etc and my dad (non-smoker) for never saying anything.
It's not something a child understands and as an adult and her parent you are responsible for her health. Speak to your nan about your concerns, I'm sure as she is now suffering with COPD she will completely understand why you don't want your daughter to suffer a life-time of breathing difficulties.
I have asthma and god knows what my lungs are like from breathing in so much second hand smoke.
My mum still smokes in her house so I take my lb for an hour per week max to see her and I ask her not to smoke whilst we are there or we won't visit anymore and she can come to us.
all my family smoke, my DM used to chain smoke on the way to school with us, she's still a 40 a day person but she always goes outside now. I would be OK with it if your mum was going outside but as it is, i'd have to say DD can't stay at hers. Really hard situation for you - I know my DM feels victimized over it, it used to be acceptable before people understood the risks of secondhand smoke, it's hard for them to really get.
I don't think it's awkward at all to insist your nan smokes outside when dd is there.
Just explain that she is wheezing and may develop asthma. Although in the past it was more accepted, nowadays you'd have to be living under a rock to not be aware of the dangers of passive smoking.
It is now illegal to smoke in a car with a child so that's a huge no no.
It's lovely for both of them that they have a close relationship but put some guidelines in place. You're her mum so take steps to protect your daughter, she's so little.
I can see why you wouldn't want to upset her. Would asking her to smoke outside be an option?
I smoke myself but never around my DD's or in the house. I can see her point she lives alone and it's her own house but she needs to put your DD first.
Maybe print off some info on the dangers of smoking around a child. Explain that your dds health has to be your priority. . If she is happy to stop smoking you are happy for your dd to continue staying with her. If not then unfortunately the arrangements will have to change..
I think I'm going to try and say that I've took Dd to the doctor and that they have advised that her exposure to smoking is causing her to wheeze and that it's a strong possibility she might develop asthma
And from there see if she's happy to start smoking outside whilst she has Dd.
Might mean she cuts the visits shorter which I don't mind but do you think that sounds ok?
The house is not safe though. It's in the furniture and the curtains etc
If the smoking is really that heavy it's not just the smoking while she's there you have to worry bout
soubriquet sounds good to me - I had to sign a nosey form from school confirming that DD wasn't spending time in a house where people smoked inside - you could actually find one and show it to your mum (I'll have a quick google). Giles and all the people saying that DC can't even be in a house where a smoker has been, where's your evidence? Not in a combative way, but can you show me because I've not heard being in a house where a smoker lives is a significant issue.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.