I wondered if any of you out there were Harry Potter 'buffs' and could answer some questions about it! I have read all seven books but finished the 7th very shortly after it came out so it has been a few years! I jsut saw the film for the second time today with the DCs and it has got me wondering. I know the films are so different to the books
Few questions I have:
1. Has Snape always been working for Voldermort? In the film he said he has managed to fool Dumbledore for many years - was this the case in the books?
2. Why was Dumbledore's hand blackened in the film? Was this the case in the books?
A few others (More film related)
3. Why was the room of requirement the same for Ginny and Harry as it was for Malfoy? I thought it changed for each person's individual needs?
thanks for the answers. Yes I have read the books though admittedly it has been a few years. Plus, I don't think I took it all 'in' or retained all the information as I would usually read them very late at night when the DCs were all in bed or I couldn't get back to sleep after BF.