Advanced search

Boy in the Striped Pyjamas

(29 Posts)
claireybee Wed 15-Jul-09 14:52:31

Oh. My. God.

That's all

Oblomov Thu 23-Jan-14 17:34:05

Ds1 saw the film at 8, and now, aged 10, wants to read the book.

Noregretsatall Thu 23-Jan-14 17:15:34

It didn't move me either for the same reason as Mistermaker describes. I thought the whole plot somewhat implausible.

carlajean Thu 23-Jan-14 17:00:53

Or The German Trauma by Gitta Sereni

MerylStrop Thu 23-Jan-14 16:53:35

It's terrible
Misconceived and disrespectful
Ditto Book Thief

Tamarto - try Primo Levi. Brilliant writing, utterly gruelling but still contains hope and dignity.

TinyTwoTears Thu 23-Jan-14 16:53:08

DH read the book and cried.

I read the book and didn't. Probably because I read it quickly to find out why DH cried so I didn't feel it.

I liked the book thief but can't remember the story, what other world war 1/2 or holocaust books have there been then? I wasn't aware that there were loads.

atthestrokeoftwelve Thu 23-Jan-14 16:51:02

I thought this was a kids book? My DDs class read it when they were 11 years old.

waycat Thu 23-Jan-14 16:48:37

I saw the film first a few years ago. That prompted me to read the book, and it is one of those rare occasions where I think the film is actually better than the book.

carlajean Wed 22-Jan-14 20:40:20

Hated it. Like a child of a high up member of the Nazi party wouldn't know all about it. It insults the memory of all those who died in the camps.

mistermakersgloopyglue Wed 22-Jan-14 17:09:21


mistermakersgloopyglue Wed 22-Jan-14 17:07:47

I watched the film and thought it was shit. The whole 'shocking' thing At the end is that the little German boy gets killed - what, is the sight of dozens of jews being sent to their death not shocking enough in itself? It was like 'yeah well we know that the jewish boy is going to die at the end, that goes without saying, so we need to give it a 'lil twist to give it that extra something'.

The ending was totally unnecessary, not to mention the fact that it would never actually happen.

hollyisalovelyname Mon 13-Jan-14 00:08:14

I thought it was a brilliant book.

theonewiththenoisychild Sun 12-Jan-14 15:48:54

i watched the film and didnt like it tbh

ChopsTheDuck Thu 16-Jul-09 11:37:25

it's written from a child's perspective but on the back cover of my version it does say it isn't intended to be for children.

AliGrylls Thu 16-Jul-09 11:24:22

This is one of the best books I have read in years. Although tere are lots of books about the holocaust there are none like this. It doesn't take the sentimental angle it takes the disturbing angle. I couldn't get it out of my head for days afterwards. It really is disturbing when you think about the cruelty of war and in particular the holocaust.

Anyway I won't say anymore in case I ruin it but it is a definite definite must read.

FairLadyRantALot Thu 16-Jul-09 11:13:03

I will let ya know once I read it.....

twofalls Thu 16-Jul-09 10:56:42

I thought it was interesting to see it from a German child's eyes, although you are right. - were they really that naive? And I don't think it matters that it couldn't have really happened - I think it's more symbolic than that.

I am glad I read it but cheerful it was not.

FairLadyRantALot Thu 16-Jul-09 10:54:48

it's a children's book...really

Tamarto Thu 16-Jul-09 10:51:10

It's classed as a childrens book isn't it?

I'm not sure how many of them are representative of real life. grin I'm not sure it was marketed as an acurate portrayal of the times.

FairLadyRantALot Thu 16-Jul-09 10:49:02

I just looked and it was first released in 2006...well...that puts that one right

FairLadyRantALot Thu 16-Jul-09 10:45:20

Well... UQD....if books about the holocaust keep it in peoples mind...not a bad thing...

just thought it will be very apt me reading it on my Holiday, considering I will be spending it in Germany!
It is not a new book neither is it?
Like I said I got it last year from a charity shop, and it looks old and a bit battered, so, assumed it is quite old....not looked at the date of release...

FairLadyRantALot Thu 16-Jul-09 10:32:11

well...i know it will be a heavy read, obviously...but will be the only time I have to read anything jsut for fun, as once back I have to get reading all those books I should be reading for my Uni course, lol

ChopsTheDuck Thu 16-Jul-09 10:12:19

It's nto a very cheerful holiday read!

FairLadyRantALot Thu 16-Jul-09 10:07:31

IT's the book I gonna read whilst on Holiday...I bought it last year (before I heard about teh movie) from a charity shop, but not gotten round to read it yet...but it sounds like a very interesting story!

ChopsTheDuck Thu 16-Jul-09 10:01:31

I've not actually read the book yet, but dd and I watched the film. We were on a Holocaust theme after visiting Holland and Germany. While there we had visted the Anne Frank Huis and the Neungamme and Belsen-Bergen sites.

It is a nasty ending and I'm not sure it was necessary. I felt like the author was trying to deliberately shock without any real grounds for it. I'm sure I read somewhere that there is no way that could have happened in reality. I also think there is absolutely no chance that the German boy could have been that naive at that age, in that situation.

UnquietDad Thu 16-Jul-09 09:31:40

It seems a favourite preoccupation of some writers. "Oh, I know, let's write about the Holocaust" - second only to "I know, let's write about the First World War." Surely it's been done to death now.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now