My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

What we're reading

just watched Pride and Prejudice... i love the film (Keira Knightly version) is the book hard going?

55 replies

juicychops · 11/07/2009 21:58

im dying to read it when i get a chance and a break from my studying

OP posts:
Report
meemarsgotabrandnewbump · 11/07/2009 22:03

Not hard going at all. Jane Austen is very readable.

Report
littlelamb · 11/07/2009 22:04

O I love Pride and Prejudice. I read it whenever I'm ill, it cheers me right up

Report
janeite · 11/07/2009 22:05

It's brilliant - and I am one of the few people on here who loves the KK version. No doubt you'll get loads of people coming along telling you to watch the BBC one - gah.

Report
HeadFairy · 11/07/2009 22:07

If you want to watch a different filmed version definitely try the Jennifer Ehle/Colin Firth one, absolutely brilliant.

The book isn't a hard read at all. Fab book.

Report
stubbyfingers · 11/07/2009 22:08

Is it really readable? I always imagined it would be a bit, well, Dickensy.

Or soppy?

Report
HeadFairy · 11/07/2009 22:08

janeite, xpost.... watch the BBC one juicychops!!! Jennifer Ehle is soooo much better as Lizzie than KK and her silly pouty mouth!

Report
Frizbe · 11/07/2009 22:08

Well if you don't like the book version, you can get the grapic novel with Zombies or the marvel comics version!!
www.chroniclebooks.com/index/main,book-info/store,books/products_id,7847/title,Pride-and-Prejudice-a nd-Zombies/

or

marvel.com/catalog/?id=11466

Report
juicychops · 11/07/2009 22:09

i read the other boleyn girl which i loved. then watched the natalie portman version of the film which wasn't all that. then thought id watch the BBC one which i thought was even worse! so wont ever watch a BBC version of anything now

OP posts:
Report
Poledra · 11/07/2009 22:09

'Tis a comfort read for me - something I reread when I'm ill, feeling blue etc. Not hard going at all. Enjoy

Report
littlelamb · 11/07/2009 22:09

O no, Dickens is a chore, I've never finished one yet.

Report
juicychops · 11/07/2009 22:10

ooo forgot there is a colin firth version!! im gunna add that to my Lovefilm list

OP posts:
Report
HeadFairy · 11/07/2009 22:26

Hate to say juicychops but the colin firth version is the BBC version.

Report
Technofairy · 11/07/2009 22:35

It's an excellent book, very readable. Do give it a try, you won't be disappointed.

I thought the KN film was pants and didn't watch it all. The BBC version (Colin Firth/Jennifer Ehle) is far superior and much truer to the book.

Report
janeite · 11/07/2009 22:37

The BBC version has Alison Steadman in and she was grossly mis-cast and is beyond irritating. And whoever played Elizabeth, with her simper and her dimples, was crap too.

Report
Heated · 11/07/2009 22:41

Whilst I was pleasantly surprised by KK not being as awful as I feared, I was woefully disappointed in Pa & Ma Bennet and actually most of the cast.

The BBC version has a vastly superior Bennet family, including the odious Mr Collins who just oozes slug-like across the screen!

P&P is a lovely read and very witty.

Report
Heated · 11/07/2009 22:44

Janeite, Mrs Bennet is beyond irritating so Alison Steadman is perfect! And Benjamin Whitrow is spot-on as Mr Bennet.

Report
Pyrocanthus · 11/07/2009 22:52

It's much more tightly written than Dickens. Very sharply observed. Absolutely not soppy.
Brilliant.

Fancy you posting here, Janeite.

Report
hocuspontas · 11/07/2009 22:52

Mr Collins in the BBC one was SUPERB!!

Report
Technofairy · 11/07/2009 22:53

I agree Heated, the casting of the BBC version is pretty much spot on in the way that Jane Austen describes the characters.

I can watch it again and again and read the book in between and never feel that it does any dis-service to it.

Am straying a bit here but I also feel much the same about the Emma Thompson version of Sense and Sensibility. Better than any other I've seen.

Report
ShowOfHands · 11/07/2009 22:55

I despised KK as Elizabeth (all that pouting and staring in mirrors, gah!) but did like the exploration of Mr and Mrs Bennett's relationship in that version. I also thought the social inadequacies of Mr Collins were better portrayed without the oozing slug-like that prevailed in the BBC version.

All that said... the BBC version is superb. I adore it and watch it when ill. Colin Firth as Darcy, well, oh Sweet Moses.

The book, OP, is lovely. And witty. And well paced. Definitely read it.

Report
RachieW · 11/07/2009 22:59

Read it OP! I love it and have read it over and over. I've not watched the KK film as I love the book so much I didn't want it spoilt...not a huge KK fan. I do own the BBC Colin Firth version on video and dvd and I agree with others that it's a very truthful adaptation with spot on actors playing the characters.

Oooh I want to go and read it again now...

Report
Bumperslucious · 11/07/2009 23:01

Read it, it's lovely. Also interesting to read along side Austen is this helps you understand the subtleties.

You absolutely must watch the BBC version, it is fantastic and the low production value just adds to the authenticity I think (but then I have been slavishly watching House of Elliott re-runs).

Mrs Bennett is meant to be annoying, the casting is perfect I think, all round. Love Jennifer Ehle, didn't she and Firth have a little fling whilst filming? Adds to the frisson for me!

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

janeite · 11/07/2009 23:08

Alison Steadman too old and wrongly annoying imho.

Mr Collins good in both versions. Mr Collins also great in 'Bride And Prejudice' in a strangely Ali G sort of way.

I did like Lady Catherine in the BBC one. Didn't like Colin Firth.

Report
Bumperslucious · 11/07/2009 23:11

Didn't like Colin Firth? Wha.....?

Report
Technofairy · 11/07/2009 23:28

Eh????

Colin Firth was the perfect Mr Darcy. Exactly the right mix of arrogance and sexuality. Matthew McFadyen is a boy in comparison.

And Alison Steadman did Mrs Bennett proud, all nerves, fluttering, selfishness and emotional outbursts.

Read the book OP and then see which tv/film adaptation you like best.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.