Talk

Advanced search

Book or books that you thought would be good but was disappointed with after reading it?

(98 Posts)
boogiewoogie Mon 07-Jul-08 20:48:28

For me it would have to be "On Chesil beach" I really enjoyed "Atonement" and had high expectaions for this but the end was an anticlimax. Pun intended.

MmeBovary Mon 07-Jul-08 20:56:26

Everyone raves about Lord of the Rings, ot Terry Pratchett or Harry Potter and I think they are all complete pants! And I have tried believe me. Give me Enid Blyton or a nice gritty novel about serial killers anytime! Actually I think I am reasonably well read - I think I just don't DO fantasy....

jojosmaman Mon 07-Jul-08 20:57:14

The Memory Keepers Daughter, it fizzled out, very disappointed twas I as I had spent about an hour choosing it for my Far East trip. Also The Devil Wears Prada had no storyline, not that I thought it would be great but there was a certain amount of hype!

claricebeansmum Mon 07-Jul-08 20:57:39

Lord of the Rings
Snow falling on Cedars
Captains wotsits mandolin

ArcticRoll Mon 07-Jul-08 20:58:12

Time Traveller's Wife
The Book Thief

FabioTheWhisperingCat Mon 07-Jul-08 20:58:34

A Prayer for Owen Meany (I think)

Many hours of my life I'll never get back.

I only got to the end so I could give myself the pleasure of ripping the fecking book to pieces.

God it was dreadful.

nkf Mon 07-Jul-08 20:59:28

Captain Correlli's Mandolin. I didn't finish it.

georgiemama Mon 07-Jul-08 21:01:08

The Lovely Bones. NO ta. And weird.

LittleBella Mon 07-Jul-08 21:01:56

I've just read Anne Enright's "The Gathering"

It was OK but it seemed to me that she hadn't developed it as much as she set it up and it got rave reviews. I got to the end of it wondering where the rest of the novel was.

JaneHH Mon 07-Jul-08 21:10:31

"The Golden Notebook" by Doris Lessing (JaneHH prepares to be put on the ducking stool for heresy)

AbstractMouse Mon 07-Jul-08 21:11:52

The Secret History Donna Tartt

Onlyaphase Mon 07-Jul-08 21:13:04

Agree with Articroll - The Book Thief was not as good as it could have been. Was it translated from another language? May have been better in the original.

Lio Mon 07-Jul-08 21:13:15

The Golden Notebook - nobody in my reading group even finished it.
That Peter Ackroyd one, Hawsmoor.

Califrau Mon 07-Jul-08 21:18:00

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BibiThree Mon 07-Jul-08 21:21:05

The Oliver Readers - the end was just soooooo rushed and felt incomplete.
I second Captain Correlli's Mandolin, didn't finish it either.

taipo Mon 07-Jul-08 21:22:31

Another vote for The Lovely Bones

spicemonster Mon 07-Jul-08 21:23:46

I have just finished The Steep Approach to Garbadale by Iain Banks and it was a massive disappointment. It needed some serious editorial input and I got the feeling they just didn't dare mess with his 'genius'

ByTheSea Mon 07-Jul-08 21:24:47

Time Traveller's Wife. I never did finish it.

Troutpout Mon 07-Jul-08 21:24:59

I third Captain Corelli's mandolin
Cloud Atlas
I second Atonement
The Alchemist

MmeBovary Mon 07-Jul-08 21:25:28

I loved the Lovely Bones!

BigGitDad Mon 07-Jul-08 21:26:48

Cloud Atlas disappointed me so many people told me it was so brilliant I think I was expecting too much in the end.

Niecie Mon 07-Jul-08 21:27:23

We need to Talk about Kevin. Nearly gave up after the first couple of chapters and I almost never give up on books.

Lio Mon 07-Jul-08 21:28:28

Wuthering Heights
Wide Sargasso Sea
Catcher in the Rye
The Great Gatsby

(But I loved Polo and Riders wink)

calsworld Mon 07-Jul-08 21:32:37

The Memory Keepers Daughter, very disappointing, interesting storyline, but so much more that could have been done with it,

policywonk Mon 07-Jul-08 21:34:11

Anything by Flann O'Brien (sp.?). I just don't GET IT.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now