Talk

Advanced search

Did anyone else think that The Salt Path was seriously overrated?

(19 Posts)
Gone2far Tue 14-Jan-20 20:18:08

I'm ploughing through it for my bookgroup, but, my God, it's tedious. Like sharing a long car journey with an embittered aging hippy. I know that most people loved it, so I'm obviously missing something, but did anyone else just not get it?

OP’s posts: |
Sweetpea1989 Tue 14-Jan-20 20:22:31

Nope I found it repetitive and dull.

wonkytonkwoman Tue 14-Jan-20 20:24:43

I didn't like it either.

Ariela Tue 14-Jan-20 20:27:12

I'm glad you said this, only I bought it as a Christmas read but have barely got anywhere with it (normally I pick up that size paperback and I get stuck in and finish it within 3 hours or so). Keep picking it up but cannot get stuck in.

Snozzlemaid Tue 14-Jan-20 20:29:56

I didn't like it either. Massively overrated.
I found them so irritating, making so many stupid decisions.

Apolloanddaphne Tue 14-Jan-20 21:27:10

I absolutely loved it and for a long time afterwards wanted to cut loose and just walk too. Maybe it is an age thing? I am the same age as the couple in the book and could really relate to where they were at.

Portulaca Wed 15-Jan-20 09:51:03

I loved it. Was very invested in their story, but also felt the frustrations with them for making some bad wrong turns and ending up homeless.

Raynor Winn has a new book out this year, which I'm hoping will bring us up to date with their lives and hopefully a bit more positive for the future now they've got their lives back on track.

Gone2far Wed 15-Jan-20 10:07:40

I'm older apollo (maybe that's it).
I just thought that they were relentlessly mean-minded about most people they came across, and simultaneously felt free to steal/freeload off them.
I suppose a lot depends on how much you empathised with the writer, as there was precious little else.

OP’s posts: |
Greenteandchives Wed 15-Jan-20 13:34:48

Yes. It was all a bit samey. Nothing much happened, although I was interested in Moth’s physical improvements along the way.
I am not sure why it got so much acclaim, as there are much better books in this vein.

MaJoady Wed 15-Jan-20 14:40:56

Nope, i disliked it immensely. Obviously I felt sorry for them at the start, but it was such a chippy, preachy read that I quickly got annoyed. And I hated the tour guide style facts shoe horned in periodically.

Shame, because I really love that part of the world and was inspired to read it after loving Bill Bryson’s A Walk in the Woods

Chickenitalia Wed 15-Jan-20 14:44:27

My SIL raved about it, so I had a read too.
It was awful, I found myself constantly wanting to shout at the couple for just being so damn self centred and rude! Talk about judging... so much navel gazing about how poorly they were treated and then judging all the people they came across. I couldn’t finish it. It wasn’t uplifting or inspiring, it was just annoying.
Still can’t work out what was meant to be so great.

musicmaiden Wed 15-Jan-20 15:00:57

I think because it is an incredible set of events – losing everything, terminal illness diagnosis, deciding to walk/wild camp, it got all the plaudits, which kind of ignored the fact it's not brilliantly written.

I liked it in some ways; it made me want to visit, and the relationship between Moth's health and the walking was fascinating. And I think the paragraphs around the way people treat the homeless were heartfelt. But I agree she was quite scathing about some people ('tourists' – as if they were not, despite their different way of doing things). And why would you not take a hat or sunscreen on a long walk in the summer, FGS! Especially second time around hmm

Beebumble2 Wed 29-Jan-20 15:58:11

Chickenitalia I totally agree with you. They lost their money, they were underprepared and lived on inappropriate social benefits.
However, my book group thought it was great!

LightDrizzle Wed 29-Jan-20 16:02:33

Nope. I’m with you and your description was perfect.

AgentProvocateur Wed 29-Jan-20 16:16:32

I was about to download this to my Kindle. But I won’t now! grin

thereplycamefromanchorage Wed 29-Jan-20 22:46:27

Not what you mean by inappropriate social benefits, Beebumble. There was no suggestion that they were claiming benefits they shouldn't have, and indeed they may well have been entitled to other benefits.

Deathraystare Thu 30-Jan-20 16:38:13

Well I did enjoy it!

Flippinfab40 Thu 30-Jan-20 16:57:37

I enjoyed it because I'm from the south west and know the coast path well but I wouldn't want to read anything else written by her. I didn't enjoy her writing but did like reading about the route and places they walked through.

Ontopofthesunset Mon 03-Feb-20 11:49:10

It was an interesting story but she's not a very good writer so it was very plodding in terms of narrative. And also nothing really happened on the walk other than dull things about sunburn and being hungry.

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in