Advanced search

the house of silk.warning maybe spoiler/upsetting

(7 Posts)
Theas18 Fri 26-Oct-12 08:12:59

Anyone read the Anthony horowitiz Sherlock Holmes book the Houser of silk?

Am I the only one who thought "shit it's Jimmy savile all over again" ? ? ?

NicknameTaken Fri 26-Oct-12 12:48:43

Yes. I liked it. I read it before the whole Jimmy Saville thing came out, so didn't have that case specifically in mind.

tiggy114 Sun 28-Oct-12 20:47:42

What the heck did it have to do with j saville? I read it at least a year ago but seemed to think it was a good effort and enjoyed it.

uoYekorByMredluomS Sun 28-Oct-12 20:48:57

Et did you read the same book tiggy? I enjoyed it but thought that theme was a bit modern and shoehorned in iyswim.

MrsVincentPrice Mon 29-Oct-12 21:21:17

I read it some time ago, and didn't like that aspect of it.

PervyMuskrat Thu 01-Nov-12 21:50:15

I thought it was ok, but agree that the theme felt shoehorned in. Didn't help that I read it after the Kim Newman Moriarty book, which was a very good book indeed.

Clawdy Thu 01-Nov-12 22:36:32

Yes,the conspiracy of silence, and the cover-up and hint of famous names did bring the current scandal to mind. I wasn't keen on that story-line either. I also felt it spoiled the authentic feel of the novel,as Conan Doyle would never have dealt with such subject matter. Well-written though.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: