Talk

Advanced search

God as the bad guy

(7 Posts)
lovemyskinnyjeans Tue 24-May-11 14:03:51

What do you guys all think of the representation of God as a more villainous figure in fiction?

Do people feel very strongly about this in the context of fictional work, or do they just not care?

AngryFeet Tue 24-May-11 14:05:30

I don't care as I see God as a fictional character anyway.

OfflineFor30Seconds Tue 24-May-11 14:12:04

I'd only really come across it in The Gospel according to Jesus Christ by Jose Saramago; I found it a very thought provoking book which made me question commonly held beliefs. So I feel strongly that it's a good thing as I don't believe anything is beyond the realms of discussion.

musicmaiden Tue 24-May-11 14:16:35

It is a completely fair and fascinating interpretation - One man's loving creator is another man's vengeful, unpleasant pyschopath.

Which books were you thinking of? Philip Pullman?

lovemyskinnyjeans Tue 24-May-11 14:21:27

Hi there, not any author in specific, anything which addresses this subject, really.

I was thinking about works which have provoked huge furore even though they are fictional (The Da Vinci Code springs first to mind), and I confess I'm struggling to put my finger on where they cross the line from inoffensive fantasy to "attacking Christianity."

WidowWadman Tue 24-May-11 14:38:08

But the DaVinci Code has the churchy types as the bad guy, not god, doesn't it?

Anyway, questioning god and his motives is an old theme in literature (e.g. the boring old despot in Paradise Lost) , and if executed well I can't see anything wrong with it.

newbroom Fri 03-Jun-11 15:33:39

I was going to suggest going back to basics with Paradise Lost but I see WidowWadman has beaten me to it grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now