Talk

Advanced search

Anyone read 'Room'

(13 Posts)
Theantsgomarching Thu 25-Nov-10 14:11:30

I thought it was great - so well written

basildonbond Fri 26-Nov-10 21:23:30

ahem there were quite a few threads about this a while back - and the consensus was that <whispers> it wasn't very good ... sorry!

Horton Fri 26-Nov-10 21:39:25

I really liked it. Ahem.

JuanManuelFanjo Fri 26-Nov-10 22:28:01

I liked it too...but I have no taste as I liked 'The Time Traveller's Wife' which got a slating recently.

Horton Sat 27-Nov-10 08:39:19

Oh, I liked that as well. Loved it, in fact.

carrotsandpeasifyouplease Sat 27-Nov-10 17:59:21

i thought the beginning and middle was great and very original but they seemed to get out so easily I sort of gave up after that.

Horton Sun 28-Nov-10 20:35:48

In a way, the bit after they got out was more interesting to me. It was kind of eerie to watch the unravelling of the world the boy had known and to see it replaced with something (slightly) more normal. How they got out kind of didn't matter. The point was the extraordinary change they had to get used to.

Theantsgomarching Sun 28-Nov-10 20:54:54

Totally agree Horton - there is soooo much of the same out there and this was a great stand out read for me..

Horton Sun 28-Nov-10 21:09:44

I'm really looking forward to reading more by her. I thought it was really original in the way it was handled. And the little boy was totally believable to me.

Scaltini Mon 29-Nov-10 08:58:05

I thought it was excellent. Accidentally lost 2 hours in the bath reading it as it was so gripping!!

Theantsgomarching Mon 29-Nov-10 09:02:37

I read it travelling last weekend and the poor man beside me on the plane thought I was gone a bit mad I think, was roaring crying!

CheeseCheese Mon 29-Nov-10 09:05:49

anyone want to flog me theres for less than teh £10 on amazon?
will paypal

HollyTwat Mon 29-Nov-10 09:09:02

You can have mine cheese
I liked it but did find myself skipping through the first bit
Pm me and I'll send it tomorrow

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now