Talk

Advanced search

Can you still lose weight by eating 1200 calories if..

(28 Posts)
FlyHighLittleBee Thu 28-Jul-16 08:54:50

You eat quite a bit of junk? for instance, im doing MFP and yesterday I ate:

A ham salad sandwich
Beef hula hoops
Grapes
Half a bag of mini cheddars
Slow cooked pork chop, mash and veg
Kit Kat
Maoam stripe thingy

And it came under 1200 cals! But will I lose weight doing this, or do you have to eat 1200 cals of the right sorts of food?

whiteonesugar Thu 28-Jul-16 09:36:00

You will lose weight if you're taking in less calories than you're expending. However, you can eat more of the 'good' stuff!

FlyHighLittleBee Thu 28-Jul-16 13:19:27

Perfect. I don't actually need a lot of food, but find it hard to give up my packet of crisps at lunch time and a treat or two at night. Sounds like MFP is definitely the way to go. Thanks!

BopperBop Thu 28-Jul-16 17:16:10

I expect you will, but the question is can you stick to 1200 cals? That's really quite low and so perhaps quite hard to stick to?

DownstairsMixUp Thu 28-Jul-16 17:28:21

Yes definitely! Back in my student days I did but must say I'd then be ravenous for a while and yo yo diet blush I'm giving low carb a go now

gonzo155 Fri 29-Jul-16 18:44:06

MFP only works if you weigh and track everything, so just be careful. I thought I was doing well but then realised that I wasn't counting oil, mayo, tomato sauce, milk, drinks etc. and as I wasn't properly weighing things like mash I was actually eating well over.

Not trying to put you off but just be aware - we tend to underestimate food and overestimate exercise.

BIWI Sun 31-Jul-16 16:29:45

A calorie isn't a calorie isn't a calorie!

Calories from carbs are the ones you need to avoid, because it's the carbs that make you fat.

yumyumpoppycat Sun 31-Jul-16 19:24:07

You could prob get away with one small 'treat' if the rest of the food providing 1000 cals is unprocessed things like veg, fish, beans, natural yog, nuts and seeds etc and providing the vitamins, proteins and whatever else that you need....problem is for me when I start on things like crisps its really hard to then eat well for the rest of the day as I start craving other things.

lougle Sun 31-Jul-16 19:37:55

Yes you'll lose weight, but if you eat junk you'll use your calories up in just a few mouthfuls and won't be full at all.

Ragusa Tue 02-Aug-16 23:06:28

see I am of the opposite opinion. It really doesn't matter where your calories come from from a weight loss perspective. If you eat fewer than you expend, notwithstanding anything like PCOS or insulin resistance or diabetes, then you're going to lose weight.

I find it helpful to continue eating (and logging) snack treat foods, as that way I don't feel like I'm being deprived. I'd rather massively cut back on my main meal portions and then still have my snacks. Obviously, this mightn't be recommended from a nutritional point of view but psychologically it works for me.

Wolpertinger Wed 03-Aug-16 07:04:36

You can but MFP will be telling you that you are way over your sugar for the day and in real life, not MFP, a calorie is not a calorie - carbs and especially sugar are much harder for your body to deal with so you are hampering your weightloss. Plus the point is to be healthy - snacks are not healthy.

Also I would doubt you are really under 1200 calories - I found when I did MFP that I always underestimated slightly what I ate, so my idea of a portion of mash, pork chop etc was prob actually more calories than I was letting on.

You prob had more than 1200 calories in that day.

BIWI Wed 03-Aug-16 08:14:05

But the point is, if you're already overweight so that you need to diet, chances are you're already on your way to insulin resistance - so it's especially important to realise that calories from sugar and carbs are not the ones you should be eating.

Ragusa Wed 03-Aug-16 11:03:39

If you are doing exercise as well as dieting, then cutting out the majority of carbs is a really bad idea. You need carbs to fuel your body when you exercise. There's a reason why endurance athletes carbo-load before events.... I know if I don't eat carbs then I find swimming/ interval training etc very very hard work.

I'm not saying that you should fill up on carbs, in fact, filling up on lean protein and some good fats is a good idea. Just, don't cut them out entirely and work with your own psychology. I didn't mean I ate baby portions of main meals and then 3 bags of walkers a day but perhaps that wasn't clear from my earlier contribution :D

KatharinaRosalie Wed 03-Aug-16 11:12:07

are you sure about your portion sizes? Unless you're talking about the tiniest sandwich and a spoonful of mash, I would be surprised if all this is really under 1200.

Ragusa Wed 03-Aug-16 11:24:39

Agreed, weighing food is a boring but important if you're doing MFP or any calorie-based diet, otherwise it's easy to underestimate the calories you're actually eating.

What the OP described could be around 1200. Not totally impossible but as you say, would have to be a very small amount of mash, smallish pork chop, sandwich potentially without butter, etc.

BIWI Wed 03-Aug-16 13:36:13

If you're doing 'ordinary' exercise, cutting down on carbs isn't going to be a problem.

But it's perfectly possible to train, and train hard, if you're a low carber, because this means you've switched your body from burning carbs to burning fat. And even elite athletes have enough body fat to keep them going through an endurance event like a marathon.

It's simply not true that you have to have carbs for fuel!

BIWI Wed 03-Aug-16 13:37:01

As this will attest

absolutelynotfabulous Wed 03-Aug-16 13:43:36

I agree. I've been 1200- ing for as long as I can remember but it's sooo easy to let it creep up. I lose weight but very slowly.

I'm still not sure about the low carb theory but I agree that cutting carbs is pretty easy.

KatharinaRosalie Wed 03-Aug-16 14:09:28

Low carb and high protein diet allows you to build muscle and lose weight at the same time - something people often think is not possible.
www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/01/160127132741.htm

Ragusa Wed 03-Aug-16 15:28:05

The low-carb diet theory is not universally accepted and there is evidence that carb restriction impacts performance even at low intensities and for shorter durations of exercise. If you're knackered you're less likely to keep up with exercise surely?

It is also not what the NHS advises, as it can lead to people missing out on macronutrients, dietary fibre, and other issues.

WorldsBiggestGrotbag Wed 03-Aug-16 15:33:14

Are you sure that was under 1200 calories? Must have been really small portions.

WorldsBiggestGrotbag Wed 03-Aug-16 15:34:10

But yeah, with that diet I imagine you'd lose weight. You'd also be missing a lot of essential nutrients though I reckon. Did you have 4 portions of veg with your dinner?

PaperdollCartoon Wed 03-Aug-16 15:38:48

BIWI

Carbs don't make you fat. Eating more than you burn makes you fat. Can't believe anyone still believes this? confused

There's also a big difference between a 'carb' that's brown rice and fruit and a 'carb' that's a biscuit. You don't need carbs for fuel but you do need them to run your brain. At least 20% of our daily calories are used by our brains and the brain runs purely on glucose. Yes sugar is worse for us than fat generally but don't demonise an entire nutrient group.

BIWI Wed 03-Aug-16 17:05:12

Carbs do make you fat. Read any of the latest scientific literature.

Carbs like vegetables and salad (and some fruits) are all fine - it's not about cutting out or demonising an entire nutrient group.

But it's important to recognise that too much carbohydrate has a really negative impact on our blood sugar levels, resulting in too much insulin, which results ultimately in gaining fat.

BIWI Wed 03-Aug-16 17:06:11

It is also not what the NHS advises, as it can lead to people missing out on macronutrients, dietary fibre, and other issues

The NHS is woefully out of date.

And as long as you get your carbs from vegetables and salads, and some fruits, there's not a problem with missing out at all.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now