Advanced search

Could my cat have been saved if I found her sooner?

(67 Posts)
Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 11:53:21

I am trying to get over the death of my cat who I think was hit by a car outside our house on Friday night.

We did not find her until 10am on Saturday morning despite going out searching about 9.30 on Friday night (we last saw her at 6pm Friday) and again at 7.30am on Saturday. She was lying in a gap between two bushes at the edge of a little park across the road from our house - I guess either someone had moved her off the road and put her there or she had crawled there.

What is bothering me greatly is whether if I had found her on Friday night at 9.30 and she had been run over, if taking her to a vet could have saved her. She had no visible injuries other than one slightly bleeding claw; her eyes were open and her tongue was poking out of the side of her mouth. I can only guess that she was hit - I can't think of another explanation. She would usually have been in at that time of night or have come back if called. And I was out calling her at 9.30: I am trying to persuade myself that if she was conscious then she would have answered me, and also if she was injured and could make it to the park, she could have made it to our house.

I don't know, I don't know if anyone can know really. Because I could see no visible injuries I don't know how she died. May seem like a silly question, but can a cat die from the impact alone of a collision without showing external injuries? I hate the thought that she was injured and couldn't move and died in the park in that freezing night (it was very cold that night) when we were only about 10 feet away inside our house. Or that she died in pain and cold and could have been saved if I had just shone a torch there when I was out looking for her in the evening. I must have walked past her several times.

I also deeply regret not trying harder to make her wear a collar with a phone number on it: if I knocked a cat down and it had a number on it I would call it to let the owner know. She was microchipped but that's no help unless she was in a vet's.

Sorry, a bit rambly. It's been a real shock and I feel responsible for her death. It's enough that she has died without feeling like it might have been preventable by me.

RubbishMantra Tue 31-Jan-17 22:11:58

Oh, I didn't realise somebody had resurrected this thread to make a point about letting cats outside.

I do hope Zoonose is OK, and not saddened more by the views of that particular poster.

RubbishMantra Tue 31-Jan-17 22:03:13

Zoonose, I'm so very sorry for your loss. I lost my beloved Creature when we were moving house, and had to keep her shut in a room for several weeks. She fell from a great height when somebody forgot to close the window in the room. Probably would've survived if she hadn't hit a stone planter. Her eyes were open too, and she died on impact, meaning instant death, no suffering. So the same for your beloved cat I'd think.

Ignore Iguannas terribly non empathic post. I can't imagine why a person would post such a thing whilst you're grieving. I have cats that are indoor/outdoors who have access to the outside during the day, like your DCat.

flowers for you and DCat.

Fluffycloudland77 Tue 31-Jan-17 20:54:21

I'm so sorry, your poor cat flowers

LellyWitchyWoo Tue 31-Jan-17 20:32:20

My young cat also died 28/1/17 my husband found her next door garden no visible signs just blood round her mouth nose. I am deverstated. We presume she was hit by a car and ran there before her life faded. She was my baby I miss her terribly. sad

EmmaKeay4 Fri 16-Sep-16 22:43:26

My cat got run over tonight and she was black so that made it a little harder to see her but she usually gets across the road before the cars near her but this time was unfortunate for her.

We did have 3 cats until my poor baby sooty was hit by a car and they just drove off! What sick f*** would do that! She was hit just the same way your poor cat was. Smack bang in the jaw blood everywhere on her face and eyes wide open. I know how you feel now after this experience. She was the youngest cat we had but she was the 3rd cat we had until my oldest cat Misty had to be put to sleep because she was too ill to even walk and get up out of the cat litter tray and then we had Lucky the other black cat. We actually thought it was lucky that had gotten hit but we then looked at sootys right ear.

Sooty had a chunk missing on the corner of her right ear. This was due to my dog, Bailey but he was roughly a pup himself when we first had sooty. Well anyway they were trying to get used to each other but sooty decided to swipe and Bailey bit a little bit of her ear and made it bleed. The last time I had saw sooty was when she came in a room in my house and I tried to grab her for some fuss. But she got away from me. She hadn't long gone back out when she was hit. My dad came back to find her lying there on the road by speed humps in my street and as soon as I saw her I burst out crying! I will always miss this poor little bugga no matter what. If she hadn't had gone out this wouldn't have happened! Why any of my cats!?!

Sorry it is a bit long but I wanted to share with you my experience and how I know you feel like.😭

timtam23 Fri 10-Jun-16 22:16:49

Iguana I don't think that comment is very helpful on this thread.

Zoonose I'm sorry to read about your cat, I agree with everyone who said it was likely very quick and she wouldn't have known anything about it. flowers for you

Papergirl1968 Thu 09-Jun-16 21:54:37

Thanks, iguana, that's really helpful - not. You don't sound very sympathetic, to put it mildly. And did you realise this thread was over three years old?
We lost two cats to the road when I still lived with my parents, and it was heartbreaking. It's a risk, yes, but i think many cats are happier being able to go out in the day. My boy loves wandering in and out while it's warm and sunny.
There is a difference between being thrown out as you put it and being allowed some freedom.

Iguanna Thu 09-Jun-16 07:55:36

It's a myth that you should keep your cat outside. Would you throw your kids outside? Cats have less road sense than children so is it really wise to put them out? Forget cars there are other bad things like dogs disease and people some people deliberately run cats over I once witnessed it on a car park the group of Asian lads in the car were laughing the cats eye popped right out of its head. I keep my cats inside they can live 20 years plus and have healthy happy lives, learn to think for yourself and what's best for your cat instead instead of an old wives tale. Keep your cats in if you don't want it squashed!

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 22:29:21

Thanks WeezyPeezy, VivienneMary and VivaLeBeaver. I'm sorry you lost your cat in this way too Viva

I feel more settled that my cat was gone pretty quickly from what people have said here.

Vivienne you are right about blame too.

WeezyPeezy it's good to know that there are people who care if a cat is run over, it was a kind thing you did.

VivaLeBeaver Wed 28-Nov-12 22:17:59

I'm sorry about your cat.

I've had a cat killed after been hit by a car. The neighbours saw it happen and said the cat died instantly. They got me and I ran out but she was already dead. Not a mark on her, she just looked asleep.

ILoveSparklers Wed 28-Nov-12 22:12:21

Ok, I'm getting soppy now but like these too.

So dear friends your love has gone
Only tears to dwell upon
I dare not say as the wind must blow
So a love is lost, a love is won

Go to sleep and dream again
Soon your hopes will rise and then
From all this gloom life can start anew
And there'll be no crying soon

Those Who Are Left Behind
by TJB Cameron
Time marches forward, stopping for no one 
Every second that passes echoes the splinters in our hearts 
We put on a brave face and play this game called life 

Yet no matter how much we try we do not win 
Our pain and loss forever scarred upon our souls 
Every moment of joy is made bittersweet by your absences 

We struggle through the remainder of life 
Holding onto our memories that are all we have 
Determined never to forget our loved ones. 

    Love rebounds after life has long past,
  For it's tied within the soul, forever to last
   True love has not, a final goodbye 
 It lives forever, never will it die.

Viviennemary Wed 28-Nov-12 22:11:30

There is no point in going over and over this and blaming yourself. I have two friends whose cats have been run over in the last few months. It's just dreadful but no-one's fault. And there is rarely anything even a vet can do when the cat is badly injured. Please don't worry about it although I know it's hard.

WeezyPeezy Wed 28-Nov-12 22:06:58

Oh Zoo, I'm so sorry for your loss. Like the others have said it sounds like internal bleeding and you could have done nothing but torture yourself more, by feeling helpless, if you'd found her at the time, It really does sound like her passing was quick. I sat with a stranger's kitty by the side if the road once, just stroking him till he passed and waiting for the RSPCA ambulance as a last resort. It was very peaceful and he at no time seemed in pain, just like I'm sure your girl wasn't. The wee darling had probably long gone when you shouted on her. Please comfort yourself with the fact that you cared enough to go looking and that you chipped her as a precaution. Sending love. Xxx

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 22:04:38

I am not religious either, but that is a good quote.

ILoveSparklers Wed 28-Nov-12 21:56:44

It gets easier... As with everything in life... I'm not religious but I like this quote -
"God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
The courage to change the things I can,
And the wisdom to know the difference."

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 21:55:14

Yes, we have heard a noise several times which sounds just like her starting to come through the cat flap. And in a similar vein, the day before my cat died I had been talking to someone saying that at a time when we were considering relocation overseas I had thought I would have to rehome my cat in the UK as she travels terribly and the journey 'would have killed her'. Horrible irony now.

I spent a lot of time out calling her the night she disappeared and morning after and I do hate that she was lying there all that time, I just hadn't seen her.

mignonette Wed 28-Nov-12 21:47:25


I have similar fantasies about Thomas just appearing in the window one morning because he had to run away after killing the neighbours similar black and white cat in a fight.....Silly, I know.

I keep hearing noises in the house at night that my imagination tells me is my cat jumping on and off furniture....

I posted some pics of Thomas on another thread the day that he went missing. Cannot believe the irony of showing off my beautiful cat on MN on the day he died, not knowing that by that time, he may well have died.

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 21:45:44

3 ... that really is very young. Mine was 10 which felt young enough as she was still very lively and not at all 'senior' despite liking the senior cat food. 3 is not much more than a kitten.

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 21:44:27

The 'like' button not the snow pictures that is.

ILoveSparklers Wed 28-Nov-12 21:44:17

I think it's difficult when they are young and had so much life to live...only 3.

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 21:43:54

Me too.

ILoveSparklers Wed 28-Nov-12 21:43:22

We have a couple of pics of him running in the snow last them Jo on the kitchen so I get to see him every morning when I go downstairs smile

ILoveSparklers Wed 28-Nov-12 21:41:40

smile, sometimes wish there was a "like" button on this forum.

Zoonose Wed 28-Nov-12 21:41:39

We have been through all our photos on the computer over most of the last 10 years and extracted every one where she features, even where she's just in the background while the photo was of something else. I am going to montage them to make one big picture, so in a way I can see all of her life with us all at once. Yet at the same time I can't believe I am having to do that and would give anything to have her back. It has even crossed my mind 'what if it wasn't her and I made a mistake and she'll just turn up again?' ... although I know it was.

I really sympathise with everyone here. Although it is so sad to hear of all these losses there is some small comfort in knowing we aren't alone.

I had had the same ideas too ILoveSparklers about the children growing up with our cat around. They loved waving a shoelace for her to catch.

mignonette Wed 28-Nov-12 21:36:01

Not silly. Definitely not. I have left Thomas's catnip mouse by the kitchen skirting board along with a rolled up piece of paper that we used to use to prop up the wonky kitchen table leg. He was batting that across the floor the morning he died.....

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now