Advanced search

Medium cost dry food - any recommendations?

(30 Posts)
lainiekazan Wed 05-Feb-14 09:50:36

Golden retriever, 10 months, hates Royal Canin, detests James Wellbeloved, indifferent about Hills Science Plan. Not very enthusiastic about Pets At Home premium stuff.

He loves human food (of course) but a dog cannot live by toast and luncheon meat (bleeuggh) alone. I absolutely do not want to go down the raw or cooked meat route.

I have read all the online guides, but wonder if anyone has a personal recommendation of something.

fishybits Wed 05-Feb-14 09:55:58

We're trialling Harringtons 20 pounds for 15kg as Arden Grange has become too expensive. I add hot water and DD's leftover supper each night so keep this interesting.

So far I've noticed that the dogs are calmer, coats are still soft and shiny, stools larger but still firm and smellier breath. Not all good news but not too bad either.

Floralnomad Wed 05-Feb-14 10:18:58

Try Barking Heads ,my fairly fussy boy loves it ,particularly the lamb variety . It's reasonably priced and TBH you need to feed less than recommended IMO.

Waitingforflo Wed 05-Feb-14 10:20:38

CSJ have lots of varieties - starts at about £15 for large bag and goes up depending on what you want. Great for allergies, sensitivities, weight gain/loss, etc.

Needadvice5 Wed 05-Feb-14 10:23:01

We feed our 7 month old Dalmatians on Collards from kennelgate, although I do mix a few leftovers/bit of tinned in to make it more exciting!

tabulahrasa Wed 05-Feb-14 10:24:48

The only food mine seemed to actually like is Orijen, which is not at all medium priced, lol.

Does he like fish? Pets at home do a pretty good quality, reasonably priced fish one, fishmongers I think it's called?

MrsPnut Wed 05-Feb-14 10:29:51

We moved our dog onto the Chappie dry food and she wasn't so keen at first but will now eat it eventually.

She would much rather be having pedigree chum pouches, or whatever we're eating but her digestive system is very sensitive.
We buy it in big sacks from the range, and it's one of the cheaper brands but has no cereals in it. Her coat is beautifully glossy and she has bags of energy despite being an old lady.

pollyglen Wed 05-Feb-14 10:37:08

Harringtons is loved by my two dogs.Smelly wind problem eradicated,poo's now firm less smelly and easy to pick up.Wouldn't even consider any other brand now.

Goldencity1 Wed 05-Feb-14 10:40:09

Another fussy Goldie! Glad I've not got the only one...
My 7 month pup hates Arden Grange, collards, James Wellbeloved plus another one that looks the same [boring brown pellets] which I can'i remember the name of!
She also gets an upset tum quite easily - [had a thread about her revolting poo!] so it has been hard to find one she will eat that won't upset her.

We have settled on Skinners ruff and ready - it has lots of dff textures and shapes and seems to be coated in something sticky - this she will eat, especially with a bit of warm water on it.

Her tum is better too, as long as I stop MIL feeding her horrible cheap dog treats!

lainiekazan Wed 05-Feb-14 11:39:29

Yes, dog's poos are a bit... squishy. And as for the wind - sometimes we all sit watching the television with jumpers/t-shirts over our noses and mouths as dog snores peacefully with his legs in the air smile .

I think that at the end of the day most dogs do not like dry food. I can't imagine eating a bowl of cornflakes/muesli with no milk on. I tried putting some warm water on the dry food but dog walked off in disgust and wouldn't touch it.

Whoknowswhocares Wed 05-Feb-14 11:51:58

I feed my Goldie wainwrights dry food with a small amount of the wainwrights wet tray stuff as a topper and a bit of warm water.
Despite starting off life with a very sensitive stomach, she is fit, healthy, firm pooed and fart free grin. She loves it too fortunately.
As an extra I use Feelwells puppy training treats daily for their probiotic benefits, which may possibly make a difference

lainiekazan Wed 05-Feb-14 11:55:36

Thanks for ideas.

Goldencity1 - I looked at your "poo" thread. I know people who have spent a fortune to discover their dog is allergic to this, that or the other. I asked the vet and she said as long as dog is healthy and bouncy then soft (not runny) poo may just be them.

WeAllHaveWings Wed 05-Feb-14 19:19:03

golden the sticky stuff in you skinners ruff and ready is likely to be the glucose aka sugar.

laine we switched our lab onto millies wolfheart a couple months ago and went from sloppy poos and smelly wind to little firm poos And fresh air within a week.

Good quality protein and grain free, a bag lasts a while as you don't feed much. They also do a great range of natural chews/treats.

needastrongone Wed 05-Feb-14 21:05:09

I am trying Millie's too, just waiting for the last of the previous stuff to run out. We do kibble am then raw pm, which seems to work for us. Millie's is £10 per bag cheaper, made in England, grain free etc

SecretSix Wed 05-Feb-14 21:25:45

We use Gilpa Kennel & Senior Light.

SixDog seems very happy with it, coat is in lovely condition which I think is the fish in the Senior. I put a bit of water in it but feed straightaway so it's damp rather than soaked. Poo is generally firm unless he's eaten crap on the park

DIddled Wed 05-Feb-14 21:29:45

Ardern grange- been using it for years.

WeAllHaveWings Wed 05-Feb-14 21:34:09

needastrongone are you in their facebook group, the owners June and mark are brilliant with their customer support!

sweetkitty Wed 05-Feb-14 21:34:12

Another vote for Millie's Wolfheart changed my 6 month old ridgeback over from Burns 2 weeks ago, she wolfs it down whereas Burns could be left in her bowl for a while, grain free, named meats all good stuff voted second best in the UK by

A 14.5kg bag is £50 but as it's so good you feed less, free delivery too and great customer service, actually spoke to the owner for ages about food and dogs grin

lainiekazan Thu 06-Feb-14 12:00:46

Just bought a small bag of Skinners. If dog turns his nose up at that I'll try Millie's Wolfheart next.

Honestly. Why will dog gulp down a slipper, foam interior and all, but spurn perfectly good food?

Isthatwhatdemonsdo Thu 06-Feb-14 13:30:52

Our Goldie is a fussy bugger too. Had him on our own brand dry food since he was a puppy loved it for a few months then turned his nose up. Went off James Wellbeloved after a couple of months so now I'm feeding him Burns.
He's still a bit picky but eats it in the end. I'm not changing to another brand again.

Rikalaily Thu 06-Feb-14 13:34:22

Wainwrites, our boy has the wet and dry

DaddysBigTummy Thu 06-Feb-14 19:26:30

Another vote for Millie's Wolfheart, my lab puppy eats this. Riverside Mix I think.

intheround Thu 06-Feb-14 19:31:19

I use Beta Pet Maintenance.

needastrongone Thu 06-Feb-14 20:07:37

weallhavewings - I didn't know that there was a Facebook page, but I have joined! Gave both the dog and the pup some Millie's for treats today, vamoosh!

Anyone who have founders called June and Mark get my vote smile

CMOTDibbler Thu 06-Feb-14 20:16:43

Ours is on Burns atm, but we also use Oscars. He needs grain free, no turkey. The difference in his poo on the right food is amazing

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now