Rose,Martha or Donna ?

[MargaretMountford]

Martha here,with Rose a close second

[fym]

can we add captain Jack into this too???

[MargaretMountford]

um, no..you can do a boys one afterwards !

[ellceeell]

Martha, but with Rose and Donna surprisingly close - Donna is better than I expected!

[fym]

aww - I like Captain Jack [pouty emoicon]

but if pressed - Donna, Rose, Martha....

[MargaretMountford]

am undecided about Donna still

[zippitippitoes]

actually donna is quite fun

[MargaretMountford]

I love Captain Jack but this is girl thread fym !!

[CrackerOfNuts]

Rose

Still haven't warmed to Martha properly, and can't stand Donna.

[zippitippitoes]

lol i thought you were talking about kids names

i dont watch tv

[MargaretMountford]

I have to say I really liked Rose when she was with Christopher Eccleston - and I love him though I suspect that David Tennent makes the best doctor

[MargaretMountford]

zippi ! and there was I thinking that Donna was gaining popularityas the series went on !!

[belgo]

I was going to say Martha then realised it's about Dr Who.

I've only seen a couple of episodes of this serious so far, but I've been very impressed with Donna. Loved her furry coat in the Ood episode.

[girlfrommars]

Martha, Rose, the rest of the female population, Donna.

[DoubleBluff]

I like Donna but sh ekeeps slipping into 'Gran' and that 'me gay no sir' character!
Really liked martha. What happened to herat the end of the last series can't understand why she didn't come back?

[MargaretMountford]

If it was a names thing then I'd pick Martha too !!!

[belgo]

Martha was in a couple of Torchwood episodes. She was quite good.

[TwoIfBySea]

Donna, she is a better match and the fact there is no romantic lead going on makes it much more interesting to watch. (Does it help that I didn't watch Catherine Tate's show?)

Then Martha.

Then Rose who was a bit too smug.

[fannysparkle]

Well i loved the catherine tate show and i think Donna is Fab. I like that i see some of her characters, she is really dry and funny!

[sphil]

Donna, Rose, Martha

Thought Martha's acting was pretty wooden at times and was shown up dreadfully by DT, Jessica Stevenson, Derek Jacobi, John Simm...

[EruvandeAini]

Rose, because I just adored the way the relationship built up through 9 and 10. Then Donna, because I'm really enjoying the different dynamic and I like her as a character. Then Martha. I do like her, but I felt they did her no favours at all by sticking the unrequited love thing on her. She could have been a great character, but the love storyline was always doomed, because Rose/Doctor took time to grow, and it was just no comparison.

But I'm liking evilMartha a lot

[goblinvalley]

Rose, Donna, Martha

[YouWillBeDeleted]

Rose, Donna then Martha. Donna has been better than expected to me.

[RustyBear]

EruvandeAine, in another reality, Martha's love might not have been totally unrequited?

[paddingtonbear1]

I liked Rose the best. Donna is growing on me though, so I'd put her next.

[MrsWeasley]

I couldn't stand Donna at first but she is growing on me. I liked the other too equally, although I only watch to keep the kids company and for a look at capt Jack