Advanced search

The Living and the Dead ending: SPOILER ALERT

(10 Posts)
chough Tue 02-Aug-16 13:48:08

Watched this series on i player, but the last episode's only on TV tonight, hence my spoiler warning.
I couldn't fathom the ending: did Nathan and his wife kill themselves or not? And what was all that with the car being found in the past?
Apologise if I'm just daft, but I couldn't get to grips with this ending at all.

WalkThePlanky Tue 02-Aug-16 17:19:05

Ooh. I've just been searching the net too. Not altogether sure. But this what I think happened:

There is some kind of link between Nathan who is grieving his son and Lara who is grieving her mother that draws them to the house and Gabriel links them together. So their fates are entwined.

When Lara is driving with the baby she sees the ghost of Nathan and that causes her to crash her car and she dies and then becomes a ghost in the house. But she doesn't realise what she's done until Gabriel tells her.

In a parallel timeline she tries to stop Nathan committing suicide and bursts in on him in the kitchen - only adding to his madness. When it seems he is about to top himself and Charlotte tries to join in. Perhaps they succeed? Although it seems as though they stop in the house - maybe they don't. And Nathan doesn't realise what he's done.

Lara dies first and Nathan finds the baby (according to Gabriel) and those scenes of the three of them happy are actually Lara's baby and not Nathan and Charlottes baby.

Lara's car falls down a deep hole. But the hole was not there in Nathan's time until Charlotte digs up the car. That creates the hole Lara drowns in.

But what is not clear is:
Why is there not a scene where Lara's (very quiet) baby is not rescued?
Why is the car grown over so quickly? ie the Lara - Garbriel grief the reason for all the unrest on the estate? Why is it not more obvious?
Ie the Maud character seemed destined to die. Why her?

chough Tue 02-Aug-16 18:02:10

WalkThePlanky, your suggestions make sense, but , as you say, it's still not all clear.

Clawdy Tue 02-Aug-16 22:04:53

I assumed the reference was to Nathan's first wife. We know very little about her, and I think that was meant to be a twist in the story, possibly leading to a second series.

Clawdy Tue 02-Aug-16 22:06:49

And Gabriel meant that Lara 's husband found the baby, not Nathan.

Memoires Tue 02-Aug-16 22:35:36

That's what I thought, Clawdy.

Lara was Nathaniel and Charlotte's great great however many times granddaughter. Her own gran told her that when she handed over the suitcase in the hospital. I've no idea whether the grief Lara felt for her own mother (who had killed herself when Lara was 3m old after being haunted by the same boy) had any part in the hauntings or strange happenings, but I would imagine that the direct relationship was more relevant.

DesolateWaist Tue 02-Aug-16 23:06:26

Nathan and Charlotte didn't kill themselves.
Charlotte had the baby as the baby was the grandmother of the Red Coat Woman's grandmother.

DesolateWaist Tue 02-Aug-16 23:10:41

My question is though how the car being found wouldn't completely fuck with everything.
It's as if an alien space ship landed in our time.
The finding would be noted in the newspapers of the time and I would think that science types would be turning up to look at it.

BaconAndAvocado Tue 02-Aug-16 23:18:07

It was all very very strange but I absolutely loved it, especially the scene where them farm workers dig up the car. Brilliantly surreal.

Do we know if there's a series 2?

Memoires Tue 02-Aug-16 23:31:27

Maybe they do, Desolate.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now