Advertisement

loader

Talk

Advanced search

Outlander. wtf?

(135 Posts)
SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 01:12:10

Just started watching Outlander and I am wondering if they could have made it any more inaccurate.

Ok so picking up on things like referring to Inverness as a city in the 1940s is maybe a bit picky (it didn't become a city until very recently).

But the constant references to the redcoats as the 'English'. FFS. Surely if they had done even a teeny tiny amount of research they would know it wasn't Scots v the English!?!

The Highland Gaels who speak both Gaelic and English.

Or I am too early in and all the inaccuracies turn out to be because it's all on her head?

Anyone else wants to pick holes? Or to try to convince me it is worth sticking with?

TrollTheRespawnJeremy Mon 04-Jan-16 01:17:33

It's very entertaining and the men in kilts can be quite braw.

Tis fiction though so plenty of historical inaccuracies

WiIdfire Mon 04-Jan-16 01:18:44

It's fiction, not historical documentary. I really don't think looking for inaccuracies is going to go well in a drama based on a premise of time travel??? The Loch Ness Monster even makes an appearance (in the book at least) and that's hardly accurate, is it?

Yes it's not perfect, but it's still my favourite series of books. Stick with it, don't overthink it, and definitely read the books which are even better than the TV series. I for one have found it has sparked an interest in me in Scottish history, even if the book details aren't perfect.

Seriously, it's a great story.

WiIdfire Mon 04-Jan-16 01:23:11

'They' by the way is Diana Gabaldon, the author, and she's American so is starting from no local knowledge whatsoever. She wrote the first book as a 'practice' novel, before she started on the real thing, only it was so popular that she never got the real thing but has instead published 8 more books in the series and several side stories. I don't think she was too worried at the time about the finer points.

SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 01:31:58

I am trying to go with it but it does jar a bit when its not just a case of the wrong tartanwink but actually the wrong protagonists in a civil war.

Explains a lot that it was written by an American (such as not knowing Scotland has always and will always be part of Great Britain).

She'd have been better going down the GOT route and making somewhen up. Then no one can complaingrin

FannyFifer Mon 04-Jan-16 01:34:35

Jamie is a total ride though eh.

Redglitter Mon 04-Jan-16 01:36:46

Just go with the story as it is. It's a great series but not a patch on the books

TrollTheRespawnJeremy Mon 04-Jan-16 01:47:02

Fannyfifer. He is solely to blame for my current kilt fetish

Sunnymeg Mon 04-Jan-16 13:45:21

Treat it as an American's view of Scotland and you'll be OK.

GraceKellysLeftArm Mon 04-Jan-16 13:47:19

I've ridden a couple of horses (not Jamie) in it.

FannyFifer Mon 04-Jan-16 14:49:26

They are filming for season 2 up the road fae me this month. I am totally going up for a perv look. wink

SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 15:19:29

Lol. I was playing spot the locations (not Inverness that's for sure).

I shall see how I fare with another episode later.

Twinklestein Mon 04-Jan-16 16:21:25

Who watches fantasy fiction like this for accuracy? shock

Was the clue not in the fact that Claire went back in time through some standing stones?? And that mad Jack (whatever his name) is her husband?

It's absolute nonsense, however Jamie is uberfit and men look great in kilts.

SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 17:50:38

The mistaken belief that the Jacobite rebellion was a war between the Scots and English is a particular bugbear of mine being as it is the cause of much nationalism and some racism in the North of Scotland. The '45, the Clearances and the diaspora are all sad chapters in Highland history but not the fault of the English. made all the more rancorous growing up the subject of much anti-Catholic hatred at the hands of Protestant classmates who still somehow managed to be pro-Jacobite due to a complete misinterpretation of their own history.confusedhmm

But surely, fantasy though it is, if you go to the trouble of setting something in a recognisable historical period you do at least a teeny bit of research. Or else just set it entirely in a fantasy era a la GOT.

Yes, she is American so can almost be excused but half the people who worked on that are Scots and so you'd have assumed one of them might have said something!?!

Men in kilts don't entirely make up for it as I see those relatively regularly anyway.wink

The standing stones thing though - that happens all the time surely? Does to me.

Piffpaffpoff Mon 04-Jan-16 18:23:25

I saw them last month when they were filming near me FannyFifer, they film all around here and just across the bridge too (from your name, I'm guessing you are in the same neck if the woods as me).

cardoon Mon 04-Jan-16 19:13:59

Tell me exactly where and when........grin

cardoon Mon 04-Jan-16 19:14:44

That was to fanny and piff

NigellaEllaElla Mon 04-Jan-16 19:16:55

Who knew a kilt could look so good?! Never found those a turn on before wink

I'm a HUGE fan of Outlander. Cannot wait for it to be back.

FannyFifer Mon 04-Jan-16 20:22:39

PPP, filming in Falkland very soon again. Was exciting when they were filming in Dysart last year as well. grin

FrostyNipples Mon 04-Jan-16 20:26:48

Jamie... phwoar.

That is all.

SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 20:28:59

Falkland! I knew that was familiar.

jollyjester Mon 04-Jan-16 20:30:37

Don't allow the lack of historical accuracy put you off it.

It's very entertaining. Wait until the end of the season, some of the most emotional scenes I've ever watched.

Any of those living near filming got a spare room?! Ill swap you a spare room near game of thrones filming!

SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 20:33:53

Oh yes. Man in kilt.

Maybe not

SmallLegsOrSmallEggs Mon 04-Jan-16 20:34:38

^ that incidentally seeing as I am being nitpicky is not the way to wear one.

FrostyNipples Mon 04-Jan-16 20:35:16

Fussy bugger I would grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now